FREE NEWSLETTER

Forum › Retirement

IRS Blows Up Tax-Free Exchange of Appreciated Stocks for ETF

This past month the IRS issued guidance which disallows a much marketed technique many advisors are pitching to investors.  The technique involves transferring appreciated securities to a newly formed ETF without recognizing capital gains.  The idea is that forming a “new corporation” (the ETF) and transferring assets to it should be a nontaxable event under IRS Code Section 351.  For the past couple of years many advisors have been pitching this.  I even heard a Vanguard advisor recommending it.  Sound too good to be true?

Well, this month the IRS brought down the hammer and told the world these shenanigans don’t work.   There may be exceptions but generally the transfer to the ETF is a taxable event.  Does anyone here have experience with this?  It seems we may see many lawsuits as some investors may be on the hook for untold amounts of capital gains taxes.

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
6 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
William Perry
7 days ago

On July 21, 2026 The Wall Street Tax Association with others had an educational seminar where it has been reported that some IRS officials made comments expressing concerns about certain ETF investment strategies the government argues are not “consistent with the intent of Congress regarding IRC 351.

In late September 2026 the IRS issued Notice 2026-62 and Revenue Ruling 2026-20.

The stated purpose of the Revenue Ruling is –

Should a transfer of securities to a newly formed exchange traded fund that is intended to qualify as an exchange to which § 351 of the Internal Revenue Code applies fail to qualify as such if, as part of the same plan, some or all of the transferred securities are distributed pursuant to § 852(b)(6) in redemption of shares held by an “authorized participant”?

On 10/28/26 Jeff Levine at Kitces.com published a long article and a 35 minute podcast titled-

New IRS Guidance On Sec. 351 Exchanges And ETFs: Managing Tax Risk Of Tax-Aware Investing

which is worth a read if you are interested in the topic.

Last edited 7 days ago by William Perry
William Perry
6 days ago
Reply to  Paul Ward

I agree with both your observation and your conclusion.

When the IRS issues a Notice I see it as a warning to anyone who is thinking about taking such a position on their tax return. A Revenue Ruling (RR) is like a private letter ruling where a person provides their own detailed information to the IRS in advance of taking a action or filing a return taking the position on their tax return except the RR is broad in scope so the IRS is giving everyone fair warning of certain specific positions the IRS deems to be incorrect.

For most people the simple current choices on disposing of a asset in a taxable account are paying the tax when the appreciated investment is sold, giving the asset to a qualified charity or holding until death and then the heirs inheriting get a step up in tax basis.

Mark Crothers
6 days ago
Reply to  William Perry

William, I’m curious. On this side of the pond, If the entire commercial premise of an adviser’s recommendation was tax mitigation, the adviser cannot disclaim responsibility when that tax premise collapses under tax authority review…is it similar over there?

William Perry
6 days ago
Reply to  Mark Crothers

My public facing role in investments before I retired was as a CPA in local and regional firms so I hesitate to offer a legal conclusion on an adviser’s recommendation responsibility.

I do know that in preparing returns that I as preparer had legal obligations to not take a position that was contrary to law, rules and regulations, along with the taxpayer.

The purpose of the boilerplate that no one typically reads often is to disclaim responsibility from the one selling the service.

Dan Smith
7 days ago

I recall a conversation about this. I believe one or more readers have done this. This could be catastrophic for some peeps if those transfers are disallowed.

Free Newsletter

Arrives weekly.

Select list(s):
SHARE
HumbleDollar · https://humbledollar.com/forum/irs-blows-up-tax-free-exchange-of-appreciated-stocks-for-etf/ · printed Nov 8, 2026

Create an account

Our readers find logging in to HumbleDollar directly more reliable than going through Google, Disqus, WordPress.com or X.

Already have an account? Don’t make a second one. Log in with the provider you use now, then go to Your Account to set up direct login.

We send a confirmation link here before the account can be used.
Shown beside your comments and forum posts.
Password(Required)
Strength indicator
Accepted file types: jpg, jpeg, png, webp, Max. file size: 5 MB.
Optional. Square images look best. JPG, PNG or WebP.
Optional. Appears on your author page.

Log in