FREE NEWSLETTER

Articles › Happiness

The Number Is Not The Answer

YEARS AGO, while practicing law, I was a frequent contributor to Humble Dollar. I loved Jonathan Clements’s vision for the site – a corner of the financial universe built on clarity, frugality, and the quiet dignity of living within one’s means.

Then my life took a sharp pivot. I left legal practice to teach gifted-and-talented students and coach varsity athletics at a public magnet high school. Almost immediately, my submissions here dried up. I was consuming entire days guiding brilliant teenagers through complex history, breaking down match film, and grading papers long past sunset and on weekends.

I wrote to Jonathan with genuine regret, apologizing for going dark on such a wonderful enterprise. His reply was quintessential Jonathan: he explained to me with characteristic, succinct warmth that his own adult child was a teacher, adding that he wasn’t sure there was a higher calling on Earth.

He was right about the calling. But what nobody warns you about a calling is its capacity to consume you whole if you let it.

The Cliff Edge

This past year, the math simply broke. Between high-load AP teaching, head coaching, and the relentless calendar of high school athletics, I was regularly clocking 17- to 18-hour days during soccer season. My central nervous system finally redlined badly. Worse, I realized with a gut punch that I had missed nearly the entire senior year of my oldest son while running on that treadmill. This realization hit me at his graduation when I felt physically exhausted and unable to enjoy what should have been one of the proudest moments of my life. I was determined to make it up to him in whatever way I could (for example, we are visiting him today at college, and we go often to see him in San Antonio – a 90-minute drive from Austin). Moreover, I will not repeat this mistake and will enjoy the years I have left with my two high-school-aged daughters.

With teenagers preparing to leave the nest and a close family member facing severe illness, I stepped away. I took a sabbatical. Maybe it will delay our retirement slightly, but as I will express further below, I am not sure I will ever really retire.

The Void

Financial planners love to reduce retirement to a single milestone: “The Number.” The spreadsheets run 10,000 Monte Carlo simulations, the house is paid off, the withdrawal rates are dialed in, and the industry assures you: You have arrived. You are safe.

At 45, I had not retired in the traditional sense, but I had stepped off the cliff of full-time professional identity because my body told me I needed to. And what I discovered in the sudden, unanticipated quiet is something many retirees spend years agonizing over without having the vocabulary to describe: The number is not the answer.

When you abruptly remove the machinery of a demanding daily routine, you don’t instantly find nirvana. You find a void.

In a recent discussion on non-financial retirement readiness, former financial adviser Tyler Gardner framed this dilemma in his video on non-financial retirement needs around Self-Determination Theory, pioneered by psychologists Edward Deci and Richard Ryan. Deci and Ryan posited that human well-being rests on three basic psychological nutrients: competence, relatedness, and autonomy.

For all its stress and bureaucratic friction, a demanding career supplies all three automatically. When you walk away from work, those three nutrients can vanish before your celebratory cake is even eaten.

If you don’t deliberately rebuild them, the fallout can be physiological.

The Trap of “Mental Retirement”

In aging literature, researchers study a sobering phenomenon bluntly termed “mental retirement” – the cognitive softening that occurs when a person ceases to be intellectually stretched.

A decade-long study from Binghamton University examining China’s rural pension expansion revealed that early retirement significantly accelerated cognitive decline. Crucially, the researchers noted that the negative impact of reduced social and mental engagement outweighed the physical benefits of improved nutrition and sleep that the pension provided.

Work forced us to solve problems under pressure. Sabbaticals and retirements do not.

To counteract that loss, I had to create self-imposed challenges. During my grueling years in the classroom, exercise was the first thing pushed off the ledge. On leave, I reclaimed the time. I started chasing benchmarks for physical competence.

Recently, I set out to regain a grueling standard: 10 continuous minutes on the Jacob’s Ladder. It was a benchmark an elite special operator had given me when I served as an Army JAG supporting special operations in Afghanistan in my late twenties. My first time back on the ladder? I barely completed one minute and staggered off it trembling and nauseous. But every week, I kept working at it – sometimes adding a few seconds and other times several minutes until I got to 10 minutes again this week. Crossing that threshold didn’t merely burn calories; it restored a measurable gradient of physical competence and, with it, confidence.

Whether it is conquering a brutal conditioning standard, learning a language, or mastering an instrument, we need something where we can objectively say: I am better at this today than I was last month. I will now find a new physical benchmark to pursue, while coming back occasionally to that masochistic Jacob’s Ladder.

The 40 Invisible People

The second nutrient, relatedness, is where most folks get ambushed.

