FREE NEWSLETTER

Forum › Investing

Do I really need International funds in my portfolio? I say no.

   My wife and I recently engaged with a financial consultant.  He’s taken a look at our investment portfolio and suggested we buy International ETFs because we don’t have enough exposure to those markets.

 

I.  I’m making the argument that we already have significant exposure  through our holdings in US based companies: 

 

      US Companies derive a large portion of their revenue from overseas.  According to Chat GPT:

  1. Apple:  ~63% from international revenue
  2. Google:  51.8% from international revenue
  3. S&P 500:  28% from international revenue

 

   These 3 holding comprise the lion’s share of our investments.

 

   A few other considerations tilting away from adding International funds:

 

  1. US based  companies have folks on board helping them deal with exchange rates for their revenue streams.  I assume funds do as well – but they add more to fund expenses relatively speaking

 

  1. International funds have slightly higher costs than US funds.  Not much higher so not a big deal.

 

  1. International funds provide a bit more of a tax filing hassle.  Again – not a big deal if the advantages are there.

 

Looking for the collective wisdom of the HumbleDollar community to find holes in my argument.

 

– Bruce Roberts

More On This Topic

Email Alerts for this Comment Thread
Notify of
37 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Martin McCue
15 days ago

I recall Jonathan was a big believer in worldwide diversification. It was one area where I disagreed with him, not because of the diversification theory, but because of political and financial realities. A few things you mention fit that view. My view is based on three things. First, I do believe the US is still unique and will remain so for my lifetime at least. Second, I also believe that most countries lack the discipline and legal structures that encourage free enterprise, and the politicians there either slow progress by private companies or extort some of their value. Third, the rest of the world is not one market. It is hundreds of individual country markets that are often governed by facts that we in the US can’t always understand, or can’t address in a timely way to protect investors. It is hard enough to try to do that for the US market.

I’m not saying Jonathan was wrong. International performance went strongly his way in the last few years of his life. I just don’t feel comfortable with my money there.

Frank P
15 days ago

I do not recommend international funds for young investors. Your equity investments will grow for 60 years so you need to look at a long time horizon. My main objection to foreign stocks is demographics. Due to the disastrous demographics of most foreign countries, I don’t believe the future will look like the past. For example, South Korea’s population in 2025 is 51.7 million. Current projections estimate the population in 2060 to be 36.6 million and in 2100 15.6 million. South Korea is an extreme example but nearly all southeast Asian countries have low fertility rates.   The fertility rate is live births per woman. The breakeven rate is 2.1. Korea is .73, China is 1.01, Japan is 1.22.  Most European countries also have a low fertility rate. Germany is 1.45, Italy is 1.21, United Kingdom is 1.55, France is 1.64, Spain is 1.19. India is a bright spot with a fertility rate of  1.96. Unfortunately, India has its own problems with onerous regulations, different languages, a class structure, and religious hostility. Canada has a fertility rate of 1.24 but their immigration policy may result in a stable or even growing population. Mexico has an encouraging fertility rate of 1.89 but currently the Socialists have taken over all branches of government. The government recently confiscated an American company without any compensation. Most of Latin America has unpredictable governments and many have low fertility rates. Socialists can take control at any time. While there are some bright spots, I see far more problems. 

Grant Clifford
15 days ago

I am on the side of diversification from a risk management perspective. Now in my early 60’s, and having benefited from decades of bi-monthly deposits and compounding in my 401k, I find my risk tolerance is decreasing. My look forward retirement plan doesn’t need 10% returns to be successful, therefore optimizing returns is no longer my priority.

To that end I have US, international, emerging markets, growth, value, large cap and small cap stocks in various index funds, with specific allocations to each. Weighting is approximately 70% US vs 30% international.

When I look at events since the launch of ChatGPT in 2022 it is truly staggering to witness the innovation, how it has grown logarithmically and almost single handedly driven stock market growth since. Projected S&P 500 future earnings growth is now completely dominated by AI related companies.

