FREE NEWSLETTER

Which aspect of the tax code do you hate the most?

Go to main Forum page »

AUTHOR: Jonathan Clements on 4/12/2021
Subscribe
Notify of
29 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Michael Hennessy
1 year ago

It’s not really a “tax” issue per se, but what irritates me most is the IRMAA surcharge on Medicare premiums. It drives me nuts every year trying to stay short of the triggering limits. Here’s what Harry Sit says about it on his site–The Finance Buff: “In the grand scheme, when a couple on Medicare has over $194,000 in income, they’re already paying a large amount in taxes. Does making them pay another $1,600 make that much difference? It’s less than 1% of their income but nickel-and-diming just makes people mad. People caught by surprise when their income crosses over to a higher bracket by just a small amount are angry at the government. Rolling it all into the income tax would be much more effective.”

Martin McCue
1 year ago

The alternative minimum tax. My taxes are complicated, so I always build a spreadsheet for myself, and I’ve found the AMT processes on paper are not intuitive and have little to do with normal logic. The calculation is just a mind-numbing series of steps involving seemingly random lines of the form. (The capital gains Schedule is not far behind.)

However, the one conclusion I did come to is that if we ever move to a flat tax, it is probably the skeleton of the AMT form that would work best.

mjflack
1 year ago

The Foreign Tax Credit. If you paid less than $600 in foreign taxes you simply deduct the amount of foreign taxes you paid from your Tax owed. If you paid more than $600 than you you may very well deduct much less than $600 from your Tax owed.

Kurt Yokum
2 years ago

Getting taxed on mutual fund distributions that produces a net gain of zero to my holdings once the NAV is decremented by the distribution. All logical and legal, but it feels criminal to a shareholder.

Kevin Rees
2 years ago

IRMAA. It’s not a “tax”, it’s a “surcharge”.

That makes it feel so much better…

Philip Stein
2 years ago

I’m annoyed by the requirement to value your IRA as of December 31 of the previous year to determine the amount of your Required Minimum Distribution in the current year.

December is often a good month for the stock market. If the market ends the year in an upswing, you’re stuck with an RMD that is likely higher than it ought to be.

I’d like to have the choice of valuing my IRA portfolio as of March 31, June 30, September 30, or December 31 — and given the option to pick the lowest number to calculate my RMD.

AJ
2 years ago

I hate that Americans are still required to fill out their own tax returns from scratch (or pay a 3rd party for the service) when the IRS already has enough data from income/tax reporting requirements to generate a simple tax return for many citizens. This basic form could be pre-filled by the IRS and sent to each taxpayer for review, allowing the opportunity for amendments and documentation to be submitted for any unreported/delayed changes that might affect the tax outcome (e.g. tax-deductible IRA contributions made after the tax year but before the filing deadline).

Ben Rodriguez
1 year ago
Reply to  AJ

This reminds me of a hilarious comedy bit that went something like:
Taxpayer to IRS: Well, do you know how much I owe?
IRS: We know exactly how much you owe.
Taxpayer: Will you tell me?
IRS: No, we want you to tell us.
Taxpayer: What happens if I get the amount wrong?
IRS: You go to jail.

Glenn Hyde
2 years ago

form 8938 report of foreign bank accounts – especially having to report joint accounts because my wife is American and is the second holder on some of our accounts. I am Canadian and feel like this is an unwelcome invasion of my privacy. Also Fincen 114 is no party either

Nick Politakis
2 years ago

I hate the fact that so much of the dealing with the IRS is with paper. I would welcome online filing only and an IRS online account for communications and responses.

John Wood
2 years ago

The Carried Interest rule. We all pay income tax rates on our earned income, while the Hedge Fund crowd pays capital gains rates on theirs (and they get the cap gains rate, even though they’re risking their clients money, not their own). Then, despite all of the rhetoric from the politicians, the Carried Interest rule survives every “tax reform” effort, while the Hedge Fund crowd stuffs the pockets of those same politicians. Crony Capitalism at its worst.

