FREE NEWSLETTER

Howard Rohleder

    Forum Posts

    Comments

    • I've taken the approach of only enrolling in this program in my Roth accounts. This way, taxes are irrelevant. I'm also not concerned about getting payments in lieu of dividends in the event a security is on loan when a dividend is paid.

      Post: Free Lunch?

      Link to comment from October 22, 2026

    • This topic seems to continue to generate continued interest (pun intended) on HD. For kicks, I asked Claude AI which stocks or ETFs generate the most lending income from these programs at Fidelity, Vanguard and Schwab. Here is the response: The money in securities lending comes almost entirely from borrow demand that outstrips available supply. When lots of short sellers want a stock and few shares are available to lend, the borrow fee rises. These are called "hard-to-borrow" stocks, or "specials." Widely held, easy-to-borrow stocks earn close to nothing. What tends to earn the most

      • Heavily shorted stocks. High short interest as a percentage of float is the biggest single driver. Annual borrow fees on these can run from several percent to well over 100% in extreme cases.
      • Small floats and low institutional ownership. Small-caps and micro-caps often have few lendable shares, because index funds and big institutions are the main lenders. Even modest short demand can push their fees up.
      • Recent IPOs and de-SPACs. Supply is limited before lockups expire, and short sellers often target these names, so fees are frequently high.
      • Distressed or controversial companies. This includes firms facing bankruptcy risk, accounting questions, failed drug trials, or a deteriorating business. Pessimism draws short sellers.
      • Meme and retail-favorite stocks. These are often both heavily shorted and volatile, and their rates can swing sharply.
      • Stocks used in hedging strategies.Issuers of convertible bonds: arbitrageurs short the common stock to hedge.
      • Acquirers in stock-for-stock mergers: merger-arb traders short the buyer.
      • Certain ETFs. These include leveraged and inverse ETFs, single-stock ETFs, and some niche or thematic funds, especially ones shorted for hedging or to bet on decay. Broad index ETFs such as S&P 500 funds almost never earn much.
      What earns very little Large, liquid stocks like Apple or Microsoft and major index funds are "general collateral." Their borrow fees are tiny, and once the broker takes its share of the revenue, your cut is often negligible. Things to weigh before enrolling
      • High fees often signal risk. A stock pays a big lending fee because many sophisticated traders expect it to fall. Buying a stock just to collect lending income is usually a losing trade.
      • Rates aren't fixed. They change daily and can collapse quickly if the short squeeze ends or more supply appears.
      • Dividends change form. While shares are on loan, dividends arrive as "payments in lieu." These are generally taxed as ordinary income rather than at the qualified-dividend rate, which matters in taxable accounts.
      • You lose voting rights on lent shares.
      • SIPC coverage works differently. Lent shares generally aren't covered by SIPC, though the programs post collateral.
      • The broker splits the revenue with you, often roughly 50/50. Each firm sets its own split, eligibility rules, and minimum balance. Some only lend shares when there is real demand, so you may earn nothing on a typical portfolio.
      To see which of your holdings might earn something, check whether your broker flags them as hard-to-borrow. Third-party sites that track borrow fees and short interest, such as Fintel, Ortex, or iBorrowDesk, can also help. Fidelity, Schwab, and Vanguard each publish their program terms, which are worth reading closely. I'm not a financial advisor, so treat this as background for your own decision rather than a recommendation.

      Post: Free Lunch?

      Link to comment from October 22, 2026

    • I have continued in the Fidelity program as described in my article. I continue to have zero problems, but the dollar amounts I receive each month have dropped significantly. It seems to be a supply/demand situation and the demand for the ETFs in my account command a much lower interest rate than they did when I wrote the article.

      Post: Securities Lending Fully Paid Program

      Link to comment from October 20, 2026

    • I am a volunteer tax preparer with AARP. A couple years ago I wrote about this topic for my low income clients: Taxing Situations - HumbleDollar. The reason many of them turn to AARP is their lack of understanding of the tax code and the last thing they are thinking about when a spouse dies is the need to increase their withholding.