My portfolio in turn has benefited as I own all the players, including the international chip manufacturers.

I also look at all this with a degree of suspicion. 300 +/- of the S&P 500 stocks are down year to date. Growth is increasingly being driven by a very narrow group, which is not necessarily unusual – Bessembinder research. But that grouping of top stocks in my mind are all interconnected – eggs in one basket. The amount of money being spent by the hyperscalers is mind boggling, as is the amount of borrowing, and it is difficult to figure out the circular trades and the sustainability of it all. As Warren Buffet said “you find out who is swimming naked when the tide goes out” or something to that effect.

I hope that my stock bond allocation and diversified equity portfolio, which deliberately dilutes the concentration of top S&P 500 companies, will hold up a little better should the tide go out. It still has significant exposure to all the S&P 500 names and will be not immune.

I am a firm believer that AI related companies will do fabulously well in the future. But I also believe there will be winners and losers, and it is the volatility associated with that I am hoping to temper with diversification which includes an international component.

Andy Morrison
7 days ago
Reply to  Grant Clifford

What is your equity/bond split?

Fund Daddy
15 days ago
Reply to  Grant Clifford

The only issue with your post is that its claims aren’t supported by evidence. There’s a good reason Buffett recommended the S&P 500, while Bogle advocated keeping things simple with just two stock index funds rather than holding multiple funds.
In retirement, risk-adjusted performance matters more than simply maximizing returns. And owning a variety of index funds doesn’t necessarily improve risk-adjusted returns.
In the last 15 years VTI made 6 times more than EEM, see the chart
https://schrts.co/IZMSKSkB
How long it will take EEM to catch VTI? maybe never

I’ve been posting on various sites for nearly 20 years, and I’ve seen countless people claim they made it their way. Sure, if you have a pension and/or a large enough portfolio, you can probably make almost any strategy work. But that doesn’t mean it was the most efficient approach or delivered the best risk-adjusted returns. There’s a big difference between making a strategy work and choosing the one that offers the best balance between returns and risk.

Last edited 15 days ago by Fund Daddy
Fund Daddy
16 days ago

I’m not against any category. Since I started in 1995, I have invested in what has worked in the last 3-6 in funds with great risk-adjusted in the last 1-3 years.
During 1995-2000 + after 2010: all in US funds tilting growth
During 01/2000-01/2010 (the lost decade): all in Value, small cap and international.

If you can’t decide, why not own 20% in GLOBAL allocation funds and let them play it. TIBIX is my first choice SGIIX is second. TIBIX also pays over 3% distributions which is a goal for some investors.
Again, investing isn’t all or none. You can combine 2 or more options.

Jeffrey Rapp
16 days ago

Most financial advisors are going to recommend international equity exposure. If they didn’t they’d be way off the bell-shaped curve. Whether you act on that or not is your own personal decision. For me, diversification is one of the few tools available to mitigate risks although one’s returns can sometimes suffer (or not). I try not to look back but prepare for going forward.

Steve Spinella
16 days ago

Wow, Bruce! You apparently stirred the nest. After reading the comments to date, I would say that international exposure is certainly the consensus view. I, like you, am a contrarian, sort of.
I have a direct index of companies and it does include several internationally domiciled ones–Shell, GSK, TSMC, SLB, which at about 4% each puts me right is the recommended zone for that portfolio, but otherwise I have no direct international exposure.
Having lived much of my life internationally, I know first hand how different markets, regulations, and management can be. In Taiwan, the saying is every business has three sets of books. Of course, I’m not sure things are that different in practice in the US in that regard. I also know how complicated it is to move money and assets across boundaries, especially on short notice.
What I ask myself, though, is how would my perspective change if I wasn’t based long-term in the US? I know that at the very least, with the dominance of US financial markets, those decisions would be harder and more perilous.

