FREE NEWSLETTER

Non-Leading Indicators

Marjorie Kondrack

IN TRYING TO FORETELL the economy’s direction, former Federal Reserve Chair Alan Greenspan has shown “a keen interest in men’s underwear,” according to CNN Business. “He sees underwear sales as a key economic predictor.”

This isn’t because Greenspan is preoccupied with nether garments. Rather, says an NPR reporter, he believes that “the garment that is most private is male underpants because nobody sees it except people like in the locker room.”

Yes, the men’s underwear index exists. It’s based on the premise that, during normal economic times, sales of men’s underwear are usually stable, but during an economic slump men prioritize other expenses over replacing their underpants.

HumbleDollar contributor Ken Begley may have unwittingly answered the question as to whether or not the U.S. is headed for a recession. A man before his time, he understands the underwear index—as indicated by his unabashedly candid “holey underwear” article.

Meanwhile, just in case you’re wondering, ladies’ underwear seems not to be an issue—presumably because women are more sensitive about wearing worn-out underwear. And who would have the temerity to conduct such an indelicate study, anyway?

There are still risks to the economy, but most economists expect the U.S. to dodge a recession in 2024. Meanwhile, here are a few more ersatz but semi-accurate ways of measuring U.S. economic downturns:

  • Lipstick index. In a recession or bear market, women tend to replace buying more expensive items, like jewelry or handbags, with smaller purchases that act as a treat or pick me up—like a new lipstick.
  • Hemline index. A scan through Vogue magazine indicates that longer hemlines will be one of this year’s trends. That doesn’t bode well for the economy and could be a harbinger of things to come. The theory, which has been around for a while, draws on the premise that skirt lengths get shorter in good economic times—the 1920s and 1960s—when women showed more leg. Hemlines get longer in bad times, such as during the 1930s, after the 1929 Wall Street crash, and during the economic turmoil of the 1970s. Perhaps the midi length, an in-between length skirt now trending, is a sign of today’s uncertainty.
  • Relationship index. Some people seek a new relationship to give themselves a lift during an economic downturn. Research indicates that dating sites see an uptick in business when the economy isn’t doing well. If there’s one thing that’s worse than being low on funds, it’s being low on funds and lacking companionship. This activity could also be a source of low-cost entertainment.

These indexes may not prove to be an accurate way to predict the economy’s direction, but they’re probably no worse than what we hear from professional prognosticators. As George Bernard Shaw is reported to have said, “If all the economists were laid end to end, they’d never reach a conclusion.”

Browse Articles

Subscribe
Notify of
19 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scott Masters
4 months ago

I just appreciate that you used “ersatz” lol

Marjorie Kondrack
4 months ago
Reply to  Scott Masters

Thank you, Scott. One of the most satisfying aspects of writing is finding just the right word or phrase to fit a description. I’ve never been satisfied with near synonyms and almost right words. I guess you could call me a word nerd.

AKROGER SHOPPER
4 months ago

Marjorie great observation, and checking my collection they are are over due for replacement. We always get the day started off with a smile after reading HD, and no exception with your article. Thanks for taking the time to post.

Marjorie Kondrack
4 months ago

And thank you for taking the time to comment

Jeff
4 months ago

Thank you for the smile this morning! Now, excuse me while I check my personal tagless whitey tighties index….

Last edited 4 months ago by Jeff
Marjorie Kondrack
4 months ago
Reply to  Jeff

Thanks for your fun comments, Jeff.

Mark Gardner
4 months ago

I recently heard a rumor that the number of people lined up at Costco for free samples is a leading indicator for the S&P 500 🙂 I am sure the free sample indicator is negatively correlated with the fine liquor indicator at Costco!

Marjorie Kondrack
4 months ago
Reply to  Mark Gardner

Mark, Thanks for commenting and giving a “sample” of your observations.

Andrew Forsythe
5 months ago

Marjorie, thanks for your article and I confess I’d never heard of the “men’s underwear index”. Your contributions are always educational and entertaining!

Marjorie Kondrack
5 months ago

Andrew, your very nice comments are very much appreciated. Thank you.

Rick Connor
5 months ago

Marjorie, thanks for a fun and enlightening article. I was not aware of these inductors. I have a friend who defines full employment as the time when the employees at his local Arby’s can’t get his order correct.

I’m hearing anecdotes about a travel index. The rental market at the Jersey shore seems to have softened as people are more willing to travel abroad. I guess that is positive for some industries, but no so great for beach house owners.

Marjorie Kondrack
5 months ago
Reply to  Rick Connor

I suppose it’s my love of the ocean, but I’ll take the Jersey shore and its relaxing atmosphere any day.
Thanks for your comments, Rick, and your always earnest and informative articles.

DAN SMITH
5 months ago

UHOH Marjorie, I’ve got socks older than some of my grandkids…. Should I move to cash?

Marjorie Kondrack
5 months ago
Reply to  DAN SMITH

Not until they reach the holey stage.😊
Thanks for commenting Dan

1PF
5 months ago

Thanks, Marjorie, for a fun start to the day! Your article, with its blend of laughs and information, is yet another example of why I *love* HumbleDollar!

Marjorie Kondrack
5 months ago
Reply to  1PF

And I *love* reading your very nice comments.
Thank you so much, 1PF.

Edmund Marsh
5 months ago

We’re always trying to predict the future, aren’t we? But only a few things are certain, like those cidicas that emerge on a regular cycle. Do you hear them where you live? It’s an otherworldly sound.
Marjorie, I like your article, but as I recall from my single days, a new girlfriend is not inexpensive!

Marjorie Kondrack
5 months ago
Reply to  Edmund Marsh

Ed, given your engaging style of expressing yourself, most young ladies,in your younger days, would have been charmed by an old fashioned walk with you and a stop at the soda shop.
And, nowadays most dating site meetups occur at a coffee shop,so not hard on the budget. many women are happy to share the cost of a dinner date as well.

About the cicadas, we do have them where I live and oddly enough I like the sound.

Thanks for commenting.

Edmund Marsh
5 months ago

You’re right, Marjorie. I did meet such a lady, and I married her!

Free Newsletter

SHARE