Steve Abney
2 years ago
  • Multiple education credits. Let’s have one.
  • Multiple types of retirement account, each with different rules. Let’s have one set of rules (can you use it without penalty for a first house? yes for IRA, no for 401k)
  • Multiple definitions of “child”
  • Capital taxed at a lower rate than labor.
corrupt
2 years ago
Reply to  Steve Abney

There are reasons to tax capital (long term) at a different rate than labor. First of all, LTCG is subject to the effects of inflation, while wages aren’t. Secondly, LTCG encourages long term holding and outlook, which is better than immediate payoff for multiple reasons (employment, capital investment, the environment, etc), in addition to reducing market froth and wide gains and losses in a short period.

Arpe Gio
3 years ago

The convoluted and opaque parts that must be taken on faith that they are right. For example, in navigating TurboTax Premier I often find a confusing lack of explanations, and using it is supposed to make it easy.

Harold Tynes
3 years ago

The complexity of the tax code coupled with the underfunding/understaffing of the IRS creates a perfect storm of frustration. With all the added legislation that flowed through the IRS, they are so far behind that my June 2020 amended return with a refund was paid this month. When I called them in Jan. they had not opened the envelope. I deal with the IRS more with businesses I am involved with. I’ve waited on the phone for hours to find I have reached the wrong group. Also the lack of technology is astounding. Can’t email the IRS (part of the Treasury Dept). However, I can email the TTB (part of Treasury Dept).

Bob Wilmes
3 years ago

Foreign stock dividends and foreign stock taxes. I used to have several investments in foreign stocks that often did not have US traded ADR’s. Some companies like LVMH withdrew their US ADRs because of the US tax complexity. It required so much time and trouble to track these investments and their dividends (which were paid in various foreign currencies to my US brokerage account) that I eventually sold them all and bought the Vanguard total international market funds.

Mike Zaccardi
3 years ago

Retirement contribution limits. Too many accounts with too many rules.

How about this – 1 account with 1 limit? Just an overall $60k/yr (or whatever) limit to a combo of tax-deferred or after-tax (Roth) contributions. Withdraw starting at age 60 (59.5??) with no penalty. No RMDs. QCD whenever.

CJ
3 years ago

The completely unfair double taxation on social security, just because I earn my living as a freelancer rather than as a company’s employee. Ridiculous and needlessly punitive. We’re uber drivers, food delivery folks, web designers – we’re eking out a living here – yet paying DOUBLE social security. I don’t understand how this still continues.

Now that I’m done ranting, I guess that’s not a taxation thing…it’s more of a legislative/program policy – but it hurts every tax season.

Last edited 3 years ago by CJ
Scrooge_McDuck88
3 years ago

Clearly the check writing part!

Rick Connor
3 years ago

The complicated interactions of different taxes. For example, an extra dollar of income can exceed a limit, and bring a dollar of social security into taxable income. The effective tax rate on that one dollar of income can be twice the marginal rate. It’s hard to keep track of all these.

Chazooo
3 years ago
Reply to  Rick Connor

Is that not the point of it? Isn’t there something like 23,000 pages of US Tax Code and therefore no “right answer”?

R Quinn
3 years ago

RMDs and taxing 401k investment growth as ordinary income.

Sonja Haggert
3 years ago

The major changes to the recent tax code involving charitable contributions and investment expenses. The difficulty in taking charitable deductions, along with the pandemic, has had a devastating effect on charities.

Ben Rodriguez
3 years ago

Capital gains taxes tax growth on investments including from inflation, which is often caused by the very government levying the tax. It’s good to be King.

Last edited 3 years ago by Ben Rodriguez
John Goodell
3 years ago

Wash sales are needlessly punitive. If you sell anything at a loss, but your dividends are inadvertently reinvested through a DRIP program within 30 days of the sale, you lose the ability to count that loss against your gains.

Scrooge_McDuck88
3 years ago
Reply to  John Goodell

Didn’t know that! That’s a stinger!

Andrew F.
3 years ago

AMT—the Alternative Minimum Tax. It induces a small migraine every time. The kicker is that, as per the instructions, I’m often told I have to fill it out and then, after jumping through all the hoops, it tells me I don’t have to pay it anyway!

Chazooo
3 years ago
Reply to  Andrew F.

The tax accountant’s dream legislation.

Free Newsletter

SHARE