Mike in LA
16 days ago

If returns from major US companies with large overseas operations / sales correlated with returns of international companies, I’d agree with Bruce’s original premise. But they don’t. International stocks / funds vary in performance to US counterparts. Sometimes a little, sometimes a lot. The real question is how much diversification he wants in his portfolio. If currency issues or lack of familiarity with foreign companies dissuades international investment, it may affect overall performance – but it’s not too illogical.

Brent Wilson
16 days ago

People like the idea that US companies bringing in revenue from foreign markets mean they don’t need International investments. That’s simply not supported by any data.

Revenue vs. True Diversification

  • Geographic vs. Economic Exposure: While you technically gain exposure to foreign consumers and economies through overseas sales, research from Dimensional Fund Advisors shows that multinational U.S. stocks still move in sync with the U.S. market and domestic economic sentiment.
  • Lack of Diversification Benefit: Owning U.S. companies with global revenue does not replicate the risk-reduction or return-diversification benefits of owning actual foreign-domiciled stocks (which have different regulatory, currency, and sector dynamics).
Langston Holland
16 days ago

By far, the most important aspect of investment is asset allocation, not asset selection.

There are two factors to weigh; the math and your gut.

The math involves risk, return and when you need cash (your age). A young man may choose 100% stocks and a retired man less. A rich man can invest like a young man.

Jonathan once said that late in life we may wish we had invested entirely in stocks.

Your gut will not change the math, but it can overrule it. If your allocation causes you to sell during market downturns or crashes, you had too much in stocks no matter what the math says. The same applies to international stocks.

US stocks with heavy international presence does not equal international allocation. Foreign exchange rates and P/E are too diluted.

For asset selection, I prefer VTI over VOO for slightly increased small/mid cap US exposure, and VEU over VXUS for the reverse in my foreign exposure.

The math says about 20% foreign allocation is ideal, I’m closer to 15% because of my gut. Unlike the math, your gut may vary.

Your consultant is talking about math, good for him.

Fund Daddy
16 days ago

Sorry, the myth “the most important aspect of investment is asset allocation, not asset selection” must be challenged.
The idea that asset allocation is the single most important part of investing comes from a famous 1986 study by Gary Brinson, L. Randolph Hood, and Gilbert Beebower, which claimed that asset allocation accounts for more than 90% of a portfolio’s return variability over time. ]
However, calling asset allocation the “only” or absolute most important factor is considered a myth or an oversimplification for several key reasons:

Why the “90% Myth” Gets Questioned

  • Misinterpreting “Variability” vs. “Total Return”: The Brinson study did not say asset allocation generates 90% of your profits. It meant that roughly 90% of the ups and downs (volatility/variance) of a portfolio’s returns over time can be explained by whether you are in stocks, bonds, or cash—rather than which specific stock you picked.
  • The Power of Security and Manager Selection: Critics (such as active management research) argue that individual security selection—choosing great companies, managing active strategies, or finding “alpha”—is the true engine of outperformance and wealth generation relative to a benchmark. Owning a generic asset mix gives you market average returns, but picking the right underlying assets determines whether you beat or lag behind that average.
  • Narrow Spread Between Allocations: Backtests by analysts like Meb Faber have shown that the long-term performance gap between wildly different, complex asset allocation models is often quite small (sometimes under 2% per year), meaning tweaking your asset mix alone won’t save a flawed savings rate or poor vehicle selection.
  • Real-World Concentration and Risk: Asset allocation is essentially diversification. While it controls systemic risk and volatility, it does not protect you from a broad market crash, and focusing too blindly on macro-asset splits can cause investors to ignore the quality, fees, and fundamentals of what they actually hold. Remember 2022? both your bond and stock funds went down together.
  • Systemic Shifts: Modern market dynamics—such as synchronized global sell-offs, inflation shocks, and changing correlations between stocks and bonds—have exposed the limits of static asset allocation models like the classic 60/40 portfolio. BND, US bond index had a terrible 5-10-15 year performance, averaging under 2%.
Brent Wilson
15 days ago
Reply to  Fund Daddy

For an active (vs passive) investor, asset selection obviously is the most important. But clearly most of us on this forum are not active investors, and for good reason. To find alpha, you must possess an informational or analytical edge that nobody else has – a massive challenge in a hyper-connected world. You are effectively competing against multi-billion-dollar hedge funds, supercomputers, and insider networks.

