The all-time closing high of the S&P500 is $7,818.93. Today it closed at $6,910.39, representing a loss of 11.6% from its all-time high.
I remember an article by Jonathan where he admitted to increasing his stock purchases during broad market declines, something critics would call market timing. He argued against this being true market timing, saying, “I’m not making a big all-or-nothing bet based on a market forecast, but rather responding to what the market has already done.”
I’ve engaged in this same “sinful” behavior over the past few days. Luckily, my purchase decisions were made with a clearer head, prior to these declines, where I set up automatic sell orders from my short and ultra short-term bond funds, contingent upon the S&P500 declining from all-time highs to certain price levels (i.e. 5% down, 7.5% down, 10% down, etc.) Thus I have purchased stocks on sale and according to the predefined rules of my investment plan.
In another article, Jonathan explains his “loosey goosey” strategy for when to rebalance back to his target bond allocation. I’ve chosen a bit more structure here, choosing to rebalance back into bonds once stocks recover to their all-time highs.
Is this strategy for everyone? Probably not. But for me, I feel the risk is low given that I have no immediate need for the short-term bonds I’ve used to purchase these discounted stocks. Purchasing stocks on sale also eases the psychological pain of the wider losses of my much larger stock portfolio.
I’m curious how others view this topic, and, if it’s something you do, what are your index decline triggers (% from all-time high) for purchasing extra stocks, and when do you rebalance back into bonds. Or, is it all a little loosey goosey?
First, some perspective: over the past 50 years, there have been 25 market declines of 10%, 8 of 25% and exactly 1 of 50%. So far, the current decline feels more like a 10% decline than a 50% decline, but no one knows for sure how much lower markets might go.
Personally, I decided to raise cash about a month ago. My normal cash allocation is 3-5%, and my overall allocation has been roughly 62/38, exclusively using funds. At the moment, I am at about 10% cash which gives me some comfort for two reasons: 1) I can cover my MRD’s for at least two years without needing to raise more cash, and 2) if it looks like a market bottom is in the wind, I have cash available to buy back in at relatively cheaper prices.
If this strategy carries a whiff or market timing I don’t mind as it helps me sleep better knowing that I wont be forced to sell into a steadily falling market if the current decline turns into a rout.
One goal I set for retirement was to only evaluate and rebalance our portfolio once per year. Retirement for me came in increments both professionally and in progressively dialing back from actively managing the portfolio. It’s been liberating.
At this point I am down to rebalancing once per year in December and concurrently make a final Roth conversion “top off” of the prevailing tax bracket.
Periodically throughout the year however I do still make Roth conversions and occasionally sell covered calls for a little extra “juice”.
Per CNN today:
The Nasdaq hit a record high on October 6, and was up as much as 18.7% on the year. Since that all-time high, the index has slumped, erasing all those gains and shedding roughly $8.7 trillion in market value.
The tech-focused Nasdaq faced even steeper losses on Friday, dropping 5.28%. It is now down more than 2% for the year.
If my simple math is correct the NASDAQ is in bear territory. In other words I think the technology bubble has burst.
David, those year-to-date figures share a start-of-year base, so they can’t be added. 0.98 ÷ 1.187 puts the Nasdaq about 17% below its high, which is a strong correction rather than a bear market (yet). When the tech bubble really bursts, I suspect we’ll all know: the dot-com bust took the Nasdaq down roughly 78% over two and a half years.
Interesting, Brent. I was mulling the same question earlier today but ended up doing nothing. I was even thinking of writing a post about it. In February I deliberately trimmed my tech concentration to 15%, which I consider acceptable, and buying a broad index on a dip could push that back up, since tech is such a big slice of the S&P 500. I don’t want to undo that work, so I’d need something other than a plain S&P fund, and I haven’t settled on one. I’ll admit I’m drawn to the idea anyway. Do your triggers account for sector weighting at all, or do you treat the index as a single unit?
I hear you, Mark. I don’t account for sector weighting in my buy/sell orders, just the percentages down or up of the total market. I only own a total stock market index fund so this strategy isn’t too difficult for me to implement.
Brent I have a similar philosophy.
What is interesting is just before this swoon I checked and our portfolio was 3% above our target allocation for US stocks and I was considering selling back to target and moving the money into bonds. This year however I had decided that I would not rebalance except at the time of my quarterly net worth calculation. If I had gone forward I would now be overweight in bonds.
Earlier today I was considering doing my last monthly Roth conversion for the year which normally would occur in late December once I have a very firm number for our income. The final conversion amount is to get our income up to the top of the 12%tax bracket. I can’t stand the thought of a dollar of income be taxed at almost double the rate because my calculations could be wrong. The reasoning for converting when the market is down is you can convert more shares at the same dollar amount. I moved several months’ conversions forward in April during the earlier market swoon. Today I decided against pulling the trigger on the conversion as they have not set the tax rate for this year, and thus I do not know how much more the second semiannual bill will be. 🤷♂️
I’m not in a great place for Roth conversions right now, but if I was, I’d absolutely evaluate doing more during market declines like you have.
Free Newsletter
Arrives weekly.