Does it matter? Probably not if we are happy and reasonably financially secure. Benchmarks can be informative, if not helpful, though. For one thing they remind us when discussing money, affordability, frugality and such how relative, how different things can be and how normal at the same time.
An interesting (?) information exercise follows without conclusions or recommendations to move to Mississippi😎
Through extensive research (four AI apps) I have learned that “rich” is determined by income and “wealthy” by value of assets, basically net worth. I don’t know if that is an official definition, but the apps were consistent.
I also learned that you can be rich but not wealthy and wealthy but not rich. Or you can be both. Most billionaires are wealthy, but probably not rich. On the other hand, those Americans with high incomes, but prone to lifestyle creep and luxury car leases, sadly may only be rich. There are some very moderate income folks who will never be rich, but time and financial prudence may help them become wealthy – relatively speaking.
There is another question to ponder. What net worth do you need to be considered wealthy? That’s subject to interpretation. For example, $1 million puts you in the top 10-15%. Is that wealthy? To many people it is for sure. If you want to be certain, shoot for $5 million, that puts you in the top 2-3%. At that level I doubt anyone would question one’s wealthy status – well, Elon may snub you.
A 2025 Charles Schwab survey found Americans say it takes an average of $2.3 million in net worth to be considered wealthy.
But there is more. With $5 million net worth would everyone feel wealthy? That’s a big maybe. Why? Where’s the money? If it’s mostly in a home or other real estate, you might not feel as wealthy as if net worth is in liquid investments. Or maybe you would. I’m guessing some people who feel wealthy don’t even know their net worth.
How much income do you need to be rich?
$200,000 a year seems to be the cutoff, but that is highly variable based on location. The median household income in the US is $87,460 (2025). In Massachusetts it is ~$104,800 and in Mississippi $59,100. Many people in Mississippi would welcome income at the national median.
To further complicate matters, you could factor in the cost of living. Overall estimates from comparison sites put the total cost of living in Mississippi 25–35% lower than in Massachusetts (including or excluding rent). 65% of $104,800 = $68,120. Is Mississippi looking better?
This is getting into spreadsheet territory🥵
So what have we learned that is important to financial planning and management? Not much of value I suppose. Or, perhaps that when discussing money and finances, any conclusions must include “it depends!”
One thing pretty is certain, readers are thinking gee, yikes, ummm, wow, okay, or not bad.
R Quinn, well done, I see a lot of discussion, and that is good for all. I like the term comfortable. Amen.
The structure of one’s “wealth” greatly influences its real value. Having $1 million in illiquid or volatile interests would seem to be less valuable than $1 million in investments that don’t fluctuate wildly and that can be tapped easily.
I also noticed in the comments that few people differentiate between “wealth” that is still subject to income or capital gains taxes (or both), and “wealth” that is not subject to further taxes in order to be accessed. Again, $1 million in CDs in a regular brokerage account is probably a lot more immediately valuable than $1 million in a stock mutual fund in one’s IRA that has greatly appreciated over the years but with capital gains that have never been taxed. The former may be subject to some income tax, but probably not too much. The latter will still be subject to some income taxes, but more importantly, significant capital gains taxes when tapped for use – and at one’s highest marginal tax rates.
So, the smart investor’s “wealth” spreadsheet may list the investment at current market value, but it should also be shown at its most likely “after-tax” value as well. IMHO, “wealth” should always be calculated at that most-likely after-tax level, based on what it would be today if one needed it all now and had to liquidate. Brag about the former, but look in the mirror and tell the truth with the latter.
I have never seen wealth calculated on an after-tax basis probably because there are so many variables in that calculation.
Pretty simple to get a ballpark. (While it’s simple I still made an error earlier, fixed below.)
Your brokerage provider should show your total capital gains in your taxable accounts. Reduce the total taxable account balance by 15% of this amount.
Reduce your Traditional tax protected accounts by your marginal tax rate.
What’s left is your result. Not perfect, and no doubt someone will point out reasons why it isn’t, but it’s a reasonable ballpark.
You can be in the 12% income bracket but the 0% capital gains bracket or have a 27% marginal rate, so this can be tricky.
“Not perfect, and no doubt someone will point out reasons why it isn’t, but it’s a reasonable ballpark.” 🙂
Thanks King Richard,
Lots of opinions in the comments. Mine is I want to be wealthy enough to not think about having enough money now or later. Rich is being able to have purpose and happiness in life.
A pastor in a sermon said study after study has indicated, those who serve others are by far the happiest people.
I think also the richest.
“With $5 million net worth would everyone feel wealthy? That’s a big maybe. Why?”
The answer is in the Millionaire Next Door. We compare ourselves to our neighbors. In the neighborhood I live in, $5M looks very wealthy. A few miles away in the Manor in Larchmont, not so much.
