Go to main Forum page Ā»
In April 2025, I watched the movie Four Weddings and a Funeral for the umpteenth time. I found tears rolling down my cheeks as one of the characters read the poem “Funeral Blues,” written by W.H. Auden, at the memorial service for his partner. What sparked the tears? The poem tells of the emotional devastation of losing a loved one. But for me, it highlighted my distress at knowing that all that brings me happinessāElaine, my kids, my larger family, my friends, the community that has become HumbleDollarāwould soon be taken away from me.
Stop all the clocks, cut off the telephone,
Prevent the dog from barking with a juicy bone,
Silence the pianos and with muffled drum
Bring out the coffin, let the mourners come.
Let aeroplanes circle moaning overhead
Scribbling on the sky the message ‘He is Dead’.
Put crepe bows round the white necks of the public doves,
Let the traffic policemen wear black cotton gloves.
He was my North, my South, my East and West,
My working week and my Sunday rest,
My noon, my midnight, my talk, my song;
I thought that love would last forever: I was wrong.
The stars are not wanted now; put out every one,
Pack up the moon and dismantle the sun,
Pour away the ocean and sweep up the wood;
For nothing now can ever come to any good.
I’ve scheduled this piece to appear after my death. I’m not afraid of dying. But the idea of not living, and missing out on all the joys that life offers, fills me with sadness.
Thank you for your writing, Jonathan. I’m hoping that there are unimaginable joys for you now. And that you’ll be reunited with all those you love.
It is a gift to be able to read Jonathanās writing. He is deeply missed by many of us, and his legacy lives on through his words.
There were 4 deaths during past 3 months in our 55+ community. It is devastating to everyone, especially survivors. My learnings: Focus on relationships, spend time wisely, and be well prepared for end of life.
Jonathan, Thanks for showing us what truly matters.
I found this article to be very challenging, both poignant and heartbreaking. Like many, I was amazed by Jonathan’s equanimity during his journey. But I knew how much his family meant to him, and this article demonstrates the pain he felt.
I recently lost a close friend to a butterfly glioblastoma that covered both hemispheres of his brain. He was about the same age as Jonathan, very sharp, with a big loving family, and young grandkids. His disease took his cognition first, and then his body. It was hard to know what he understood of his condition as it progressed. Two good friends, one stayed mentally sharp until the end, one lost his cognition well before he lost his life. I guess there are blessings and curses with each.
I apologize for the mournful thoughts. My wife says the thing she dislikes the most about aging is that the challenges your loved ones face are big deals. As Jonathan often wrote, my takeaway is what a gift he gave us by allowing his family, friends, and the HD community to share his life, until the end.
I lost my brother at 59 years old to Alzheimerās and Lewy body dementias (he donated his brain to the memory disorders clicic at Mass General. He was non communicative for years before his death as well as unaware of his surroundings as well. At his passing I kept thinking is he in pain, does he hear us, and does he know what is happening? Six months later my father died at 85 of suspected Lewy body dementia and was non communicative for the last six or so months. Then my mother passed away at 85 six months after that after having dementia for more than a decade. She did not recognize any of the family for years. So for the passing of half of my family we could not support them, or know their thoughts as their lives were ending. It was horrible.
Last year my mother in law passed away at 103 1/4 and was in complete control of her capacities until the day she passed away. She lived in senior housing until 102 when her husband went to a nursing home and she moved in with us. Other than by age she physically never would have qualified for nursing home care. The way the end of her life ended up going was a blessing for me.
For the newer readers of HD you can read my thoughts on her under my David Lancaster profile (I had to create a new profile via Discus due to problems logging on to HD via X.
R.I.P. A salutary reminder of the importance of carpe diem. Also, that the problem is not being dead, it’s the process of becoming dead, and the devastation left behind. I recently lost a friend unexpectedly – fine one day, gone the next. Is that “better”? Easier for her in many ways, but no time for goodbyes or for those left behind to start to prepare. Jonathan did a great job of preparing.
God Bless Jonathan. One who loved Family and Friends and made his mark to ALL. Thanks. May he rest in Peace.
I read about you, Jonathan Clements, in the AARP magazine (March 2025, yes, I am reading this magazine from my old collection). Your grit, determination and positive outlook of life in face of adversities motivate me and I am sure it motivates many others.
Quoting you directly: “I’m determined to make the most of each day. I’ve long thought happiness has three key ingredients: a sense of financial security, time with family and friends, and doing work I love. My diagnosis has made me even more focused on those three things.”
” I still want to make difference in the lives of others. That’s why I continue to write and edit every day. In return, I end each day feeling fulfilled and with that pleasant sense of progress that makes me happy.”
Your ‘humbledollars” has inspired and continue to inspire many.
Thanks to all those who continue to keep this running.
Thank you, Jonathan for all you did.
I love that movie and have also watched it umpteen times. I remember that scene and that W.H. Auden poem well.
The only thing I can say about the sadness Jonathan expressed here and that we all feel while reading it isāexperiencing that kind of loss means that youāve also had a special love in your life, and for that, we can be grateful.
š„ŗš„ŗ
To everyone who read this post we owe it to Jonathan and ourselves to LIVE! Live to the fullest.
Jonathan, your candle was snuffed out far too soon. Your words continue to touch and inspire, but how I wish you were still here to write more of them. You are deeply missed, not only as a writer, but as a brother.
What a fantastic memorial post! And also a great reminder of your quality writing. Thanks, Jonathan!
Thanks, Jonathanš„¹
Jonathan, I think of you often—for the many finance (and writing) lessons you taught us, but even more for the pragmatism and dignity with which you approached death.
You were more guarded about your deeper feelings. That makes this piece all the more striking.
Andrew
Wow, such a powerful reminder to appreciate everyday we have and the people around us who make our lives so happy. š¢
Miss you so much Jonathan š¢
I could/should read this post everyday. I’m reminded of the first post I wrote about death & taxes for Humble Dollar since I am once again leading a course on A Year to Live. Jonathan taught me many things over the years but fully embracing dying while living may be the most important. Miss you!
A wonderful reminder about the things that bring us joy, but we so often overlook due to daily minutia.