Most of us like to be in control. I certainly do. But what about controlling how our heirs use the money we bequeath?
That’s a question I’ve had to face. I’m hoping both of my 30-something children will use my bequest to bolster their long-term financial future, adding the money to their portfolio and perhaps using a portion to buy new homes.
Both have good financial habits, and the money they’ll receive could—if used sensibly—mean they’ll be far wealthier in their 60s than I am. But, of course, there are no guarantees. Perhaps their spouses will argue for using the money in other ways. Perhaps they’ll commit some major financial blunder. Perhaps the money will make them the target of some scam.
Meanwhile, because I’m remarried, I could have used a trust arrangement to leave money to my wife Elaine, and then have what remains pass to my two children upon her death. But I didn’t go that route. Instead, I’ve asked Elaine to leave at least part of what I give her to the kids. She’s promised she will, and I totally trust that she’ll do so. But I can also imagine scenarios where it won’t happen. What if she gets hit with, say, huge long-term-care expenses?
As the joke goes, it’s tough to make predictions, especially about the future. But that’s also why I’m not inclined to bequeath the money with any strings attached. Besides the cost of complicated trust arrangements, what if Elaine or my two kids get hit with a large and urgent financial need? I’d rather not tie their hands.
I’ve told Elaine and the kids what they can expect from my estate. I’ve made it clear I don’t want any quibbling over my will, my beneficiary designations, the division of my possessions and my funeral arrangements. As detailed in the recent posts from Dana Ferris and Marjorie Kondrack, as well as the comments those posts triggered, such fights can cause hefty emotional damage, and I’d be appalled if anything like that happened after my death. But I also believe the best course of action is to clearly express my wishes, and then trust that they’ll be respected.
This and the thread about family estrangement are dancing around the same truth, which is that we have no control. Not over other people, even our beloved kids and relatives; and not over the unfolding of life. Good estate planning (for estates) and good communication (for family matters) can influence the direction things will go, but are far from guarantees. With apologies for ratcheting up the altltude of discourse, one could argue that learning this truth is the the task of life.
This reality fuels my gratitude for the many wonderful – and often evanescent – people and moments in my life.
I have two children. Both are fine individuals, and they get along well with one another. One is married with three children. One is single. That doesn’t matter. I have had “adult” relationships with them for years – we have conversations as equals, and I’ve tried to treat them as equals since they could walk. All I care about is that they know I love them. It is up to them what they feel they should do with what I leave them. I won’t be around.
Someone once said passing on things of value with a warm hand is better than a cold one… I’ve been guided by that now over the years and more so now that I’ve been diagnosed with stage 4 prostate cancer. I feel good that my daughters who are now both professionals, will make good decisions, and frankly any financial wisdom I have was earned the hard way, by making bone headed mistakes, which I’m sure they will too. Cheers.
Jonathan,
Of course there’s no way I can be certain, but I believe Elaine and your kids will handle the money according to your wishes. All of the steps you have taken since the diagnosis will help immensely.
You’re in our thoughts as if you are family.
Dan and Chrissy
The first time we prepared estate planning documents, our four children were about 5 to 15 years old. The lawyer gave the standard advice that if one of us were to die, that person’s half of our estate go into an irrevocable trust to ultimately be split among our children. That way the surviving spouse could not leave everything to a new spouse.
We wanted everything left to the surviving spouse with no strings apptached. I explained to the lawyer that we truste