In NYC, $200k/yr does not feel rich. But I guess it also depends on age, who depends on us, and who our immediate neighbors are. For instance, when we were paying for a new car, a mortgage, private lessons for our kids, sleep away camp, and college, $200k would be wholly inadequate. But with kids out of the paid off house not asking for financial help, $200k would comfortably cover the expenses.
Mr Quinn – I enjoyed your article and the ensuing discussion as well. You are a great asset in the Humble Dollar community, making me feel wealthier and richer!!
👍😁
What has always confounded me is why the super rich want so much more. The desperate need to have more by the super wealthy, even at the expense of the super needy, is a problem. We see the huge tax cuts, the policies that reduce restrictions on corporations to increase the bottom line, all to increase their net worth. I guess the old saying “he who dies with the most toys wins” is, sadly, true for the top .01%
How is someone striving to accumulate more “at the expense” of the super-needy? Me or anyone else accumulating wealth doesn’t rob from others. It is my initiative that allows me to accumulate wealth. This is the mentality that is causing class warfare in this country.
Dealing with CEOs over the years I found their compensation was simply a measuring stick with their peers. Looking around the neighborhood, it appears the same thing happens with cars. Different peers, different measuring stick.
I think that is a perception, not a reality. In many cases it not about more money at all. It’s about success, accomplishment, achieving more. The stock market grows their wealth. Not sure what huge tax cuts you refer to.
When I was a kid, the income tax rates were far higher. In my own lifetime, income tax rates have dropped. I remember a year when I made more money than the previous year but I got a substantial refund because the tax rates dropped, and it wasn’t because my partner and I swapped the kids that year.
I grew up in Mississippi. I wouldn’t suggest it 🙂 At that time, I was in the poorest county of the 82 counties in MS which was the poorest state in the United States. It was the place from which MLK planned the Mule Train. I’m sure I’m bias due to my negative experience. Back to the main point of the article, I suppose it does not matter if you’re happy but would matter depending on your goal and the reason for your goal. If your goal was wealthiness because that is the thing that would make you happy because you wanted to reach that metric for some reason that drives you like proving that you can or because you want to reach some milestone in your family that no one has yet reached etc etc . I suppose then you wouldn’t be happy until you met that goal. I personally am in the “enough” camp. If I can have enough to not struggle and provide for my family then I am happy. Tomorrow is not promised so I say work hard for the future but live for today. It’s human nature to wonder where one stands compared to his peers even financially. It can be inspirational to reach for a goal others have reached. It also however is important to remember when we compare ourselves to others, we can often feel superior or inferior, so do so at your own peril. I say just try to appreciate what you have wherever you fall on the financial spectrum.
I have been setting financial and life goals since I was 18 and to a modest extent I still do at 83. I am very fortunate to have achieved all those goals, but I see no reason to stop striving.
I admittedly do compare myself with data. I just want to know where I stand. There is no purpose other than to measure myself against myself.
As far as money goes my goals have shifted because now the purpose of never having enough is because I want to give it to others, primarily my family, but charity as well.
Comparison is the thief of joy isn’t it Chris? I watched my Dad, a WWII vet, live a 31 year retirement (and he retired at 65!) with his enough and he was very content–and he did it as a widower. Having grown up in the depression, his retirement enough was a paid for house, a paid for car, golf with his buddies 4-5 days a week, and lots of travel. He did that on less than $30K a year having passed away in 2014. When I did his taxes every year, I was amazed at how he lived so well on so little income yet he had no debt. While pondering this reply, the thought just hit me regarding how one might know if they have their enough. I’ve been thinking I may have mine, but it’s always nice to have a little more. I live in a paid for house, retired, and am looking at my cars in the driveway now. I have a 2003 Yukon XL, a 2012 Camry, and for excitement, a 2022 Subaru Outback–all paid for. Might what’s in your driveway or garage be a sign of enough? At least in part I would think, but always a work in progress–like life.
“Comparison is the thief of joy…” What a great saying…and so true.
I guess it is human nature to want to know where you stand in comparison to others, especially in our culture here in the US. I know that over the years I have often compared myself to the “averages.”
Lately, however, I find myself wondering how to shed so much of what I have accumulated over the years. I recently told my wife, jokingly, that I want to have an estate sale…NOW…while I am still alive, to get rid of all my “stuff.” When I think about it, I would be doing my kids a favor.
I decided to start by emptying my closets of all the clothing I haven’t worn in the past year. I have never bought “cheap” clothing, so it is all in good shape. I even have clothing with the tags still on them. That’s a start anyway.
I am a fan of Bogle’s book, “Enough.”
If your goal is riches, there will never be enough. If your goal is wealth, the definition will be totally subjective and personal.
