FREE NEWSLETTER

Forum › In Retirement

A Rule of Thumb Is Not a Plan

Occasionally I read about a new method or model for determining your portfolio withdrawal rate during retirement, or a formula to use when setting your asset allocation. While there’s nothing wrong with organisations trying to make things simple with these important questions, I sometimes wonder about how the research is framed.

Normally it’s a respectable financial institution, quite often backed by research from an in-house team or an academic institution, sometimes a combination of both. I’m sure the data and back-testing is rigorous and the intention is genuinely to help people figure things out. But I think the veneer of respectability can lull readers into a false sense of security.

However you dress these research papers up, a simple truth is often lost in the data and jargon. They are all just rules of thumb. Useful perhaps as a rough outline, but not a substitute for planning grounded in your own personal circumstances.

While it’s the best tool we have, back-testing, as the name implies, is backward-looking. It tells you what would have worked across historical sequences of returns. It says nothing meaningful about your specific thirty-year window, which is genuinely personal. Markets, inflation, healthcare costs, tax policy, none of these will behave exactly as they have before. A rule derived from the past is being asked to do a job in an unknowable future.

So leaning heavily on these shortcuts when making decisions about your financial future is, I think, a mistake. The question is what you should do instead.

At the very least you should start by building a realistic picture of your yearly spending needs and mapping this across your planning horizon. I know that sounds straightforward but most people underestimate what it actually involves. Your spending won’t be flat. Early retirement often brings higher discretionary costs: travel, hobbies, the things you finally have time for. Later years can bring rising healthcare and care costs. A simple annual figure won’t capture any of that, and if your foundation is wrong, everything built on top of it is compromised.

Getting this right takes time and a degree of honesty about how you actually live, and how you expect to live. But it’s worth it, because once you have a realistic picture of your withdrawal needs across time, you can start to think about the portfolio that has to support them. Asset allocation stops being a formula and becomes something more useful, a structure designed around your life rather than a generic model designed for everyone and therefore truly tailored to no one.

I know with Humble Dollar I’m preaching to the choir. Rules of thumb have their place. They’re fine for a back-of-the-envelope sense check. The problem is when people treat them as a plan. Retirement isn’t a generalisation. In the final analysis, it shouldn’t be managed like one, however academic the research behind it sounds.

 

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
29 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Chris (baldscreen)
8 months ago

Back to the spreadsheets…. Chris

corrupt
8 months ago

RMD rates aren’t limited to just 70 years and older. Perhaps using those rates would work?

Kurt Yokum
8 months ago

I hope to see in the future when we stop talking about the Bengen withdrawal rate as a retirement spending strategy. For a rough approximation of sufficient funds until end of plan — ok. But, to really understand your spending against your income and portfolio requires a bespoke touch. Life’s planned and unplanned events are unique and sporadic for each individual. Between events like moving residence, medical procedures, car purchases, etc we have a continuous flow of variable expenses. A plan that ignores that variability is not a plan.