We have multiple insurance programs – based on age and income, there are differences among the states, who pays how much is a mess – many seniors pay more than younger Americans at the same income level.
Enrollment periods and rules differ by type of coverage. Out of pocket costs frequently ignore ability to pay. Employers try to mask costs via FSAs, HSAs and HRAs – if you can afford to contribute. Trying to deal with out-of-pocket costs jeopardizes the ability to save for retirement.
We allow drug companies to market directly to consumers driving demand and costs and perhaps creating health risks.
Allowable fees paid to providers for the same service vary greatly depending on the source of payment – Medicaid, Medicare, employer coverage, private pay – thus causing cost shifting and an unfair distribution of costs to patients.
Employers continue to shift costs to workers sometimes offsetting raises.
We make our disconnected approach so confusing few can figure it out.
Make an attempt at change and we hear the cry “socialized medicine” which is nonsense as we are talking about a payment system not health care delivery system.
I hear people from other countries talk about their much better “free” healthcare system. Of course, it is not free, but the very fact they feel that way tells us the perceived value of paying via taxes and not at the point of service. Everyone is in the same risk pool.
Why can’t America do better? I don’t expect to see significant change in my lifetime, but someday we may see the light.
Sorry, there is no valid argument against a universal USA health insurance system. We have tinkered with our system since the 1960s and I was involved in trying change after change to manage costs, nothing has worked. Nothing has assured universal coverage.
I once lobbied Congress against the Clinton health care plan, I was wrong. Will any universal system be perfect? Certainly not. Will there be tradeoffs? Absolutely!
But if our system works fine for people like me – aside from premiums over $2,000 a month for us – it doesn’t for tens of millions of others young and old and the cost shifting to the middle class is getting worse.
Our goals should be universal insurance coverage, uniform management of costs, fair distribution of costs and no variations based on where you live.
I would like to see serious tuition help for medical students as the debt where I live is preventing them from buying into practices. Our PCP is overloaded with patients. Also, raises in Medicare should be included in the Social Security COLA, rather than erasing the small increases we get. We are anxiously awaiting the promised 2025 cap on Part D of Medicare, as it runs us about $8K/year and we have good insurance!
to understand how convoluted and “weird” our healthcare system is in terms of who and how we pay listen to the podcast an arm and a leg. It’s surreal at times what people have to go through. One hint is clear there are profits being earned by big corporations that are not adding a penny to the quality of healthcare. I’m not sure what the answer is since to change anything you have to pass laws but these corporations make huge political contributions.
Keep in mind that in places where there are perceived
long waits for health care services as in Canada and the UK there is budgeting intended to manage costs, but which also limits available services in some cases. Medicare does not do that, but attempts to manage cost by limiting payable fees.
No matter what, the open access and generally readily availability of healthcare resources Americans want and expect will always be expensive.
For example the US has 38 MRIs per million population, Canada has 10. The UK 8.6 Only Japan has more than the US.
So easier access, more spending. Also, scanners are expensive so to pay for them they have to be used – who creates the demand?
No valid argument against universal health insurance, huh? I admire your confidence. You may find of interest a concept called “steel-manning,” where instead of exposing the weakest possible argument against your position, you deliberately discuss the opposing side’s strongest case.
My dad’s from a communist country that has universal health insurance and their health care is terrible. Have you ever wondered why the richest people from all over the world come to the US for care? They don