When people contemplate retirement, they assume their social health depends on their spouse or a handful of close friends. But work provides something entirely different: a vast scaffolding of “weak ties.”

In a landmark 2014 study published in Social Psychological and Personality Science, researchers Gillian Sandstrom and Elizabeth Dunn found that daily subjective happiness and feelings of belonging rose noticeably on days when people had more peripheral interactions – even something as fleeting as a 20-second genuine exchange with a coffee barista.

Broader public health research reinforces this with astonishing gravity. A massive meta-analysis led by Julianne Holt-Lunstad spanning over 300,000 individuals found that strong social integration increased survival likelihood by 50%. Remarkably, the mortality benefit was strongest for complex, varied social networks (the diverse web of people you bump into) rather than simple binary measures like living with someone.

When I taught, I had hundreds of involuntary interactions before lunch: hallway greetings, banter with the front desk, coaching video sessions, cafeteria check-ins. On my sabbatical, I plunged into writing a historical thriller called The Blood Money Ledger set during the Vietnam War – a passion project rooted in my love of history and informed by my own military service.

I was thrilled to find that the fiction flowed with unexpected ease. In fact, I am now leaning toward turning my main character, Tom Calder, into a series of books about morality, the law, and institutional rot. But writing is, by definition, solitary confinement.

Left entirely unmanaged, isolation is insidious. To survive it, I had to engineer artificial friction:

  • I go to the gym at the exact same hour every day to see the familiar faces of regulars.
  • Once a week, a close friend and I meet at a local coffee shop; he reads while I hammer out words for the book. It’s quiet, parallel work, but the ambient presence makes the solitary act of writing sustainable.
  • I signed up for an evening furniture-making class to work with my hands alongside people I wouldn’t otherwise meet – a skill I am going to start out terrible at and eventually become… less terrible at.
  • I took on a volunteer docent shift at the Austin History Center, trading archival stories with curious strangers.

None of these people are lifelong confidants – except my close friend who joins me for coffee. But together, they rebuild the 40 casual touchpoints work used to gift me for free.

Anticipation Over Accumulation

The final hazard is structural: time without seams.

When we dream of retirement, we picture unstructured calendars and checking off items on an expansive bucket list. But behavioral psychology shows we often misunderstand how human satisfaction works.

In a well-known 2010 study by Dutch researcher Jeroen Nawijn tracking over 1,500 adults, vacationers exhibited significantly higher happiness before their trips than non-vacationers. The post-trip happiness bump, however, was negligible and evaporated rapidly. Even though I haven’t written for Humble Dollar much in the past several years, I have been a frequent lurker, and know that this is a topic we all understand well.

The engine of joy is almost entirely anticipation, not completion.

A bucket list should never be treated like a grocery list where the goal is an empty page. If you clear out your list with no new ambitions behind it, life goes flat. The real art is maintaining a continuous horizon of things you are eagerly anticipating: an upcoming course, a seasonal trip, an archival project, or a fresh manuscript draft. We are in the midst of using high school and college graduation presents as family adventures we take. For my son’s graduation gift – he loves soccer – I took him and his soccer-obsessed sister to the World Cup. My other daughter, who is very much not soccer-obsessed, and my wife visited a spa together for significantly less money. Win-win.

The Real Ledger

The Monday morning after your final Friday, your spreadsheet will not ask how you are doing, provide an intellectual hill to climb, or hand you an unexpected laugh across a desk.

The number is just the admission ticket that we too often obsess over. The actual show begins when you decide what will make your days count.

 John Goodell was a deputy director of policy and general counsel at the Texas Pension Review Board. Currently an Army Reservist, he previously served 14 years on active duty before leaving to become the general counsel at the Texas Veterans Commission. John has spent much of his career working with public sector employees on tax, investment, estate planning and retirement issues. His biggest passion is spending time with his wife and kids. Check out John’s earlier articles.

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
25 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Tony Schmitt
1 month ago

John – What an inciteful article with many reference to various studies to support your comments. I have been retired for 8 1/2 years and I have not looked back because I have a great network of friends and I have tremendous energy to do things that challenge me. Ironically, there are times (few though they might be) when I have a “gap” in my schedule. That is truly scary. I am trying to learn how to make the most of those gaps.

Jeff Bond
1 month ago

John – best of luck with the furniture making class! I did the same when I retired. I’ve made a couple of pieces that turned out well. I’ve also made a couple of mistakes that were great teaching experiences. I joined a woodworking craft center at a local university that provides the expensive tools that I don’t have space for. The fee to join was far less than the cost of the tools.

bbbobbins
1 month ago

Wow, I’m exhausted already. Totally agree with the message.

