Since it's unlikely that you would file a claim for <$10,000, I recommend that you save even more money on your premium and raise your deductible to $10,000 if your insurance company offers it (as mine does).
Richard:
Just curious: who was your employer?
(mine was AT&T who, over time, has been reducing or eliminating the retirement benefits that it promised its retirees)
I don't think you could use your HSA in his case:
Rules and Limitations for HSA
No Friends or Extended Relatives: You cannot use HSA funds for general relatives, siblings, or adult children who do not qualify as your tax dependents.
Agree that the Roth IRA withdrawals themselves are not taxable income, the question is about the fairness of whether or not the withdrawn amount should be included in the IRMA and SS taxability calculations.
I agree with your logic, Roth IRA withdrawals are certainly income when it is withdrawn and should be included in MAGI calculations for determining IRMA and SS taxability!
I hope that our Kaiser Permanente LA and Orange County Senior Advantage Medicare Plan doesn't ever terminate because both my wife and I absolutely love it, and we highly recommend his wonderful non-profit health care organization to everyone who lives in their service area.
Richard: This was my goal as well: "it’s 100% of the income YOU WERE ACTUALLY LIVING ON day to day before you retired." Not the gross combined income that my wife and I were earning when we retired, but instead the (now) yearly inflation-adjusted pre-tax amount that we were actually spending at retirement, which reflected the way we actually live, including our normal spending patterns, taking yearly vacation trips, etc. It has worked out very well for us after being retired now for 16 years (I retired at age 65 and my wife retired a year later at age 62).
Comments
A wonderful and very informative article, thank you!
Post: Pirates, Pieces of Eight, and the $ in Your Pocket
Link to comment from November 11, 2026
Since it's unlikely that you would file a claim for <$10,000, I recommend that you save even more money on your premium and raise your deductible to $10,000 if your insurance company offers it (as mine does).
Post: To Claim or Not to Claim, That Is the Question
Link to comment from October 29, 2026
Very interesting, thanks for sharing it!
Post: Mid-term bounce?
Link to comment from October 18, 2026
Ha-ha, good one! :-))
Post: Little luxuries
Link to comment from September 20, 2026
Richard: Just curious: who was your employer? (mine was AT&T who, over time, has been reducing or eliminating the retirement benefits that it promised its retirees)
Post: What would you do if you received this text from your child as I did this morning?
Link to comment from September 17, 2026
I don't think you could use your HSA in his case: Rules and Limitations for HSA
Post: What would you do if you received this text from your child as I did this morning?
Link to comment from September 17, 2026
Agree that the Roth IRA withdrawals themselves are not taxable income, the question is about the fairness of whether or not the withdrawn amount should be included in the IRMA and SS taxability calculations.
Post: Income taxes on retirees with Social Security
Link to comment from August 15, 2026
I agree with your logic, Roth IRA withdrawals are certainly income when it is withdrawn and should be included in MAGI calculations for determining IRMA and SS taxability!
Post: Income taxes on retirees with Social Security
Link to comment from August 15, 2026
I hope that our Kaiser Permanente LA and Orange County Senior Advantage Medicare Plan doesn't ever terminate because both my wife and I absolutely love it, and we highly recommend his wonderful non-profit health care organization to everyone who lives in their service area.
Post: Medicare Advantage Part C — Not too soon to start planning for 2027
Link to comment from August 12, 2026
Richard: This was my goal as well: "it’s 100% of the income YOU WERE ACTUALLY LIVING ON day to day before you retired." Not the gross combined income that my wife and I were earning when we retired, but instead the (now) yearly inflation-adjusted pre-tax amount that we were actually spending at retirement, which reflected the way we actually live, including our normal spending patterns, taking yearly vacation trips, etc. It has worked out very well for us after being retired now for 16 years (I retired at age 65 and my wife retired a year later at age 62).
Post: What is the right percentage?
Link to comment from August 10, 2026