FREE NEWSLETTER

Forum › Spending

Manhattan Island, Was It The All Time Greatest Deal, Or Not?

Manhattan was purchased from Native Americans, hundreds of years ago, for something like 23 dollars. At first glance , it appears to be the greatest bargain, ever,  for the purchasers, while the biggest rip off ,for the sellers.

I have no idea what even the approximate value of Manhattan is currently, other than more than 23 bucks, so I respectfully ask those far more astute at real estate values, compounded returns and the like, to approximately value the entirety of Manhattan, and also to calculate the value of that purchase price,  , if it was compounded at 7 percent annually for  400 years, or so.

 

 

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
5 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Mike Gaynes
2 years ago

I’ve gotta go with the Louisiana Purchase. $15 million for what would later become pieces of 15 states, a whole lot of corn, wheat and oil, and New Orleans jazz. (The latter alone was worth the price.)

Manhattan was only $1 per square mile versus $18 per square mile for the deal with Napoleon, but let’s face it, Manhattan has not been a similarly productive purchase.

Mike Gaynes
2 years ago
Reply to  Mike Gaynes

Still not sure why my email address displays instead of my name.

Jonathan Clements
Admin
2 years ago

It isn’t clear the sale ever took place:

https://www.livescience.com/was-manhattan-sold-for-24-dollars.html

Still, if you invest $24 at 7% a year, you get $13.6 trillion after 400 years. The value of all U.S. homes is currently put at some $50 trillion. Perhaps the sellers did better than the story suggests, and these early illegal immigrants got ripped off!

Last edited 2 years ago by Jonathan Clements
Dan Smith
2 years ago

Wow, I just checked with the New York County Recorders Office and there is no official record of the transaction! Who’da ever thunk that?

Free Newsletter

Arrives weekly.

Select list(s):
SHARE
HumbleDollar · https://humbledollar.com/forum/manhattan-island-was-it-the-all-time-greatest-deal-or-not/ · printed Nov 15, 2026

Create an account

Our readers find logging in to HumbleDollar directly more reliable than going through Google, Disqus, WordPress.com or X.

Already have an account? Don’t make a second one. Log in with the provider you use now, then go to Your Account to set up direct login.

We send a confirmation link here before the account can be used.
Shown beside your comments and forum posts.
Password(Required)
Strength indicator
Accepted file types: jpg, jpeg, png, webp, Max. file size: 5 MB.
Optional. Square images look best. JPG, PNG or WebP.
Optional. Appears on your author page.

Log in