FREE NEWSLETTER

Forum › Spending

Dickies simplistic view of personal finances

Can someone explain the value of tracking expenses in detail? Seems to me expenses are either routine and ongoing or they are voluntary or unexpected. If they are unexpected, they can’t be predicted in any case. 

Some people say they need to know what they spend. What you spend is easy. It is the difference between your net income (after taxes and saving) and what you have left the day before for the next payday or end of the month. Can it be anything else – except if you live on credit, of course, in which case you probable don’t want to know what you spend anyway.

Do you need a budget? Why? Your budget is set by saving first, and never ending a month with a unpaid credit card balance. Spend the difference any way you like. In a month or so you will know what life style your income can sustain. If it is not the life you want then you must increase your income or look for what spending must change …as I write this in my local Starbucks.

Am I exaggerating the simplicity? No doubt many people think so, but look closely, what am I missing?

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
12 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Jack Hannam
6 hours ago

We too limited our spending to what remained after taxes and savings, and not incurring credit card debt and we did not need a budget. After a few years though, we found that a spending plan, or “budget” helped us to spend that cash more efficiently. So not required, but we prefer using one.

You mentioned unexpected expenses. As you know, some authors in the financial media refer to future expenses such as a new roof, replacement of HVAC, and others as “unexpected”. Unpredictable yes, but not unexpected. We guesstimate what these future costs might be, whenever they might occur and escrow away cash. As for any actual unexpected expenses, like anyone else the best we can do is to spend our assets prudently and hope for the best.

Last edited 5 hours ago by Jack Hannam
David Lancaster
7 hours ago

I agree wholeheartedly Dick if you have regular income. As I have written we are utilizing our retirement accounts to pay bills while awaiting claiming Social Security in ‘28. But still I don’t track expenses. We are frugal by nature and have no debt. Every expense that can go on the credit card without a surcharge does. Each month the bill comes in and we pay it. Every quarter I tally up our year to date withdrawls from our retirement accounts. This is done mostly to be sure we don’t exceed the 12% tax bracket. And that’s it. I don’t tally up the credit card bills quarterly because the withdrawls tell me how much we have spent including occasional teller withdrawls for a little jingle in our pockets/purse.

Again, I follow Thoreau’s philosophy of: Simplicity, Simplicity, Simplicity.

Last edited 7 hours ago by David Lancaster
S Phillips
8 hours ago

I find it enjoyable to Track spending. Sort of like how some people find jigsaw puzzles or crossword puzzles enjoyable.