I like the idea that index investing is not completely passive, because choosing how broadly to diversify is still an active decision. The three approaches outlined here give investors a useful way to think about geographic exposure, customization, and the trade-offs between simplicity and control. I especially agree with the emphasis on keeping costs and turnover low, since those are factors investors can actually control over the long term. There may not be one perfect allocation for everyone, but having a clear strategy and understanding why you choose a particular index seems much more important than simply picking a fund because it is labeled “passive.”
Comments
I like the idea that index investing is not completely passive, because choosing how broadly to diversify is still an active decision. The three approaches outlined here give investors a useful way to think about geographic exposure, customization, and the trade-offs between simplicity and control. I especially agree with the emphasis on keeping costs and turnover low, since those are factors investors can actually control over the long term. There may not be one perfect allocation for everyone, but having a clear strategy and understanding why you choose a particular index seems much more important than simply picking a fund because it is labeled “passive.”
Post: Index Three Ways
Link to comment from October 7, 2026