I favor the concept of enough. I am also reminded of the bible verse, 1 Timothy 6:9-10.“Those who want to get rich fall into temptation and a trap and into many foolish and harmful desires that plunge people into ruin and destruction. For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil.”
Several people commenting, even criticizing, this post seem to have missed the first sentence.
”Does it matter? Probably not if we are happy and reasonably financially secure.”
Nope, saw it.
Had you stopped there vs continuing on a vacuous diatribe thereafter your feedback may have been different.
Well, if you see the post as an angry rant full of hot air, so be it, although I’m at a loss finding any rant or any reason to find anything objectionable. Me thinks thou protests too much.
“Me thinks thou protests too much”
Ironic.
Here are some more song lyrics that are applicable for all the feedback you have received yet don’t seem to hear…..
“Everybody’s talkin’ at me”
“Can’t hear a word they’re sayin’”
“Only the echoes of my mind”
I give up you got me, I have reread the post many times trying to see any opinion, let alone rant. I can’t see anything but facts and a recognition of that, so I guess it’s me.
I think these lyrics are appropriate too, from the song Happy on the Stones Exile on Main St.:
Well, I never kept a dollar past sunset
It always burned a hole in my pants
Never made a school mama happy
Never blew a second chance, oh no
[Chorus]
I need a love to keep me happy
I need a love to keep me happy
Baby, baby, keep me happy
Baby, baby, keep me happy
[Verse 2]
Always took candy from strangers
Didn’t wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
[Chorus]
I need a love to keep me happy
I need a love
Baby, won’t you keep me happy?
Baby, won’t you keep me happy? (Happy)
Baby, please keep me
[Chorus]
I need a love to keep me happy
I need a love to keep me happy
Baby, baby, keep me happy
Baby
The Stones’ lyrics I reflect on are: “I have my freedom, but I don’t have much time”. We all have plenty of things we’d like to do after retiring or when we have “enough”, but what we don’t know is the amount of time we’ll have to do those things. As others have noted, best to get started on doing those things we’d like to do!
Yes, I like that!
Interesting discussion, Dick. I think the word that may matter more than either “rich” or “wealthy” is “enough.”
We can put numbers on income and net worth and determine where someone falls statistically, but I’m not sure those numbers tell us how wealthy a person actually feels. Someone with $1 million who has modest needs, good relationships and control over his time may feel far wealthier than someone with $5 million who is always looking at the person with $10 million.
For me, financial security is ultimately about what money allows us to do, and, perhaps even more importantly, what it allows us not to worry about. Once we have enough, I’m not sure the label matters very much.
Well summarized Andrew!
I think that’s all a given, but the public discourse doesn’t seem to recognize that. It’s all about the other guy, envy, somehow who has more, what’s unfair. In any case, none of that was the point of the post, certainly not praising wealth or being rich above the important things.
Amen, Andrew.
John Bogle’s book, aptly titled Enough, is a great read along the lines of the thoughts you outline.
Hard to see what your point is in all this. As far as I’m concerned rich and wealthy are synonymous. If your point is that there is a difference between income and assets, I’m pretty certain most HD readers understand this.
i would like HD readers to consider the lyrics to Wild Horses by the Stones as a response to this post:
Childhood living
Is easy to do
The things you wanted
I bought them for you
Graceless lady
You know who I am
You know I can’t let you
Slide through my hands
Wild horses
Couldn’t drag me away
Wild, wild horses
Couldn’t drag me away
I watched you suffer
A dull aching pain
Now you’ve decided
To show me the same
No sweeping exit
Or offstage lines
Could make me feel bitter
Or treat you unkind
Wild horses
Couldn’t drag me away
Wild, wild horses
Couldn’t drag me away
I know I’ve dreamed you
A sin and a lie
I have my freedom
But I don’t have much time
Faith has been broken
Tears must be cried
Let’s do some living
After we die
Wild horses
Couldn’t drag me away
Wild, wild horses
We’ll ride them some day
Wild horses
Couldn’t drag me away
Wild, wild horses
We’ll ride them some day
Sorry, I don’t get it. Enlighten me please.
I was hoping someone would ask 😁
I’m with Richard on this one. I’ve read the lyrics twice and still can’t figure out what Mick and Keith are trying to tell us about the difference between $2.3 million and $5 million. 😄
My best shot: You’ve accumulated enough. You have your freedom. Your remaining scarce asset is time. Go live.
Mark, since you were hoping someone would ask, the floor is yours 🙂
Mark, I was hoping someone would ask as I didn’t want to be the stereotypical, thick Irish bloke asking what it means 😊
My best guess is that money can buy things, but not what really matters. The lyrics talk about giving someone everything they wanted, yet the relationship still frays. I think Nick’s point is that “rich” and “wealthy” are just different ways of counting, and neither measures devotion, connection or contentment.