      Post: Widow Tax

      Link to comment from July 25, 2026

    • "If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs when it's free." --- P.J. O'Rourke, American political satirist and author

      Post: What do we Americans want? We want “free” healthcare

      Link to comment from June 13, 2026

    • I have played with Claude AI with my portfolio and, like your experience, the value came from identifying areas where I had gone on autopilot. The answer you get depends on the question you ask.  I worked with each different account type separately. One day I did our combined Roth holdings; another day I did our combined Traditional IRA holdings, etc. I provided our ages and our goal for that account and uploaded a spreadsheet of my portfolio holdings (ticker and balance for each holding). There was nothing in what I provided that identified us, although I guess AI could link them to my sign in??  The first account I loaded consisted of mutual funds. I asked for a critique of the portfolio without giving criteria. The response was almost exclusively focused on fees. For example, I had a highly rated active fund in a specialty area that has consistently out performed its peers. The recommendation was to exchange it for an index fund because of the high fees. I asked Claude to reconsider, looking back at past performance and Morningstar analysis. It changed the recommendation to “continue to hold.” As I loaded in other accounts, I made sure to ask for the evaluation to include fees and performance. There were other areas where I questioned the recommendations. I had other instances where the recommendations changed, as well as some where Claude stuck to its guns. The value was in the dialog. The lesson is that you need to know why you are holding a specific fund or stock and push back if you think AI is missing something. I was very impressed with the detail of the recommendations and the downloadable spreadsheets it provided. I was dismayed when I found multiple math errors. When I challenged the errors, they were corrected but my first thought was how can I trust the big picture ideas if it can’t add 2+2.  A comment in Gary Klotz’s recent post ChatGPT’s Portfolio Advice - HumbleDollar referred to an outside article evaluating AI for portfolio analysis. The author made it clear that AI programs are not calculators and they are likely to make math errors.  I realized that I have a spreadsheet to do the math. What I’m looking for is a dialog about the big picture issues. Claude gave me that. The biggest eye opener was in a Vanguard IRA account that I have neglected. I had accumulated the money prior to retirement in the STAR fund and have just left it there. It has grown nicely, but Claude pointed out that I could save a substantial amount in fees each year if I invested in the component funds rather than the blended fund. It specifically recommended a portfolio of funds to replicate the STAR holdings without having to buy them all.  I felt that the first portfolio Claude recommended was missing the small/midcap space. It went back to the STAR holdings and concurred. Then it produced a new portfolio and a transition plan for me to move my investments. A future project is to load in all my accounts together to look for overlap across the various accounts as well as to get asset location recommendations for different account types.

      Post: How to Use AI With Your Portfolio

      Link to comment from June 9, 2026

    • One of our AARP volunteers harps on the raw deal (as he perceives it) that gamblers get when trying to offset wins with losses. I'd like to hope that, to the extent the taxpayer understands the tax treatment, it discourages gambling. Is it good public policy for the non-gambling public to subsidize gambling losses?

      Post: Taxes Season 3

      Link to comment from April 12, 2026

    • In the post that Rick provided, I am a Tax Counselor. The first year, I went to 6 day-long sessions with AARP volunteer trainers at a nearby college during their winter break. There were also problems to do at home. After that, you must pass a proficiency test, an ethics test and a technology test. Each subsequent year, there is a one-day refresher training with more homework problems. Again, there are three tests to pass. This all sounds intimidating but there is a lot of support from the leaders and lots of peer support. You are never on your own when you are preparing taxes. Every return you prepare is reviewed by another counselor, regardless of how much experience you have. If you run up against a difficult situation, there is a lot of experience in the room to sort it out. As far as qualifications, you simply need to have an aptitude for and an interest in doing taxes. There are former CPAs and former paid tax preparers in the group, but there are also plenty of others who just want to help. To get started, I sent an inquiry through the AARP volunteer website and got a call within a couple of days from the District Coordinator where I live. He asked about my interest, explained the program and told me about the commitment.

      Post: Taxes Season 3

      Link to comment from April 11, 2026

    • Lack of transparency, greatly reduced liquidity, higher fees. What could go wrong?

      Post: Private Credit Stress?

      Link to comment from March 28, 2026

    • I was slow to coming around to indexing. I have had made good selections with active funds and bad. More and more of my portfolio is indexed. This shift will tilt me significantly to index funds.

      Post: Once Burned, Twice Shy

      Link to comment from March 6, 2026

    Articles

    Many Unhappy Returns

    Howard Rohleder   |  Jun 19, 2024

    I WAS INSPIRED BY Rick Connor and other HumbleDollar contributors to sign up for the AARP’s volunteer-run Tax-Aide program. After completing 48 hours of training at a local college and passing the required tests, I volunteered two days a week at two different senior centers. I completed my first tax season in April.

