FREE NEWSLETTER

Forum › Cars

Is buying a used car always the smarter financial choice?

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
18 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Susanne Krivit
3 years ago

Every time a buy a car I look around to see the best way to buy it. I have bought new and used over the years. I keep cars until they become unreliable. My current car is leased. This is the first time I have leased. The deal was just too hard to pass up, plus it is electric and I liked the idea of having a “3 year trial” before I bought it. I do plan to buy it in 5 months when the 3 year lease is up.

Frank Stanford
3 years ago

Generally, yes, but of course it depends on the price. We’ve all seen folks over-pay for a used vehicle. Car fever is real. It takes time and patience to find that great deal. I’ve bought one new vehicle in my life. A 2002 Ford Ranger. After 21 years, I still drive it every day. If you’re going to keep it a long time, the price of new vs used doesn’t matter much. Cars are like Wives, it’s always cheaper to keep her. I kept her too.

Captain FI
3 years ago

Absolutely! I think its madness that a brand new car depreciates by 20% the moment you drive it off the lot. I think the sweet spot is around the 3 year old mark

Klaatu
3 years ago

I follow the conventional wisdom of buying a used vehicle at least three years old. Only new vehicle I ever bought was a motorcycle for cash and lost money on it even after selling only a year later. Think what is comes down to is whether a loan is taken out and since loans on new cars are likely higher (than on used), one is bound to lose more money buying new.

Roboticus Aquarius
4 years ago

I’ve done both.

If I have the resources, and expect to hold onto the car at least 15 years, I like to buy new. I can get exactly what I want, with the latest safety features, ensure timely maintenance, and I can baby the car. We’ve done this twice: 20 years and 301K miles, 17 years and 276K miles.

If not, a used car can be a great option. I like used Toyotas with 100K miles on them. There are usually some expenses with used cars beyond the purchase price, so I try to include a couple grand of repairs in my budget. It’s especially great when you have kids. A fender bender is no big deal.

I’ve also leased a car, when I wasn’t sure I wanted to own it forever, but did want to try it out. It was a Kia Sportage, which we loved. We returned it, but we are looking into it’s big brother, the Sorento PHEV, and have one reserved.