I see a lot discussed about using cash and bonds in retirement. I’ve wondered why using portfolio income (interest and dividends) isn’t discussed to supplement or as an alternate to withdrawals.
I’ve thought about using income temporarily during market downturns to reduce cash and bond allocations.
What do you think and who has experience with this strategy?
Wow, what a response! Thanks to all for sharing your experience and thoughts. Your support as a community is appreciated!
Some additional detail on my developing principle of strategic income (from a total return portfolio) …
I’ll credit my late father for the idea. In his case, he used a small collection of utility stocks to provide dividends that supplemented his SS and pension. He lived a comfortable lifestyle and maintained his networth during his 30-year retirement (’88-’18). Fairly conservative, his stocks didn’t grow much (and didn’t show much volatility), but it got the job done.
My portfolio is developing in early retirement as a total return strategy and selling appreciated assets in a tax efficient manner. Based on our budget that means taking traditional IRA distributions first using the 10 & 12% brackets, then taxable using LTCG 15%, and finishing with Roth conversions to fill the 22% bracket (or IRMMA limit when that applies) as our plan is still showing 24% tax rate at the end. OCDs make be part of the picture later as well. In the end, without children, my goal is to leave a financial legacy in the form of an endowment. We’ve started this with a donor advised fund (DAF) a couple of years ago.
While the portfolio is total return, it does have 1-2 years cash (some in the traditional IRA until needed to avoid a little tax drag), ~6 years of bonds, and the remainder in equities. Each bucket has several holdings as I am enjoying exploring and researching different asset styles and respective performance within each bucket.
Some of your experiences about simplifying later in life and shifting to a more income-oriented portfolio make a lot of sense to manage cognitive decline risk. I’ve also started developing an investment policy to capture all of this to share with my wife and financial advisor/planner.
In summary, thanks again for all the feedback, I’m more comfortable that periodic short-term use of portfolio generated income is a sound strategy and could help extend more traditional cash/bond “ballast” assets during extended market depressions.
For many years I owned oil royalty trusts which typically returned 10% tax free based on the value of the stock. But I wouldn’t recommend the strategy now.
About ten years ago in this blog there was a discussion of QYLD. I have since learned about GPIQ which may have an added benefit of capital appreciation. Also, a few weeks ago a friend told me that his financial advisor has him following this strategy with a large percentage of his investments for steady income. I have a smaller position than this in my Roth IRA. Regardless, I learned about it here and depending on your worry that the strategy may stall, since 2020 the two positions have returned a steady dividend of between 10% and 12%. I could be using this as income, but I don’t need the income yet, so I’ve been reinvesting the dividends in SCHD and VYMI which are high dividend stock ETFs with low expenses.
I am currently experimenting with a simple three fund portfolio that historically (based on portfolio visualizer) provides around 8% growth with 3.3% dividend/interest income. I have been a total return investor all my life and had not paid much attention to dividend income (it has always been reinvested). However, as we are starting to enter into our 80s, I am experimenting with different income strategies to see if it can help reduce the need for decision making (to mitigate possible cognitive decline in the future).
In our situation, we have sufficient lifetime income (from SS benefits and annuity income) to cover all our essential expenses and much of our discretionary spending as well. We currently need around 3% of our portfolio annually for travel, gifting, and charitable donations. The above portfolio appears to meet that goal (over a long term). Currently, I have an account that started out with $100K for experimentation with this portfolio structure and has been operating (untouched) for the past 30 months so far. The mix of funds is 30% growth equity (S&P 500), 30% US Div 100 index equity, and 40% bond fund (Fidelity Strategic Income). All equity gains are reinvested while all dividend and interest are “withdrawn” and put into a reserve fund. I am 30 months into a 3-year experiment where I have been tracking the monthly gain and dividend/interest income. So far, this model portfolio has had 11% annual growth and 3.8% annual income for a total return of 14.8%. The last 2.5 years have been relatively good but the returns are in line with historical outcomes. While the month-to-month income is quite variable, I simulate the monthly income withdrawal by removing such assets from the reserve fund, which was initially “seeded” with several month “income” as a buffer. Then all dividend/income from the funds are distributed to the reserve fund to replenish the balance. After 2.5 years, the original 60/40 asset allocation has shifted to 70/30 (implying the possible need to rebalance every 3rd year or so). If I were to start with a 50/50 asset allocation, it could increase the annual income but with a slower growth, while increasing the time frame when rebalancing may be needed. Since the income from this portfolio is mainly for discretionary spending, there is flexibility in both withdrawal and spending.
I forgot to mention that half our assets are in Roth accounts and that a 3% withdrawal rate satisfies our RMDs as well. In six months when this experiment will come to a close, I will do an analysis of the monthly cash flow, play out a few “what if” scenarios, and then decide if I want to transition our full portfolio to this structure.
Outside of this I still have another 20% (equivalent – not counted as part of the 100% above) in alternative assets. These assets include bitcoin and precious metals, which I consider as part of growth and not income.
Personally, I would not consider doing this earlier in retirement. I do worry about what might happen if I am no longer here or cannot carry out our portfolio management in the future. I have interviewed several financial advisors and also have considered a robo-advisor with once-a-year meetings. Those are still options. But so far, I am leaning toward just simplifying the portfolio management process if “enough” is “good enough.”