FREE NEWSLETTER

Alphabet Soup

Marjorie Kondrack

MOST PEOPLE ON Medicare report that they’re very satisfied with their health care coverage—but the program is undoubtedly complicated. There’s an alphabet soup of plans, coverage choices, premium levels and enrollment rules.

While it’s easy to be flummoxed by the ins and outs of Medicare, think of it as “eating an elephant.” The only way to start is one bite at a time. Learn the basics first—by deciding whether you want original Medicare or Medicare Advantage.

Original Medicare has these parts: Part A is for aggravation and Part B is for bureaucracy. Meanwhile, C is for confusion, better known as Medicare Advantage—which seems to have lots of disadvantages. And then we come to D, for the donut hole.

What happens when you come to the donut hole? Are the donuts glazed? Or do they have sprinkles? Just who is responsible for this incomprehensible concept? It had me crying in my alphabet soup.

Got the basics down? If you decide on original Medicare, you may wish to add a Medigap supplemental insurance plan, which involves a dizzying array of standardized plan options with more alphabet designations and varying degrees of coverage.

I’ll make it easy for you, and save you the hassle of figuring out the whole Medigap alphabet. You won’t even have to read the Medicare for Dummies book. Plan F exists, but it’s not open to new enrollees. Plans G and N are the most popular, with plan G being the most comprehensive. Plan N has co-pays which can easily add up and surpass what you think you might be saving in premiums. Pick your poison and try not to pull out too much hair.

It’s also easy to confuse the Medicare parts with the Medigap plans, as well as the premiums with the deductibles and co-pays. Just when you think you have a reasonable grasp of the whole shebang, you have to deal with all the companies that are providers of the various plans, each one saying they’re better than the others.

If you’re new to Medicare, your mailbox will be flooded with offers. This will happen automatically once you near the magical Medicare age of 65. If you have decided on original Medicare, just pitch all the Medicare Advantage offers. If you decide on Medicare Advantage, you’ll need to navigate all the competing possibilities—in my area, there are 35 major carriers offering Medicare Advantage plans—but at least you can toss all the Medigap plan offers.

Apologies to those who thought this article was a comprehensive guide through the Medicare maze, especially to our editor who prefers articles giving more detailed information. But I leave that to other HumbleDollar contributors, who have handled that task more admirably than I could.

Start slowly. Gather information. It’ll all fall into place eventually, preferably before Medicare madness sets in. As for me, I’m an information junkie, but writing about Medicare is giving me a headache. I think I need a donut.

Browse Articles

Subscribe
Notify of
33 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
OBX9397
1 year ago

Marjorie,
 
Today, I needed a good dose of just what you provided. I plan to go get a donut this afternoon and offer up a toast to you as I enjoy it.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  OBX9397

Thanks, OBX. Donuts are guaranteed to lighten your day. Enjoy.

David Lancaster
1 year ago

Comment on an article last week by a HD reader:
It’s easier to do brain surgery than to comply with IRS rules and guidelines.

My reply:

That’s because of the “brain surgeons” who write and pass the laws! 🙂

Ditto for Medicare

BTW: The worst part about part D is you can use the excellent Medicare site to input your medications to find the most affordable plan, but the government allows the insurance companies to drop a medication in the middle of the contract year 🤷

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago

Thanks for your comments, David. Unfortunately dropped drugs are on the rise.
I have had good luck using discount websites like Blink and Good. RX Also your doctor can ask insurance company to request an exception, according to Medicare Rights. Consumer Reports had an excellent article —when your insurer drops your prescription drug.
Nothing is easy. It can be frustrating.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago

Link: Consumer Reports/when your insurer drops your prescription drug

David Lancaster
1 year ago

Thanks, and for others HD readers info another good source of low cost meds is costplusdrugs.com which is Mark Cuban’s organization

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago

👌

R Quinn
1 year ago

It takes a bit of homework for sure. The Medicare website contains a good explanation of all of the moving parts – which are too complicated. The two worst parts are Medicare Advantage and Part D.

Part D is incredibly complex with all the variables and virtually incomprehensible because of that. Selecting a plan is a gamble because what is the best deal depends on the medication a person takes or will take in the future. There are just too many unnecessary choices in plan design.

Medicare Advantage can be likened to a big con game if you view the advertising. Some MA plans us deductibles and co-pays rarely talked about and all use provider networks and managed care. The allure of low or no premiums can be risky.

If anyone asked me I’d say Medigap Plan G is the way to go.

Adding to all this confusion is the Medigap and MA plans are regulated by the states in addition to federal control so there are variable by states.

The whole thing is a good example of politicians trying to keep everyone with a vested interest happy.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  R Quinn

Hi Dick…thanks for sharing your knowledge.
Things do get a little heavy and intense at times,
so i try to lighten things up once in awhile
with a different viewpoint.

Mark Schwartz
1 year ago

OMG, I’m still laughing. Brings to mind Who’s on first, What’s on second and I don’t knows on third…the Medicare merry go round..

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  Mark Schwartz

Glad you got a few laughs,Mark. I’m not a jokester, per se but my mind thinks of funny situations. . Thanks for commenting.

mytimetotravel
1 year ago

That was a fun read! I still recommend Original Medicare with Medigap Plan G, if you can afford it. Plus a drug plan, a dental plan, a vision plan….

OldITGuy
1 year ago
Reply to  mytimetotravel

I agree with your recommendation for Original Medicare with Medigap Plan G. The only thing I’d add is for the shopper to be aware of when comparing policy costs is whether the policy being considered is “Community-Rated”, “Issue-Age-Rated”, or “Attained-Age-Rated”. Just make sure you know what you’re buying, and how the costs will change as you age. For example, a Plan G policy at 65 that’s Attained-Age-Rated will probably be relatively inexpensive at 65, but may be cost prohibitive at 90, especially if the surviving spouse may be trying to live on a reduced household social security income due to the loss of a spouse. I suspect most readers of HD are well aware of this, but thought I’d mention it just to be safe. 

