FREE NEWSLETTER

Andrew Forsythe

Please see Andrew's writer's page.

    Forum Posts

    Marcus Savings Bonus Offer

    12 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 1/31/2026
    FIRST: Mark Crothers on 1/31   |   RECENT: Chris Rush on 2/2

    Grocery Shopping for the Mildly Obsessed

    41 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 1/5/2026
    FIRST: OldITGuy on 1/5   |   RECENT: Andrew Forsythe on 1/18

    Home, Auto & Umbrella Insurance---"Longevity Benefit"?

    53 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 1/23/2025
    FIRST: Dan Wick on 1/24/2025   |   RECENT: Patrick Rodrigues on 12/8/2025

    QCDs (and other donations) for Jonathan’s Legacy

    9 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 11/7/2025
    FIRST: Andrew Forsythe on 11/8/2025   |   RECENT: Andrew Forsythe on 11/11/2025

    Seeking Input on Medicare Supplement Carriers

    43 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 7/27/2025
    FIRST: R Quinn on 7/27/2025   |   RECENT: Marti DIY on 11/8/2025

    Is Remembered for…..

    25 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 5/23/2025
    FIRST: Jeff Bond on 5/23/2025   |   RECENT: luvtoride44afe9eb1e on 5/29/2025

    Buying Treasury Bond ETFs vs. MM Funds in this Moment

    18 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 4/10/2025
    FIRST: Ben Rodriguez on 4/10/2025   |   RECENT: Dan Sturgis on 4/20/2025

    What is the risk level of sitting on the sidelines when it comes to bonds?

    7 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 4/10/2025
    FIRST: quan nguyen on 4/10/2025   |   RECENT: Ben Rodriguez on 4/11/2025

    Recommendations for Free Portfolio Analyzer?

    6 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 3/27/2025
    FIRST: G W on 3/28/2025   |   RECENT: Andrew Forsythe on 3/31/2025

    Golden Perks

    43 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 1/4/2025
    FIRST: Dave Melick on 1/4/2025   |   RECENT: Phil Brancazio on 1/11/2025

    Try to Remember

    66 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 11/10/2024
    FIRST: Jonathan Clements on 11/10/2024   |   RECENT: Andrew Forsythe on 11/23/2024

    Wellcare for Part D

    63 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 10/7/2024
    FIRST: R Quinn on 10/7/2024   |   RECENT: Jerry Granderson on 10/19/2024

    Friday the 13th, the Luckiest Day of My Life

    16 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 9/13/2024
    FIRST: Dan Smith on 9/13/2024   |   RECENT: Andrew Forsythe on 9/15/2024

    The Habits of Old Men

    29 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 9/7/2024
    FIRST: mytimetotravel on 9/7/2024   |   RECENT: Andrew Forsythe on 9/8/2024

    Amazon (Almost) for Free

    3 replies

    AUTHOR: Andrew Forsythe on 6/23/2024
    FIRST: Ken Cutler on 6/23/2024   |   RECENT: Jonathan Clements on 6/24/2024

    Comments

    • Jim, you may well be correct and I freely admit this topic is pretty much over my head. I went back and looked at some long ago notes and found a copy of a discussion in the "Accountant Forums" where it was stated: When the mutual fund you invested in (Vanguard Total International Stock Index Fund) buys and sells stocks at a gain or loss, it is U.S. source income. When a foreign stock pays a dividend, that is foreign source income. Just now I posed the question to Google's AI, and got a similar response: Capital gains distributions from foreign-investing U.S. mutual funds/ETFs are generally not included as income on Form 1116 in the same way as foreign dividends. These distributions are usually treated as U.S. source long-term capital gains, reported on Schedule D (Form 1040), because they result from the fund selling assets, not foreign withholding on income. So beats me. I'm just hoping/expecting that whatever FreeTaxUSA comes up with is right!

      Post: Taxes on foreign stocks

      Link to comment from February 20, 2026

    • Bill, thanks for your detailed reply. I used FreeTaxUSA for the first time last year and it handled the Form 1116 painlessly, for which I was most grateful. I suppose the IRS could one day question their calculation, but at least I can say I was in good faith in relying on it.

      Post: Taxes on foreign stocks

      Link to comment from February 20, 2026

    • Jim, Form 1116 is bad enough but I can wade through it. What concerns me is qualifying for the "adjustment exception." If you don't qualify, just a quick preview of the diabolical calculations involved triggers the beginnings of that migraine I referenced. One of the requirements for qualifying for the adjustment exception (per Form 1116 Instructions) is: The amount of your foreign source capital gain distributions plus the amount of your foreign source qualified dividends is less than $20,000. I want to remain under that threshold; hence, my limiting the amount of foreign holdings I have in my taxable accounts. Incidentally, my understanding is that while dividends count as foreign income, capital gain distributions do not. So, including CGDs in figuring eligibility for the adjustment exception, as per the IRS language above, seems odd.

      Post: Taxes on foreign stocks

      Link to comment from February 20, 2026

    • Michael, I'm not sure about just ignoring the foreign tax paid. As to claiming only the $600 credit, I actually thought about doing that one year so as to avoid the Form 1116. But the Form 1116 Instructions caused me to believe that wasn't allowed.

      Post: Taxes on foreign stocks

      Link to comment from February 20, 2026

    • You make a good point that having your international funds or ETFs in a taxable account gets you the foreign tax credit. One thing I've come across, though, is that once you exceed a certain amount in foreign holdings in a taxable account, the calculation required to figure the foreign tax credit is migraine inducing. I long did our tax returns by hand with no software (dinosaur, I know). The above issue had me keeping much of my VXUS in my SIMPLE IRA and Roth accounts. Now that I'm a happy user of FreeTaxUSA, maybe I shouldn't worry so much. I'm hoping Bill Perry or one of our other tax pros might weigh in on this one.

