FREE NEWSLETTER

John Goodell

    Forum Posts

    Comments

    • “One thing I’ve learned is that we don’t need to fill every hour with activity or accomplishment.” Somewhere along the way, I became a workaholic without meaning to and to such an extent that this sentence really rings embarrassingly true in retrospect. I thought I had outrun this moving to teaching, but I had not. Like all “holics” I had to enter a form of rehab where I am now doing my best to learn the real value in your second sentence of that paragraph (Sometimes the greatest rewards come from simply having the time to appreciate life’s quieter moments.) It’s a process. Thank you for your comment.

      Post: The Number Is Not The Answer

      Link to comment from October 11, 2026

    • Thank you all for the wonderful comments. They really have meant a good deal to me.

      Post: The Number Is Not The Answer

      Link to comment from October 11, 2026

    • I left the Pension Review Board, in part, because it became clear to me that the state of Texas and its various municipalities had no interest adopting the Nevada state pension approach of indexing (despite or perhaps because it would cost taxpayers less in terms of government salaries let alone superior returns from indexing). When I pushed on this topic, eyes rolled and ultimately, it was too hard to convince certain powers that be that special interests who wine, dine and contribute to campaigns weren’t very good at delivering returns. Ultimately, teachers, fire fighters, municipal workers etc are the losers as are the taxpayers who cover the shortfall when the failure is big enough. Active management has never delivered superior returns for any retirement system in Texas of any meaningful scale over any meaningful time period, and yet the willful desire to the look the other way was as ever present as it was discouraging.

      Post: The Number Is Not The Answer

      Link to comment from October 11, 2026

    • It’s great to hear from you, Rick! Thank you for the thoughtful comment!

      Post: The Silent Committee

      Link to comment from September 16, 2026

    • Thank you! I must admit to finding the argument that it’s passive investing to own VOO (or any S&P index fund) really odd because they’re basically a fund manager with really reasonable constraints.

      Post: The Silent Committee

      Link to comment from September 15, 2026

    • Thank you, sir!

      Post: The Silent Committee

      Link to comment from September 15, 2026

    • Huge compliment to be lumped in with other authors on here who I respect so much.

      Post: The Silent Committee

      Link to comment from September 15, 2026

    • Thank you for reading and commenting!

      Post: The Silent Committee

      Link to comment from September 15, 2026

    • Thank you for the kind words, Andrew. I haven’t been able to write as much over the past few years, but I am taking a small break from the grind and have more time right now. It’s really nice to hear from you again!

      Post: The Silent Committee

      Link to comment from September 15, 2026

    • Correct

      Post: What’s your Domicile?

      Link to comment from September 12, 2026

    Articles

    The Number Is Not The Answer

    John Goodell   |  Oct 10, 2026

    YEARS AGO, while practicing law, I was a frequent contributor to Humble Dollar. I loved Jonathan Clements’s vision for the site – a corner of the financial universe built on clarity, frugality, and the quiet dignity of living within one’s means.
    Then my life took a sharp pivot. I left legal practice to teach gifted-and-talented students and coach varsity athletics at a public magnet high school. Almost immediately, my submissions here dried up.

    Who Will You Become?

    John Goodell   |  Dec 5, 2022

    YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT your future self will want. This is the tantalizing hypothesis of Hidden Brain podcast host Shankar Vedantam, who argues that we’re constantly becoming new people.
    Vedantam offers the example of a hospice nurse who, having witnessed so much misery in her dying patients, made her husband promise never to extend her life if she became terminally ill. Yet, when her body was ravaged by ALS, often called Lou Gehrig’s disease,

    Twelve Paradoxes

    John Goodell   |  Jun 17, 2022

    WHAT SEEMS TRUE about money often turns out to be false. That brings me to the financial paradoxes I’ve come across during my investing journey. Here are my top 12:

    The more we try to trade our way to profits, the less likely we are to profit.
    The more boring an investment—think index funds—the more exciting the long-run performance will probably be.
    The more exciting an investment—name your latest Wall Street concoction, SPAC or anything crypto—the less exciting the long-term results typically are.

    Stay Positive

    John Goodell   |  May 24, 2022

    AMONG THE AREAS of law that have made me miserable over 16 years of practice, it’s the adversarial roles that have made me most miserable. My experience in labor and employment law has been particularly difficult because the interaction with opposing counsel is usually contentious, each side compelled to zealously advocate for their position.
    Almost any type of litigation is a zero-sum game. One side wins, the other loses. Because the outcome is never guaranteed,

    Not Digging It

    John Goodell   |  May 4, 2022

    BEFORE I BECAME a devotee of index funds, I began my investing journey in commodities, with a focus on commodity miners and producers. These firms extract a variety of goods from the earth, including precious metals like gold and silver, as well as energy-related commodities like oil, natural gas and uranium.
    As a college student first studying the markets, I was drawn to the outsized returns that can occur in a commodity bull market.

    Wrote and Grew Rich

    John Goodell   |  Apr 9, 2022

    IF YOU GOOGLE “best business books of all time,” you’ll find Napoleon Hill’s Think and Grow Rich at or near the top of the search results, ahead of works by luminaries such as Ben Graham and Jack Bogle.
    Truly helpful business analysis requires the reader to pay attention to evidence backed by boring data, a formula that’s hard to sell to the masses. Books like Think and Grow Rich or Jim Collins’s Good to Great offer the reader questionable assumptions built on anecdotal evidence,

    Side Hassle

    John Goodell   |  Apr 6, 2022

    THE SIREN SONG of a side hustle is alluring in theory—but not in reality. We’re beset by platitudes such as “to become wealthy, you need multiple streams of income.” Many folks, I suspect, take on a side hustle without fully understanding the costs. They imagine it’s an opportunity to monetize their hobbies or interests and achieve their financial goals faster.
    Let’s face it: “Second job” just doesn’t sound sexy, so financial bloggers and the media favor “side hustle,” an apparently more glamorous term.

    Don’t Be Deceived

    John Goodell   |  Mar 11, 2022

    AT FIRST GLANCE, personal finance might appear to have nothing in common with the world of personal fitness. I’d argue otherwise.
    Perhaps the clearest parallel is between the gains from diligent investing in low-cost index funds and the gains from proper diet and exercise. Both are hardly noticeable at first and, as a result, there’s a temptation to stray. But if we continue the process of saving and investing—or eating correctly and exercising—we can see tremendous gains over time.

    Making Good Time

    John Goodell   |  Mar 4, 2022

    PARKINSON’S LAW states that work expands to fill the time available for its completion. This law is a pervasive reality—and misguided practice—in much of the working world. But I recall first encountering it before I joined the ranks of the employed.
    During the summer before my senior year of college, I spent several weeks in Fort Lewis, Washington, for the ROTC training required for a commission in the Army. On the day when it was my turn to lead my peers,

    Saving Their Souls

    John Goodell   |  Feb 18, 2022

    EVERY FALL AT LAW schools across America, a process occurs called on-campus interviewing, or OCI, as it’s commonly known. The more elite the law school, the more prestigious the crop of law firms that visit, each offering the promise of large salaries to brilliant, mostly young minds. Only students with excellent grades or editorial positions on the school’s law review are selected to interview for summer internships.
    Like nearly all graduate schools, law school comes with an expensive price tag,

    SHARE