I’m struggling with the idea of too much structure in post-retirement life. Part of the joy of non-working days is the “I don’t have to be ready for the call at X am, worry about travel to Y for Z pm & I’ll probably be too late for dinner by the time I get home.” It seems to me that some people intentionally recreate work stress and obligation by the things they get involved in. Though some structure is probably desirable to hold one accountable for just pottering around days.

V Saraf
1 month ago

Thanks for sharing your journey. Fascinating!

While we may think we took detours from the normal path, they turn out to be enriching experiences in my opinion.

Recalibration is always good, because we live one day at a time and guiding principles change with age and experience.

John Goodell
1 month ago

Thank you all for the wonderful comments. They really have meant a good deal to me.

Jack Hannam
1 month ago

“…decide what will make your days count.” Great way to phrase it, and good to remember that the best time to start is right now, not waiting until one reaches their number or some other goal. Welcome back!

Dan Smith
1 month ago

John, I thought of your article this morning when I read an article from the Washington Post about a 103 year old bartender, still going strong. I have to wonder if personal encounters have added to his longevity and his sharp mind. 
I didn’t begin hanging with this HumbleDollar crowd until after you ceased contributing; I’m glad you’re back, you have had an interesting life. I’m looking forward to more of your articles.

William Dorner
1 month ago

Well said John. I am a lucky one, and decided in my 20’s, to lead a great family life you have to have balance in all the facets of life for the Best outcome. Glad you learned that early enough for you and your Family. The Best to you.

Rick Connor
1 month ago

John, Great to hear from you, and thanks for a fascinating and thought provoking article. One of the joys of HD is learning about other people’s lives and the many different ways we humans navigate the journey.

This article reminded me of something my father used to say when one of us returned from a trip. He was sincerely interested in hearing about where you went, what you did, what you learned, and interesting things you may have encountered. Upon your return we would sit down and he would say “So, you left here”. That meant start at the beginning and tell your tale. Thanks for catching us up since “you left here”.

Michael1
1 month ago

John this is an excellent article. I’m glad you’re finding your way again. 

Two things I found particularly instructive:

First, “Whether it is conquering a brutal conditioning standard, learning a language, or mastering an instrument, we need something where we can objectively say: I am better at this today than I was last month.” Well said, and I’d suggest even just being able to say trying to get better (or not get worse) can be enough.

Second, the notion of several small or even tiny touch points of personal connection is new to me. As nomads we have few ongoing relationships, but we meet new people all the time. Recently we’ve revisited a few places and caught up with some. Nice to know the research. 

Thanks for the article. Now off to work on my handstand and one of those barista interactions.

Donny Hrubes
1 month ago

Passing on educational treasures learned of life to an EAGER learner is a wonderful passion. Too often The “youngers” do not want to learn, but simply complain.
I truly wish to find even one that could be successfully influenced a little in the correct direction.

Senthil Nathan
1 month ago

WoW. What a piece of writing. An eye opener for those in their 50s and 60s thinking of retiring at some point. A high value article. Thank you.

Kalpesh Sheth
1 month ago

John, really appreciate this article. As a person who’s contemplating and preparing for – “what will I do with my time”, this really hit home.

Last edited 1 month ago by Kalpesh Sheth
Edmund Marsh
1 month ago

John, thanks for your writing. You touch on a number of concerns and experiences that I share as I transition into my own retirement. Best wishes on finding the right balance.

Andrew Clements
1 month ago

John, what a thoughtful article, and welcome back to HumbleDollar. I especially appreciated your recollection of Jonathan. His belief that teaching was among the highest callings speaks volumes about the man he was.

Having retired at 55, I’ve had more than a decade to reflect on what makes retirement fulfilling. I’ve come to realize that financial independence gives us the freedom to choose how we spend our time, but it doesn’t necessarily give that time meaning. That comes from the relationships we nurture, the interests we pursue, and the opportunities we find to make a difference in the lives of others.

One thing I’ve learned is that we don’t need to fill every hour with activity or accomplishment. Sometimes the greatest rewards come from simply having the time to appreciate life’s quieter moments.

Your decision to step away and reclaim time with your family is something I suspect you’ll never regret. Money can be earned again, but those years with your children cannot be recovered. As I’ve written before, time is our most precious asset, and how we choose to spend it ultimately defines our wealth.