      Post: Taxes on foreign stocks

      Link to comment from February 15, 2026

    • Heidi, thanks for your post and your wit. I look forward to more of both in the future.

      Post: Yes, I am a NIIT wit

      Link to comment from February 11, 2026

    • Dennis, I likewise often think about Jonathan. I greatly value the personal interactions I had with him in the course of contributing a few articles. Having him as an "editor" was a thrill as well as a great learning experience. These days whenever I write some long winded letter, post, or email, he's still right there to remind me to shorten, simplify, and get to the point!

      Post: Value of Waiting

      Link to comment from February 7, 2026

    • Rick, I miss seeing you around here. Your comments have always been the voice of reason....and kindness. Hope you'll pay a visit soon. Andrew

      Post: Many Words Later

      Link to comment from February 6, 2026

    • Thanks.

      Post: Less Paper, More Fraud

      Link to comment from February 3, 2026

    • Dan, that's wild. Thanks for the heads up. And Magoo, thanks for the article link. I had not heard of this massive scheme at all.

      Post: Less Paper, More Fraud

      Link to comment from February 3, 2026

    Articles

    Retirement Dreams

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Feb 20, 2024

    THIS ISN’T ANOTHER article about dreaming of retirement. Rather, it’s about dreaming in retirement.
    I retired in 2017 after practicing criminal law in central Texas for almost four decades. It could be stressful at times. Before that, there were long years in college and law school.
    College was relatively easygoing and enjoyable in the laid-back Austin of the 1970s, plus my major was sociology—a world apart from those in pre-med,

    Cooking Up a Kitchen

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Feb 6, 2024

    I’VE WRITTEN BEFORE about the financial benefits of learning to cook and then preparing meals at home, rather than frequently eating out. I still heartily endorse that notion. Still, our recent decision to remodel our kitchen can’t be defended as a wise financial choice.
    In fact, the consensus is that almost all remodeling jobs result in an increase in home value that’s less than the remodeling project’s cost, and that includes kitchen renovations. Instead,

    Getting Off Lightly

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Dec 15, 2022

    I’VE BEEN A WITNESS to inflation with every trip to our neighborhood H-E-B grocery store. As various articles have pointed out, inflation can disproportionately hurt retirees. Yet recently I stumbled on a piece that argued the reverse, at least for some of us. I think my wife and I fall into that lucky category, and I’m curious if other HumbleDollar readers feel the same.
    We own our home free and clear, so there are no rent increases to worry about and no mortgage to pay.

    Booking It

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Dec 10, 2022

    I SPENT 40 YEARS practicing criminal law, and there was always a lot to read: police reports, lab reports, probation and pre-sentence reports, motions, orders and court opinions. These were required reading and there was little time left to read for pleasure.
    One of the great joys of retirement is the freedom to read a lot—and whatever I choose.
    Which, in this season of reflecting on the things we’re thankful for, brings me to one of mine: public libraries.

    Heightened Interest

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Nov 14, 2022

    I TEND TO KEEP MORE cash than the average investor, so the recent rise in interest rates paid on savings has my attention. In fact, 2022’s pitiful performance by bonds has caused me to shift even more money into cash.
    We have online savings accounts at CIT Bank, Synchrony, Marcus and American Express. CIT is currently paying 3.25%, Synchrony 3%, Marcus 3% and American Express 2.75%. The rates have climbed so frequently this year that they’ll probably be higher by the time you read this.

    Hear, Hear

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Sep 19, 2022

    I TURNED 70 THIS YEAR, and decided to finally do something about the hearing loss I’ve experienced over the past few years. In other words, get hearing aids.
    I asked my older sister for advice. She told me she ended up spending $4,000 to $5,000 for her hearing aids a few years ago. She also said she wishes she’d asked her friends for advice first.
    My sister doesn’t consider herself wealthy but has a few friends who are.

    What’s Cooking?

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Sep 10, 2022

    COUNTLESS ARTICLES on HumbleDollar speak of the need to save, especially for those early in their careers, so they can eventually retire in comfort. The powerful effect of compounding means that the sooner those dollars are saved and invested, the greater the sum down the road.
    But where can folks find those extra savings? Let me offer a suggestion: learn to cook.
    The amount Americans of all income levels spend on eating out,

    Fashion Statement

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Jun 30, 2022

    I’VE PREVIOUSLY written about the dramatic turn my life took when I went from carefree bachelor to husband and proud father of four. With multiple college educations looming, I drastically curtailed my spending, including on my professional wardrobe.
    Initially, instead of the Hickey Freeman suits in which I’d previously indulged, I was happy with the latest sale at Jos. A. Bank. But eventually, I dipped my toe in uncharted waters—buying clothes on eBay.
    This comes with risks.

    MOO for Me

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Jun 22, 2022

    I’VE WRITTEN BEFORE about stumbling on an unexpected way to save on auto insurance. My education continues: I’ve also learned of a way to save on Medigap coverage.
    When I became eligible five years ago for Medicare, I bought Medigap Plan G supplemental coverage from Mutual of Omaha (MOO). Last summer, as my wife was about to become eligible for Medicare, we took another look at Medigap coverage. I was generally happy with MOO’s claims procedures and customer service,

    Following Through

    Andrew Forsythe   |  Mar 27, 2022

    THERE ARE MANY virtues, but one of the rarest is persistence in following through. In our complicated world, often you can’t get something done on the first go. Instead, you have to revisit the task, sometimes more than once. This is true not just of financial decisions but also many other aspects of our lives.
    In fact, if you’re trying to get folks to do something, often their first defense is to stall—because they know that,

    SHARE