Sometimes things go your way, and sometimes they don’t. Some of the best things in my life have come through good timing or circumstances I had little to do with. Other times, I’ve given something my best and it still hasn’t worked out. I try to keep both in mind. When things go my way, I’m grateful and careful about how much credit I take. When they don’t, I give myself some grace, too.
As I noted, I'm new to this game, and am by no means an expert on this topic. But a lot of this is fresh in my mind after having just gone through this. But you need to do your own research. Don't take what you see here as gospel truth. That said .... first, if you are happy with your Medicare Advantage plan and it has served you well for 12 years, you are wise to be cautious about switching. As you noted, your network of doctors is stable and you have access to the care you need.However, your concern about future restrictions on care or changes to provider networks is valid, as those are common frustrations with Advantage plans. The critical issue you must investigate before making any decision is medical underwriting. At 77 years old, with a history of stents, you would likely have to undergo medical underwriting to purchase a separate Medigap (supplement) plan. Unlike during your initial enrollment period, insurers can review your health history and deny you coverage or charge a significantly higher premium based on your condition. A history of stents is a major risk factor and could very likely result in a decline. The only way to avoid medical underwriting is if you qualify for a "guaranteed issue" right. This is a specific set of circumstances where an insurer must sell you a Medigap policy regardless of your health.
Federal Rules: You generally get guaranteed issue rights if your current Medicare Advantage plan is ending, you move out of the plan's service area, or if you joined an Advantage plan for the first time and want to switch back to Original Medicare within the first year (a "trial right"). Voluntarily leaving your plan because you are worried about the future does not trigger a federal guaranteed issue right.
State Rules: This is where it gets complex. Some states, such as New York, Connecticut, Maine, and Massachusetts, have additional laws that offer broader or continuous guaranteed issue rights, or "birthday rules" that allow you to switch policies annually.
As you can see, there are many conditionals. You cannot make an informed decision without consulting a trusted, independent Medicare insurance agent or your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP). They can help you understand your specific health underwriting risks and whether any guaranteed issue rights apply to you based on where you live.
Well, that's just it. My wife and I are healthy today, but you never know what's around the corner. We didn't want to roll that dice that we could survive underwriting this time next year.
Correct. It does not include routine dental and vision. I think many Medicare Advantage plans offer dental and vision coverage to compensate, in part, for the disadvantages they present in medical coverage. For me, that is a side show compared to the ability to see virtually any doctor I want, use any hospital I want, and for the very most part, escape prior authorization hell. Yes, I'm paying more for this ability, but to me at least, and I gather from many others responding to this post, the cost is worth it.
I'm still new to this, Mike, but from what I understand, the max out of pocket for us is the combined cost of the monthly premiums, and the 2027 projected annual Medicare Part B annual deductible of $292 (for each of us). That does not include, of course, the standard Part B Medicare monthly premium projected to be $209.50 per person in 2027. Nor does it include Rx costs. And I'm not sure yet whether that $209.50 premium will be jacked up by IRMMA. Need to check that out. I figure all in, my wife and I are looking at spending approximately $10,000 next year on medical/Rx costs. That includes United Healthcare Plan G Supplement premiums, Part B annual deductible, standard Part B Medicare premiums, Plan D (Rx) premiums, and out of pocket Rx costs.
We were warned over and over again not to drop the employer sponsored plan until we were 100% sure we are covered under Plan G. United Healthcare emailed us that we are approved in the last few days, but until the documents and ID cards are in our hands, we won't move on the current coverage. Supposedly, they will show up in about 7-10 days.
That was exactly it, Mike ... can we afford it. And we are fortunate that we can. I've said to my wife many times that we are lucky -- we will run out of health/time before we run out of money. Given that, this decision was to really invest in the one thing that will hopefully extend our quality of life as time goes by.
There are so many different ways this issue might be addressed by Congress that my plan is to sit back and react, if necessary, once the final approach is legislated. It's very possible that none of the changes that are ultimately made even apply to current SS recipients.
Comments
Sometimes things go your way, and sometimes they don’t. Some of the best things in my life have come through good timing or circumstances I had little to do with. Other times, I’ve given something my best and it still hasn’t worked out. I try to keep both in mind. When things go my way, I’m grateful and careful about how much credit I take. When they don’t, I give myself some grace, too.
