FREE NEWSLETTER

Forum › Saving

Jonathan Clements Initiative at the Bogle Center for Financial Literacy

I heard Christine Benz talk about this initiative (details at https://boglecenter.net/gettinggoing/) in which young adults (particularly from low income backgrounds) are given $1000 for a Roth IRA.

I started to donate, and then the ‘mind chatter’ started- is this the best way to help? how will they track whether this approach actually helps young people to become better savers and investors?, etc. ( I’m sure I’m not the only person here with many voices in our heads chiming in on financial decisions.) I donated to the Initiative and hope it will prove useful and life-changing in many ways. But my final reasons for donating were: I have benefitted greatly from Jonathan Clements’ writings. If he thinks this is a worthy effort to try, then I want to support it out of gratitude and respect.  And I’ll pay attention to what happens, and make further donations based on what is learned from this effort.

I find making donations to charitable efforts challenging. Charity Navigator is one tool that helps, but I also support some smaller organizations that are still in the ‘start up’ phase and don’t (yet) have good track records and are still working out metrics to evaluate effectiveness. I would be curious to know how others make charitable donation decisions and what they’ve learned in this area (including how to work with mind chatter!).

 

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
19 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Steve Spinella
18 days ago

We are giving much more than we ever have, but we still find it hard. In fact we have a couple DAF’s (donor advised funds, essentially deferred giving) that have grown larger than most people’s net worth. Why is it so hard to give money away?
For us, having always been very frugal, a big barrier is the loss of control. Once we give away the keys, someone else will make the decisions about how to drive. I try to calm this fear by reminding myself that I am also an inadequate, imperfect, deficient manager, and that giving away control is just like diversification, which in the long run will lead to a greater and more stable return on investment. We’ll try to keep working on it!

Cammer Michael
21 days ago

I find charitable donations are for things I feel strongly about and more for things that help people directly.

Increasingly I get invitations to charity events. I have zero interest in a gala or dinner and I think that spending $50k on an event to net $25k is a waste of resources. So if I give to one of these organizations, I give my time doing something useful or money directly for their mission.

William Dorner
21 days ago

Thanks for your article. We all need to be thoughtful of our giving to insure the gift gets to the people in need. I use a QCD to donate to my local church and to the Annual Catholic Appeal. I also like to donate to local scholarship funds and the like and use taxable money to do so, which helps my deduction on Schedule A. I do like charities that give back close to 95% or more to the needy.

Martin McCue
22 days ago

I choose donees based on one or more of three criteria: an essential objective I support, efficient use of donations for the donee’s purpose (low solicitation and administrative expense), and a personal charity to whom I am personally connected and thankful. I went to a Catholic high school and am particularly thankful to it. But I also believe religious charities of many different faiths tend to be most efficient in how they deliver goods and services to the needy. I also like public libraries.

For a while, I clustered bigger donations to maximize itemized Schedule A deduction value. The deduction laws have now changed, and using the deduction path is less valuable. But I have pretty big RMDs for my IRA and SEP. So I now use the QCD route to donate some pretty large sums. It is easy, and every dollar totally eliminates your Federal tax on that dollar, though maybe not state tax. (Setting up a charitable trust or donor advised fund is not for me. I like my donee and the exact donation amount to be connected at the time the money leaves my pocket.)

I revisit this every year, to make sure I keep up with the law.

Last edited 22 days ago by Martin McCue