FREE NEWSLETTER

Articles › In Retirement

Can’t Go On

WHEN I WAS IN HIGH school, I had a summer job at a machine shop. My job was to deburr large cutting tools known as end mills. I would take a penny and run it over the cutting edge of the tool to smooth it out. Once I finished my job, the tools were sent to another facility for the next operation.

There was a young man in his 20s named Max whose job was to load these heavy boxes of tools onto a truck and transport them to the other facility, where he would unload them. He would do this all day long until one day he never came back from lunch.

I was excited to get Max’s job because I’d just got my driver’s license and I got to drive a truck for the first time. It didn’t take long for reality to set in. I got my first taste of what hard manual labor was like. I spent the rest of the summer soaking my aching body in a warm bath after work.

I was lucky to spend most of my adult life working behind a desk. Not everyone gets to do that. More than 10% of all workers nationally hold physically demanding jobs. In 2002, 29% of workers ages 55 to 60 said they experienced chronic pain in their jobs.

There have been discussions in Congress about how to keep Social Security solvent, including raising the full retirement age to 70. This doesn’t seem fair to laborers who do hard work. Their declining bodies makes it difficult to work longer. In addition, they usually start working relatively young and hence spend more years paying into Social Security.

I admit I don’t have a solution to this conundrum—one that would be fair to all workers. But I know raising the full retirement age isn’t the right answer.

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
9 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
ishabaka
5 years ago

I had just finished by second year of college and wasn’t sure I wanted to finish, when I got a summer job in a factory that made leaf springs for cars. It was hot, my feet hurt every day from standing on a concrete floor for 9 hours, and the boss was an alcoholic who’d pick one worker to scream at for an hour every day. Made me realize finishing college was worth it.

parkslope
5 years ago
Reply to  ishabaka

I had a similar eye opening experience working a summer job in a hot factory on an assembly line that made car door arm rests.

John Wood
5 years ago

The Social Security “solvency issue” is a problem of political will, not an economic problem. For 2021, $142,800 of wages is the maximum amount of earned income that one is taxed on. Have every dollar of income taxed (as it is with Medicare), and the amount of additional contribution that will accrue will let the workers who wore out their bodies for income retire at 66 or 67 with no risk to the program’s solvency. The supply-chain bottlenecks we’re seeing today have a lot to do with the lack of people willing to take on physical jobs. The economy needs these workers badly, and they deserve a fair deal.

Philip Stein
5 years ago

I’m not sure I would dismiss raising the retirement age. We all know that Social Security in it’s current form is under financial stress mainly due to people living longer lives than previous generations.

Don’t those workers who suffer physical decline from a lifetime of manual labor get support from the Social Security Disability program?