FREE NEWSLETTER

Articles › Investing

Waiting It Out

THOSE WHO REGULARLY read posts on Bogleheads.org—and I’m guessing a good chunk of HumbleDollar readers do—know that the Bogleheads’ philosophy is to:

  • Never time the markets.
  • Buy only broad-market index funds via either mutual funds or exchange-traded funds.
  • Invest 25% to 75% of a portfolio in stocks using such funds, with the rest in bonds, and thereafter rebalance as needed. How big a percentage should you put in stocks? That’s based on risk tolerance. The allocation should be the one that allows you to sleep at night.

The Bogleheads forum is built around the investment philosophy of the late John Bogle, Vanguard Group’s founder who launched the first index mutual fund in 1976. The strategy is simple and brilliant, and has been shown to outperform almost all active fund managers over the past several decades.

All that said, I’m going to admit that I haven’t stayed true to the Bogleheads approach for the past few years. When interest rates began to rise in early 2022, I started paring back my stock and bond investments.

Once Treasury bills and certificates of deposit began approaching, and sometimes exceeding, a 5% yield, I put almost all our portfolio into money market funds and, as of this writing, almost all that money remains there. My thinking is that getting that kind of yield essentially risk-free is good enough.

What’s more, and probably most important, my wife and I are almost 68 years old, fairly early in our retirement, and I don’t want our portfolio to take a double-digit hit in the event of a severe market correction. A Boglehead would call this sequence-of-return risk.

The simple fact is, I feel that stocks, particularly in the U.S., are overvalued, and I’m happy to wait for what I believe is an inevitable major market correction. Whether that happens in six months or six years, I plan to stay mostly in cash until then. I don’t feel the current risk is worth the reward.

Of course, this goes completely against Bogleheads thinking, and I won’t be surprised if I’m proven wrong and miss out on more market gains. Still, I believe that keeping large sums in stock markets that set all-time highs virtually every day, even as interest rates can provide a strong, risk-free return, isn’t a good idea.

It’s obvious that I’m violating point No. 1 above. I am indeed timing the market. But I do feel that the Achilles’ heel of the Bogleheads philosophy is the belief that stocks always come back in a reasonable period of time after a correction.

Recent U.S. market history supports this belief. Markets needed only two years to recover from the 1987 Black Monday crash, six years to recover from the dot-com bubble and five years to recover from the 2008 financial crisis. In fact, the recovery from the COVID-19 crash took a mere six months.

All that said, am I willing to base our financial future on statistics from the past? Nope.

Elsewhere in the world, it has been known to take a while—a long while—for markets to recover. It took Japan’s Nikkei index an astounding 34 years to surpass its 1989 record high, a feat achieved earlier this year. If that arc were to occur now with U.S. stocks, the recovery wouldn’t be complete until I turn age 102. At that point, the wait would be over—and, almost certainly, so would I.

Tony Wilson spent most of his career working as a journalist and then newsroom technology trainer at news organizations in Kentucky, Kansas City, New York City, London and Geneva. He finished his career as the translations planner at printer manufacturer Lexmark. Tony’s previous articles were Fearing Nothing and Happy to Follow.

Want to receive our weekly newsletter? Sign up now. How about our daily alert about the site's latest posts? Join the list.

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
44 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Kevin Lynch
2 years ago

A quote for you from Dale Carnegie, “A man convinced against his will is of the same option still.”

As a Boglehead, I certainly identify with your article’s premise. And like you, I made the decision to diversify my portfolio, by taking a significant sum “out of the market.”
In June 2023 I purchased 4 Fixed Indexed Annuities, with Income Riders. One I was from my wife’s Roth Account and the other three from my Roth Account.

Your “investments” are earning an interest rate. My annuities are not benefitting directly from interest earnings, rather, they are growing by a guaranteed fixed rate of 8.25%, in the Income Account of each annuity. In other words, for each year I delay taking income, my income account balance, from where future guaranteed income stream will originate, the income account to grow by 8.25%.

And like your strategy, many will argue that you are timing the market, or missing out on the market’s recovery, or you locked in your losses, etc., etc. The truth is you made decision to accept a reasonable rate for your investments and remove them from the risk of being in the market. Key words here..YOU and YOUR.

I think am 5 years older than you presently, as I am 73, and like you, I do not choose to take the chance that the next down turn will have a 2022 6 month quick recovery vs, the 5 year recovery of 2008. I simply choose not to participate, with those funds “moved off the table,” and invested in guaranteed income streams.

Now, I still have a considerable balance in the Market, and those funds are fully invested in equities…Vanguard’s VTI and VXUS. They represent my equities and my annuities represent my fixed income portion of my portfolio. I simply substituted one form of fixed income, Annuities, for the traditional form, Bonds.

Add to that my 67 months of cash, and that is my answer to all the various financial risks of retirement.

I enjoyed your article, as it gave me the opportunity to rethink and reaffirm my strategy. Thanks!

Andy Morrison
2 years ago

Tony,
Like it has been stated, one of the Boglehead tenets is setting an asset allocation that allows one to sleep at night…and of course, an investor is allowed to change their allocation if they feel compelled.

Corrections (~10%), bear markets (~20%), crashes (yikes)… We don’t like any of those :(, but they are the price of doing business.

I’m curious what magnitude of correction you are looking for to “get back into the market.” Recent down draft examples – S&P 500 down ~25% (~3600 from 4800), NASDAQ down~37% (10K from 16k). Obviously, those occurred while you were going to cash, but now what? Just curious if you have determined what magnitude of pullback and what index (or indices) will give you “the sign.” Thanks.

mike schellenberger
2 years ago