Post: The $100 That Bought Nothing
Link to comment from November 19, 2026
As I noted, I'm new to this game, and am by no means an expert on this topic. But a lot of this is fresh in my mind after having just gone through this. But you need to do your own research. Don't take what you see here as gospel truth. That said .... first, if you are happy with your Medicare Advantage plan and it has served you well for 12 years, you are wise to be cautious about switching. As you noted, your network of doctors is stable and you have access to the care you need.However, your concern about future restrictions on care or changes to provider networks is valid, as those are common frustrations with Advantage plans. The critical issue you must investigate before making any decision is medical underwriting. At 77 years old, with a history of stents, you would likely have to undergo medical underwriting to purchase a separate Medigap (supplement) plan. Unlike during your initial enrollment period, insurers can review your health history and deny you coverage or charge a significantly higher premium based on your condition. A history of stents is a major risk factor and could very likely result in a decline. The only way to avoid medical underwriting is if you qualify for a "guaranteed issue" right. This is a specific set of circumstances where an insurer must sell you a Medigap policy regardless of your health.
- State Rules: This is where it gets complex. Some states, such as New York, Connecticut, Maine, and Massachusetts, have additional laws that offer broader or continuous guaranteed issue rights, or "birthday rules" that allow you to switch policies annually.
As you can see, there are many conditionals. You cannot make an informed decision without consulting a trusted, independent Medicare insurance agent or your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP). They can help you understand your specific health underwriting risks and whether any guaranteed issue rights apply to you based on where you live.Post: Dropping My Subsidized Retiree Health Plan for a Medigap Plan G—Am I Crazy to Pay $2K+ More?
Link to comment from November 3, 2026
Well, that's just it. My wife and I are healthy today, but you never know what's around the corner. We didn't want to roll that dice that we could survive underwriting this time next year.
Post: Dropping My Subsidized Retiree Health Plan for a Medigap Plan G—Am I Crazy to Pay $2K+ More?
Link to comment from November 1, 2026
Correct. It does not include routine dental and vision. I think many Medicare Advantage plans offer dental and vision coverage to compensate, in part, for the disadvantages they present in medical coverage. For me, that is a side show compared to the ability to see virtually any doctor I want, use any hospital I want, and for the very most part, escape prior authorization hell. Yes, I'm paying more for this ability, but to me at least, and I gather from many others responding to this post, the cost is worth it.
Post: Dropping My Subsidized Retiree Health Plan for a Medigap Plan G—Am I Crazy to Pay $2K+ More?
Link to comment from November 1, 2026
I'm still new to this, Mike, but from what I understand, the max out of pocket for us is the combined cost of the monthly premiums, and the 2027 projected annual Medicare Part B annual deductible of $292 (for each of us). That does not include, of course, the standard Part B Medicare monthly premium projected to be $209.50 per person in 2027. Nor does it include Rx costs. And I'm not sure yet whether that $209.50 premium will be jacked up by IRMMA. Need to check that out. I figure all in, my wife and I are looking at spending approximately $10,000 next year on medical/Rx costs. That includes United Healthcare Plan G Supplement premiums, Part B annual deductible, standard Part B Medicare premiums, Plan D (Rx) premiums, and out of pocket Rx costs.
Post: Dropping My Subsidized Retiree Health Plan for a Medigap Plan G—Am I Crazy to Pay $2K+ More?
Link to comment from November 1, 2026
We were warned over and over again not to drop the employer sponsored plan until we were 100% sure we are covered under Plan G. United Healthcare emailed us that we are approved in the last few days, but until the documents and ID cards are in our hands, we won't move on the current coverage. Supposedly, they will show up in about 7-10 days.
Post: Dropping My Subsidized Retiree Health Plan for a Medigap Plan G—Am I Crazy to Pay $2K+ More?
Link to comment from November 1, 2026
That was exactly it, Mike ... can we afford it. And we are fortunate that we can. I've said to my wife many times that we are lucky -- we will run out of health/time before we run out of money. Given that, this decision was to really invest in the one thing that will hopefully extend our quality of life as time goes by.
Post: Dropping My Subsidized Retiree Health Plan for a Medigap Plan G—Am I Crazy to Pay $2K+ More?
Link to comment from November 1, 2026
Julie ... we did pass underwriting. Just heard that yesterday. Glad you endorse this decision. We gave it quite a bit of thought.
Post: Dropping My Subsidized Retiree Health Plan for a Medigap Plan G—Am I Crazy to Pay $2K+ More?
Link to comment from November 1, 2026
Once you've flown in the first class section of a plane, it's a long, doleful trudge back into coach again.
Post: Jonathan’s Parting Thoughts: No. 6
Link to comment from October 2, 2026
There are so many different ways this issue might be addressed by Congress that my plan is to sit back and react, if necessary, once the final approach is legislated. It's very possible that none of the changes that are ultimately made even apply to current SS recipients.
Post: Is your retirement plan counting on a Social Security COLA in the future?
Link to comment from September 25, 2026