FREE NEWSLETTER

Forum › Taxes

The Luxury of Choosing Tax-Free Cash from a Roth IRA or HSA….but Which One?

As a recent retiree who is using my cash reserves to cross my two-year “bridge” to my SS claiming date, I need to decide from which of my tax-free accounts I should withdraw to supplement our living expenses as I move into 2025. I will have used up my taxable account funds by the end of 2024.

Given our household’s low taxable income during this period I have been doing strategic (fill up the tax bracket, but keep my spouse eligible for a low ACA) Roth conversions that entail converting equity holdings from my Rollover IRA into my Roth IRA.  This  leaves an increasing proportion of my Rollover IRA in slower growing bond funds, thus reducing the level of future RMDs that I will be forced to take in the future.

I have built up significant cash reserves in my Roth IRA. I also have a low five-figure in balance in my HSA– all in a short-term government bond fund. These HSA funds have been invested while I used my taxable funds to pay my medical expenses, thus accumulating a stack HSA-eligible receipts, including an increasing proportion of Medicare-related premium receipts.

I need to make a choice…. do I use my Roth IRA cash reserves (invested in Vanguard’s Fed. MMF), or do I begin selling my short-term government bond funds in my Fidelity HSA account to begin funding my expenses in 2025?  I realize my MMF interest rate is sensitive to the Fed’s. interest rate decisions and its NAV is directly correlated to that.  Likewise, with my HSA short-term govt. bond investments— but their point-in-time value is also tied to the what the market will pay at the time I sell shares of that fund.

I realize the negative tax implications of not spending down my HSA and having it pass to a beneficiary, as compared to my Roth IRA balance being passed to a beneficiary with no negative tax implications as long as withdrawal rules are followed (spouse vs children).

I have the luxury of even facing this decision, but welcome the HD community’s counsel as I move forward.  Is there a clear answer? Am I missing others things that I need to take in to account?

Thanks,

Bill

 

 

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
15 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Mark Eckman
2 years ago

When my wife passed, I began reimbursement withdrawals from my HSA, using the accumulated medical receipts since 2004 and my Medicare part D premiums. My rationale here is the funds will become taxable income the moment they pass to my heirs, since they are not my spouse. the tax benefit is mine to use or lose, so…

Lou Daigle
2 years ago

Good question! We decided that spending our HSA’s and not touching our Roth IRA’s made the most sense. For us, it all boiled down to wanting to simplify our financial lives in preparation for our later years and wanting to let our Roth IRA’s continue growing for our heirs.

My wife and I each had our own HSA so there were two accounts to manage. My wife is technically challenged so I managed both accounts. If I were to pass away before my wife she would struggle with maintaining these accounts. Determining what qualifies for reimbursement and scanning and submitting receipts would be puzzling and frustrating for her. And managing these accounts could become more difficult for me in my later years if I begin to lose my mental abilities. So depleting the HSA’s just made good sense to us.

I hope this helps you out.

Kevin Madden
2 years ago
Reply to  Lou Daigle

Makes sense. To my knowledge, receipts do not need to be submitted/filed. They are needed if audited, though.