    Two clients, with whom I spent extra time, stood out. The first was a widow in her late 60s whose husband had always handled their finances.

    Getting in Line

    Howard Rohleder   |  Mar 29, 2024

    WE RECENTLY MADE a down payment on our next home. After several months of research, we joined the waiting list for a continuing care retirement community, or CCRC.
    We’re in our late 60s and only relocated to our current home four years ago. It’s in a metropolitan area two hours’ drive from our daughter and her young family. We know that perhaps 10 years or so from now, we’ll want to be closer to her,

    Make Them Good Years

    Howard Rohleder   |  Jan 4, 2024

    MANY YEARS AGO, a Wall Street Journal article quoted a source as saying, and I paraphrase, “Young-old age should last as long as possible, while old-old age should last 15 minutes.” Those of us who have visited nursing homes can all relate to this.
    Public health initiatives and medical breakthroughs have extended lifespans significantly over the past 100 years. In his bestselling book Outlive: The Science and Art of Longevity, Peter Attia argues that we should focus not just on lifespan,

    Forget the Check

    Howard Rohleder   |  Dec 10, 2023

    THE HOLIDAY SEASON used to be a time when we’d write and mail more checks than usual. Some were gifts to family, while others were year-end charitable donations. But with the rise in mail theft and check washing, we’ve been on a campaign to limit the number of checks we write, plus we’ve almost eliminated the mailing of checks. Here are eight things we’ve done to reduce our exposure to check fraud:

    We opened a secondary no-fee checking account and opted out of the overdraft protection.

    Look All Ways

    Howard Rohleder   |  Nov 20, 2023

    WHAT HAPPENS WHEN you’re hit by the proverbial beer truck? Will it be easy for others to pick up the pieces—the pieces of your financial life, that is?
    To my knowledge, my wife isn’t checking the delivery schedule for the Anheuser-Busch brewery here in Columbus, Ohio. Still, she’s worried about the complexities of our finances. I’ve made a concerted effort since I retired to consolidate and close financial accounts, reduce our investments holdings, and streamline where it makes sense.

    Location, Location

    Howard Rohleder   |  Oct 12, 2023

    WANT TO IMPROVE YOUR portfolio’s long-run performance? You could boost your stock allocation—something I wrote about last year—or cut your investment costs. But don’t overlook another key strategy: thinking carefully about which accounts you use to hold your various investments, or what financial experts call “asset location.”
    My wife and I have taxable accounts, Roth IRAs, traditional IRAs and a health savings account. Earnings in each account get different tax treatment both now and in the future.

    Pin Money

    Howard Rohleder   |  Aug 25, 2023

    I’M OLD ENOUGH TO remember when companies rewarded employee anniversaries with lapel pins. The number of years you served determined the quality of the metal and how many jewels were embedded in the pin.
    I also remember when two different hospitals where I worked moved away from this practice in the 1980s and 1990s. Human resources departments came to realize that many employees didn’t value the pins. Perhaps there had been a day when pins were something people wore,

    College in Retirement

    Howard Rohleder   |  Jun 29, 2023

    I RECENTLY COMPLETED a course called England: From the Fall of Rome to the Norman Conquest. Before that was Books That Matter: The Federalist Papers. Okay, I’m a nerd, I’ll admit it.
    Since I retired, I’ve looked for avenues to broaden and deepen my understanding of subjects that I was taught in high school and at the liberal arts college I attended. Back then, there were college courses,

    The Mary Jean List

    Howard Rohleder   |  May 25, 2023

    MY FATHER-IN-LAW Carson was a stereotypical engineer—organized and precise. All four of his children know the motto “measure twice, cut once.” Carson applied these traits to his finances, which he managed on behalf of himself and Mary Jean, his wife. Mary Jean depended on this.
    As they aged, Carson maintained his mental acuity, but he was the first of the two to deteriorate physically. Mary Jean was strong physically but slowly surrendered to Alzheimer’s.

    Powering Up

    Howard Rohleder   |  May 5, 2023

    SPRING TURNS A MAN’S fancy to… wait for it… outdoor power tools. Every April, I’d haul out the gas mower to prep it for the summer season. That meant a trip to the hardware store for oil, a spark plug and an air filter. Then I drove to the gas station for some new fuel.
    For an hour, I would pretend that I understood the manly art of maintaining an internal combustion engine. I would gap and change the spark plug,