I’m beginning to feel like I’m sitting on the sideline watching everyone else play. So far, I’ve asked questions (The Quiet Failure of Good Advice), listened to your answers, and fed back what I’ve heard (Reflections on a Quiet Failure). Thank you all again.
But maybe it’s time for me to say what I think.
Both questions I asked in Reflections on a Quiet Failure, in different ways, ask what financial planning is for. Let me share where my own thinking has landed.
My wife and I both feel very happy and proud today – our daughter reached her first major financial goal by buying a car and driving it home this morning.
This may not sound like a big deal, especially for a working lady in her late 20s. To us, it is.
It’s not about the physical possession of a material item. It’s a result of patience, discipline, and a few financial habits that we insisted on early.
I’m planning my first course correction 2.5 years into retirement. I thought I was going to write about Roth conversions, bucket strategies, asset location, and so on. And I am. But it turns out that that’s not the point.
I came late to the HumbleDollar/Bogleheads way of thinking. I’ve been absorbing it all for about 4 years. Thanks to Jonathan, Adam Grossman and all here. I’ve learned a lot, put the advice together into what I think is a coherent plan,
I used AI as an editorial assistant to help organize and refine my thoughts; the underlying ideas and personal experiences remain my own.
Like a lot of engineers, I spent my career solving problems the same way: build a model, gather the data, run the simulations, optimize the result. So when retirement came into view, I did what came naturally. I built spreadsheets—and got back a mountain of output and almost no peace of mind.
Morningstar posted an article by Allan Roth (an investment writer just in the past year) this morning.
He writes the delaying Social Security until 70 and buying a US Treasury TIPS ladder are risk free inflation adjusted alternatives to purchasing an annuity through an insurance company who’s payments generally are not..
https://www.morningstar.com/funds/hidden-risks-income-life-target-date-funds?utm_source=eloqua&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=MorningDigest&utm_content=None_75089&MorningDigestUS&utm_id=39201
Enjoy
“Family. Readers. Words.”
At Jonathan’s memorial service, one of the songs he selected was the Bee Gees’ Words. At the time, I simply thought it was a beautiful melody, a favorite of ours from the Bangladesh days. Only later did I realize how perfectly it captured his life.
A few months before his death, Jonathan wrote the final chapter of his book Money and Me. Knowing his time was limited, he reflected on how he hoped to be remembered.
Recently “core” and “core-plus” actively managed total bond ETFs have become available. A Wall Street Journal “Not All Total Bond Market ETFs Are the Same…” makes many interesting points about managed total bond ETFs, including the point that they have higher returns than index total bond ETFs. Owning only one total bond ETF that returns more than the index makes for an uncomplicated and appealing portfolio. If you want the simplicity of owning only one bond ETF rather than actual bonds or multiple bond ETFs that yield more than the index,
If you’re inclined to create a spreadsheet — and I know that some of you are and some of you aren’t — you can put that spreadsheet directly into an AI program and ask it to analyze what you own. What happens next might surprise you.
Setting Up Your Spreadsheet
Your spreadsheet doesn’t need to be complicated. At minimum, include these columns:
Ticker — the symbol for each holding
Shares — how many you own
Cost per share — your purchase price,
Jonathan’s thought of the day is, If the stock market’s performance over the next five years was miserable, would you be? I thought it might be fun to kick this one around a bit.
Though I am positioned just fine to survive five or even ten years of misery from the market, I still wouldn’t like it. I guess I’m just too used to seeing things go up. So while the nuts and bolts of our life would be fine,
A week ago I posted “The Quiet Failure of Good Advice.” More than two dozen of you replied with experience, candor, and care. Thank you, sincerely. I’ve been thinking about what you wrote, and I wanted to come back and share what I took from it.
A few patterns kept surfacing.
The first is structural. Several of you named the same diagnosis: financial planning as a profession is calibrated to serve the wealthy. Mike Lynch, a retired CFP and longtime industry educator,
A few weeks ago my 27-year-old daughter mentioned she’d been hearing a lot about memecoins. That conversation sparked this text, which I wrote for her first and then revised for HD. I hesitated over the slight political connotation, but on reflection the underlying lesson feels too useful not to share.
Do you remember inauguration week? January 2025 didn’t just mark a political transition, it also launched a brand new cryptocurrency: the $MELANIA memecoin. It arrived with fanfare,
To try to keep up with the 21st century, I recently started to use ChatGPT.
I have an excellent financial advisor, who is a Certified Financial Planner, and for over 40 years, I have also made a lot of investment decisions on a “do-it-yourself” basis. I have read the Humble Dollar for years as well.
An early request to ChatGPT was to develop a training plan for me to help me revive a long-neglected hobby. I was very pleased with the analysis and the specific suggestions that ChatGPT provided to me.
Our children know we are not your typical retirees when it comes to finances. I’m sure they figured that out from our funding eleven 529 plans, gifts and more often than not, picking up the check when families go out to eat, but that’s all they know.
They have no idea of our income, no knowledge of our investments-what kind, or how much. They, of course, know we own two homes, but not our net worth.
I don’t use Instagram. I drive a 21 year old car. Many of my clothes are from the charity shop. I really do spend most of life completely oblivious as to how I compare to others.
But my guilty pleasures are the “See the average net worth for Australians….” articles. It’s reassuring to think that you’re going better than average. That the hard work and moderate spending have actually led you to a healthy financial position.
I WAS RECENTLY asked about strategies that high earners can use to reduce their tax bill.
Most people know the usual options. They contribute to a 401(k), fund a health savings account or make a Roth IRA contribution through the backdoor method. Business owners may have additional opportunities through retirement plans and business structures.
But there’s another strategy worth knowing about: the Mega Backdoor Roth (MBDR).
The MBDR allows some workers to put far more money into Roth accounts than the usual contribution limits permit.