It’s taking me right back to English literature class at school! 😂
Okay, there are many things more important than money. That’s certainly true. But what has it to do with a post defining two sometimes mistakenly interchanged words?
I don’t see anything praising the accumulation of money, just defining it and how it is perceived.
So what is being responded to?
Dick, if the post was meant to highlight the difference between being wealthy and being rich, then fair enough. I think the comments simply used it as a springboard to explore the more complicated relationship between money and how we think about it. We hijacked your post to dig into that deeper meaning. So as an exploration of how these definitions can blur depending on circumstances, you’re spot on.
You summed it up very well!
Brewing these two words up in a world where most people don’t approach either in a financial sense prompts the question” Arrogant or Divisive?” (could be “and” as well). “Insensitive” could be another.
Most people as they mature, look deeper introspectively and aspire toward “comfort” (as has been mentioned), “safety” (something many do not enjoy) and “fulfillment”…the latter potentially the most important word when all is said and done in a life.
“Humility” is a worthy aspiration along the way as well.
What has arrogant or divisive or insensitive to do with the post? It just relates facts on a topic that often comes up in discussions and also misunderstood.
Sometimes (not always), it is a distinction without a difference, but as a bit of confirmation bias I suspect our fellow readers know this difference intimately. Further, they’re probably more aware than most of the challenges of looking around at friend and peer groups, or nowadays influencers, and feel like they’re somehow behind, despite objective evidence to the contrary.
All of which reminds me of an adage taught to me by professional mentors, that, ‘the enemy of good is better.’ In practical terms, lamenting not buying NVDA while ignoring that those same assets were in the S&P 500 or NASDAQ all along, earning > 20% last year alone. Good may be far better than good enough.
Personally, I prefer to use the term “comfortable” to describe my circumstances.
Achieved mostly through winning the birth lottery. Born in the mid-1950’s to a middle-class white family.
The view that neither matters (which in the big picture of life is true) does not seem consistent with the public discourse and obsession with wealth and who has it. Because of that, not sure we can simply ignore it.
Isn’t the public discourse around billionaires having more money than they can use in many lifetimes, built on the sweat equity of paeans, yet some of those workers and those in their communities have to live precarious lives?
Some of the most generous, compassionate people I’ve ever met are those at the bottom of the wealth ladder who give their money or labour to local food banks etc. They give far more of their net worth than the truly wealthy do.
Yes it is and I find it interesting that billionaires are the target while ignoring all the benefits from their obtaining wealth through what they created and generated by the stock market, not the sweat of workers who may not even have a job without them.
At the same time we hear nothing about the multi millions even billions earned by entertainers and sports stars who add no lasting value and make their money almost exclusively directly from people willing to spend money on tickets.
I agree that there are many generous people in both time and money at the lower end of the economic spectrum. But there are notable exceptions among the super wealthy too.
Sure there are exceptions. I’ve huge admiration for Gates for his efforts to
microchip everyone through vaccines,be a whatabout him distraction for Trumpites re island activitiessubstantially improve world health, education and equality. Plus the giving pledge.But there are also billionaire/trillionaires who seem to revel in a Dr Evil persona.
Of course creating work and wealth for others goes with the job of being a mega entrepreneur. They literally can’t do it alone no matter how slick their PR.
I don’t think you can say sports stars and entertainers don’t contribute lasting value. I still remember viscerally Tommy Smith’s header in Rome* and I was a young child at the time. You ever heard of a little LP called Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band? Or seen Godfather Part II? Or cried over a book? Plus you can actually measure the economy boost on a city when Beyonce or Taylor Swift is in town.
But they do tend to be more demonstrably socially aware. Or just do better PR, who really knows.
*IYKYK YNWA
I’m fine with regarding them as homonyms and pretty meaningless ones at that. Because once you have wealth the question is do you have generational wealth etc (one that the luxury goods and services industries love to target).
I use my own personal definition – wealth will be the capacity to do the what I where I want to do with the people that I choose not all the “comparison is the theft of joy” dick measuring. My idea of a luxury holiday is the time and sufficient means to park a van and camp alongside a loch or fjord.
Rich or wealthy? As you say, it doesn’t really matter. Personally, I don’t much care which label we get. I prefer a third word: comfortable. For me it means the income from our investments, plus a little capital growth, covers all of our needs and wants, without anyone checking the balance before ordering whatever they want from the menu.
By that test, you can be rich but not comfortable (hello, luxury car leases). You can be wealthy on paper but not feel it, if most of it is in a house you can’t spend. And someone with modest income and modest assets can be perfectly comfortable if their wants are modest too.
Marc: comfortable is the exact word I was thinking of as I read Richard’s interesting essay. Rich and wealthy, to me, seem like bragging about one’s financial picture. So, I am comfortable with comfortable.
Free Newsletter
Arrives weekly.