R Quinn
1 year ago
Reply to  mytimetotravel

Dental and vision plans require a close look. Rarely are they a good buy compared with putting the equivalent of the premium aside to self- insure. My former employer offered them to 65+ retirees (retiree pay all). Many retirees jumped at the choice, but the next year most (including me) dropped the coverage when they figured out that plan limits would prevent added value over premiums.

mytimetotravel
1 year ago
Reply to  R Quinn

I agree that dental coverage is generally minimal. However, I pay $14/month for VSP and highly recommend it. The ophthalmology practice I’m going to later this month seemed to think it was a good deal too. https://www.vsp.com/

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  mytimetotravel

They are the best choice Kathy. And the older we get, the more relevant it becomes. Very few of us get through the Senior years unscathed by the vagaries of advancing age.

Thanks for your knowledgeable input.

Marilyn Lavin
1 year ago

My husband and I are retired and have dental insurance. We have coverage for the “small stuff” (cleanings, xrays, fillings) as part of our medigap insurance. We also pay $64 a month for an additional policy that covers major work — root canals, crowns, extractions, etc. I think it’s a good deal. So far this year, I’ve had to have a crown because some decay was detected under an ancient filling. The insurance covered more of the cost of that procedure than we will pay for the year’s insurance. In addition, my husband had an extraction and is in the process of getting an implant. The insurance will pay about half the cost of the implant. We’ve had the insurance for the seven years we’ve been retired. Our benefits every year have outweighed the cost. Keeping “old teeth” in good condition is pricey. I know people who are postponing dental visits. Probably not a good idea.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  Marilyn Lavin

Marilyn..thanks so much for relating your experience with dental insurance. I think we all want to know more about the pros and cons. You are so right about keeping teeth in good condition.Seniors encounter many problems with teeth because of medications they may need to take, osteoporosis, chemotherapy, dry mouth and so on. Major dental work does seem to occur later in life. It’s a constant battle to keep up but well worth the effort and good to know dental insurance can take the sting out of expensive dental treatments.

ostrichtacossaturn7593

As a 63 1/2 year old getting up to speed on Medigap choices, I’d love a resource on reliable advice for choosing between attained age, issue age, and community pricing policies. A Plan G issue age Medicap policy in my zip code runs $140/mo. “Issue age” means the premium is determined at the “issue age” (which will be 65 in my case), and is only supposed to go up by inflation and loss experience, whereas “attained age” means the premium increases annually based on your “attainted age” as well as inflation and loss experience. “Community pricing” means everyone pays the same premium regardless of age, which doesn’t sound attractive for someone in the younger/healthier side of Medicare ages. Anyone correct me if this does not sound right.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago

See also my reply to Andrew below.

Andrew Forsythe
1 year ago

Excellent point and one so little discussed. Before I started on Medicare, I thought I’d read a lot, but I didn’t learn about attained age vs. Issue age vs. community pricing till a couple of years later. Even the broker I used didn’t mention it.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago

Andrew..most companies offering medigap plans only offer attained age option. The rating system for calculating premiums is based on your age when you sign up for the plan.
The younger you are at enrollment the lower your premium. But your premiums increase as you get older.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago

A good source for information on all medigap questions would be your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP). You can find the telephone number and addresses for local offices on your State’s website, usually under the Division of Aging. They have volunteers who can answer your questions and guide you with your needs.

Good luck

Mike Gaynes
1 year ago

That you produced a smile from me on this subject is quite an achievement, because I’m experiencing my first donut hole right now. My insulin pump just went up 6X. I am grumpy. Seriously grumpy.

mytimetotravel
1 year ago
Reply to  Mike Gaynes

At least next year you won’t have to pay anything if you make it to catastrophic coverage, and the following year your drug costs will be capped at $2,000. Always provided the law isn’t changed before then….

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  Mike Gaynes

Mike…you’re entitled to feel grumpy. So glad that through it all you managed a smile. Best wishes to you.

William Perry
1 year ago

This was a fun read for me. Thanks for putting a smile on my face.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  William Perry

Thanks, Mr. Perry, for validating my intention
and for your comments.

Winston Smith
1 year ago

One of my wife’s cousins worked in the Insurance industry all his life.

He used an agent who SPECIALIZES in medicare.

We also used him and are extremely pleased with his recommendations and results.

Of course … YMMV

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  Winston Smith

up to date,accurate information from a qualified Medicare expert can be a big help in helping to choose the best plan for your needs and offering you objective, personal enrollment advice.
it pays to look into available resources.
Thanks for sharing your experience.

jerry pinkard
1 year ago

My wife went on Medicare a year before I did. I had to sign her up. I was amazed at all the different options and their complexity. One of my core competencies was contract negotiations and administration. So I was used to complex agreements, but it took me a while to sort out all of her Medicare options.

People need to do their own research to determine what is best for them. Do not rely on recommendations from friends because their needs may be different and they may not have done their research.

Mike Gaynes
1 year ago
Reply to  jerry pinkard

Jerry, your primary provider of specialized care can be a great source of a recommendation as well. They know who is good to work with and who isn’t, who’s responsive and who isn’t, who delivers on their promises and who doesn’t. Once I decided to go Advantage, I sat down with a finance specialist at UW Medicine. He was delighted to offer his feedback on various companies.

Marjorie Kondrack
1 year ago
Reply to  jerry pinkard

Good advice, Jerry. It does require a lot of thought. Just thought I’d have some fun with the absurdities. Thanks for commenting.

Free Newsletter

SHARE