THERE ARE TWO THINGS that Americans loathe paying: taxes and health care costs. When those two come together, watch out.
That brings us to IRMAA, short for income-related monthly adjustment amount, the steeper Medicare premiums paid by retirees with high incomes. Those who pay IRMAA are often livid about the extra cost.
I looked up my Social Security records. Over my working career, I paid $98,062 in Medicare taxes and my employer paid $97,735, for a total of $195,797. Yes, that’s a lot of money. But my wife, who didn’t have any earned income after 1970 and thus paid minimal Medicare taxes, has incurred bills paid by Medicare well in excess of $300,000.
Many retirees can say the same and most paid far less in Medicare taxes than I did. Keep in mind that the current taxes funding the Medicare hospital trust are inadequate. The trust will run out of money in about four years. The standard Medicare Part B premiums only fund about 25% of the program’s costs. The balance comes from general federal government revenue.
In that context, the IRMAA surcharges don’t seem so terrible. Yet, when I pointed out to a group of retirees that the income-based premiums affected only 7% of retirees, many weren’t impressed. Many also discounted the fact the premiums start at $91,000 for individuals and $182,000 for couples, well above the typical U.S. household income.
Here are some of the replies I received from various Facebook groups:
Affluent current and future retirees seek ways to avoid or limit IRMAA. One strategy is to fund Roth accounts or to make Roth conversions two years in advance of Medicare. Tax-free distributions from Roths aren’t counted when determining income for IRMAA purposes, but tax-free municipal bond interest is. Go figure.
I think keeping your income low to avoid paying $816 a year more in Part B premiums—that’s the sum if you breach the first IRMAA income threshold—is a losing proposition. But this Facebook commenter didn’t think so: “The last thing you want is to make $1 more than the [IRMAA] bracket. That’s really feeling screwed.”
Yes, IRMAA is a so-called cliff penalty. Even if you’re just $1 above the threshold amount, you get charged the full extra premium for that income level. The premium surcharges could have been better designed. Still, is it so unreasonable for high-income retirees to pay more for Medicare?
i am going to go in a different direction. my wife of 30 years was all about “the market” and accumulation. i am not. she passed 3 years ago. she was and i am an orphan. i am sitting on 700 k in cash and a paid for house after unwinding from “the market”. i am 64 and have 100 acres and a small off grid house waiting for me when i retire at 65. none of my immediate family made it out of their 70’s. i am done with the machinations of the world and wish the best for you and yours. at some point, enough is enough. 1500 a month in ss (in its coming diminished form) will take care of any ‘extras’.
Have tried to explain this before to
Mr. Quinn but he does not get it –
IRMAA is a form of double taxation-
Part B Is financed through general
revenue and higher income taxpayers
are already paying higher marginal
tax rates (not to mention Obamacare
taxes). But we are still asked to pay
a disguised income tax through IRMAA.
Also, paying IRMAA over many years
can degrade the resiliency of a retirees
investment portfolio. There is a lot of
Instability in the world – Covid/war/
inflation/poor public policy – retirees
have limited means of coping as they
are at the mercy of financial markets.
Mr. Quinn worked in HR. Companies
try to attract employees with good
benefit packages even when the
core compensation elements are
good. Retirees in IRMAA face 20 K
per year or more health care costs
which are not pre-tax dollars.How
many employees would sign up with
a company offering plans with costs
like that.
It’s a premium surtax not unlike the higher premiums many employers charge higher income workers. Is the standard Part B premium a tax or a premium?