John Goodell
1 month ago

“One thing I’ve learned is that we don’t need to fill every hour with activity or accomplishment.” Somewhere along the way, I became a workaholic without meaning to and to such an extent that this sentence really rings embarrassingly true in retrospect. I thought I had outrun this moving to teaching, but I had not. Like all “holics” I had to enter a form of rehab where I am now doing my best to learn the real value in your second sentence of that paragraph (Sometimes the greatest rewards come from simply having the time to appreciate life’s quieter moments.) It’s a process. Thank you for your comment.

Andrew Forsythe
1 month ago

Hi, John. It’s a pleasure to see you here this morning. I’ve always greatly enjoyed your writing, and this very thoughtful article is no exception. I especially liked your comments on “peripheral interactions” and the role of “anticipation” in happiness. Jonathan likewise often wrote about the latter.

Your observations about retirement are insightful and interesting. I’ll add that I believe retirement is a very individual thing. I’ve been retired now, likewise from the practice of law, for almost 10 years and have thoroughly enjoyed it.

But as an introvert, while I need some amount of human interaction to be happy, I likely don’t need as much as the average person, so that hasn’t been a problem for me. I do enjoy staying in touch with my friends, and retirement has also given me the pleasure of spending more time with my wife—who put up with my ridiculous work hours for many years.

As for the intellectual stimulation that work no longer provides, in this day of the internet I believe that anyone with a curious mind has no reason to be bored or to quit learning. In fact, the additional free time I now have has allowed me to read and explore way beyond what I could possibly manage during my hectic work days.

Thanks for this topnotch article and I hope to read many more in the coming days.

Andrew

P WARE
1 month ago

Given your position, I’d love to get your opinion (if you are allowed to express)of Pension Plans investments into Private Credit and Private Equity. Their risk to investors and Pension Plans is just now becoming public.

John Goodell
1 month ago
Reply to  P WARE

I left the Pension Review Board, in part, because it became clear to me that the state of Texas and its various municipalities had no interest adopting the Nevada state pension approach of indexing (despite or perhaps because it would cost taxpayers less in terms of government salaries let alone superior returns from indexing). When I pushed on this topic, eyes rolled and ultimately, it was too hard to convince certain powers that be that special interests who wine, dine and contribute to campaigns weren’t very good at delivering returns. Ultimately, teachers, fire fighters, municipal workers etc are the losers as are the taxpayers who cover the shortfall when the failure is big enough. Active management has never delivered superior returns for any retirement system in Texas of any meaningful scale over any meaningful time period, and yet the willful desire to the look the other way was as ever present as it was discouraging.

Patrick Brennan
1 month ago

Great article. I’ll tell you one thing I don’t miss in retirement and that is solving work problems under pressure. There may be a cognitive benefit, but for me the absence of that stress in retirement seems a whole lot better.

Glad to have you back John and I look forward to many more of your articles.

Mark Crothers
1 month ago

John, please don’t take this as criticism: I found the premise and arguments in your article self-evident, and I mean that as a compliment. In my experience, most successful retirements rest on a loose framework of the ideas you set out. My own experience, and that of many others on this site, bears this out. Money is only the enabler; social interaction, friendships and personal interests are the bones that keep a good retirement on the road.

I enjoyed the article, and I’m glad you’ve eased off the gas in your own working life. I wish you every success in maintaining a better work/life balance. I look forward to reading more of your writing on Humble Dollar.

William Perry
1 month ago

Thanks John. I am bookmarking your article as your observations deserve more than one read.

jan Ohara
1 month ago
Reply to  William Perry

Bill, I would like to do the same. How does one bookmark an article in HD?

William Perry
1 month ago
Reply to  jan Ohara

The web browser I like the best is Firefox where the toolbar has a five pointed star to click when you are on the page you wish to bookmark and then you choose which destination you want the bookmark to be located (e.g. Other Bookmarks for example). Maybe those that favor other browsers will comment on their procedures.

Mark Crothers
1 month ago
Reply to  William Perry

Google Chrome has the same arrangement in the web address bar.

Free Newsletter

Arrives weekly.

Select list(s):
SHARE
HumbleDollar · https://humbledollar.com/2026/10/the-number-is-not-the-answer/ · printed Nov 17, 2026

Create an account

Our readers find logging in to HumbleDollar directly more reliable than going through Google, Disqus, WordPress.com or X.

Already have an account? Don’t make a second one. Log in with the provider you use now, then go to Your Account to set up direct login.

We send a confirmation link here before the account can be used.
Shown beside your comments and forum posts.
Password(Required)
Strength indicator
Accepted file types: jpg, jpeg, png, webp, Max. file size: 5 MB.
Optional. Square images look best. JPG, PNG or WebP.
Optional. Appears on your author page.

Log in