You might try to solve this by investing in actively managed funds you think have the right tools and skillsets to find your alpha. While it is easy to look backward and find funds that generated massive alpha over the last three or five years, data shows that past performance does not predict future results because alpha lacks persistence.

According to the widely cited S&P Indices Versus Active (SPIVA) scorecards, which track the performance of active fund managers against their benchmarks:
• Over a 10-year horizon, roughly 85% to 90% of all large-cap active managers fail to beat the S&P 500.
• Over a 20-year horizon, that failure rate climbs closer to 95%.
• The Persistence Trap: Studies tracking top-quartile winning funds show that within a few years, those same “elite” funds routinely drop into the bottom quartiles. True skill is virtually indistinguishable from a temporary streak of good luck in a random distribution.

I will stick to my low-cost index funds and continue to believe that asset allocation is far more important than asset selection given my passive investing philosophy.

Boomerst3
16 days ago

This may help:
Relying solely on U.S. multinationals means you completely exclude dominant global industries and market leaders that happen to be headquartered outside the U.S.

  • Sector Sector Tilts: The U.S. market is heavily dominated by Technology and Growth companies. International indexes feature much higher concentrations of Industrials, Materials, and Financials, which act as a natural structural hedge.
  • Irreplaceable Foreign Leaders: You cannot gain exposure to industry titans like ASML (semiconductor equipment, Netherlands), TSMC (chip manufacturing, Taiwan), Nestlé (consumer goods, Switzerland), or Samsung (electronics, South Korea) simply by buying U.S. index funds.
Jo Bo
16 days ago

My modest (5-10%) international holdings are the only part of my stock portfolio in which I am reinvesting dividends. I like that international exposure hedges against dollar declines and provides some diversification. As for expenses, they are trivial: 0.035% for FSPXS in my taxable account and 0% for FZLIX in my IRA. As for tax hassles, they too are trivial with tax preparation software.

Rob Jennings
16 days ago

I dont find any of the points justifying the author’s position compelling and I might respectfully suggest such positions may have a hint of underlying home country and recency bias (which is not an original thought). As far as international funds having higher costs, that isn’t necessarily true and it ignores the larger point that international stocks are generally cheaper-the argument that US stocks offer international exposure is well-worn but it can turned on its head by mentioning that international stocks offer exposure to the US market-at a discount. International funds offer diversification and there have been times when they outperformed the US (early 2000s). As a retiree, I am less interested in performance and more in preservation and risk management-I believe exposure to international markets offer that. To each his own.

Michael1
18 days ago

Rather than debate the point, I would just note that practically all of the investing and personal finance experts I follow recommend some kind of international allocation. As I recall Jonathan Clements liked holding the global stock market as represented by Vanguard Total World Stock Index Fund ETF (VT) where international is well more than a third. Adam Grossman says for diversification purposes there’s not much point in holding more than 20 percent. But virtually all recommend some kind of international allocation. 

Edmund Marsh
16 days ago
Reply to  Michael1

It’s hard to examine any investment decision without reading and pondering what Jonthan had to say, isn’t it? Two articles:

https://humbledollar.com/money-guide/great-debates-how-much-abroad/

https://humbledollar.com/2024/11/stuck-at-home/

David Lancaster
17 days ago
Reply to  Michael1

Just looked up at Vanguard. International is 34.61%.

Dave Melick
18 days ago

We are currently at 15% international funds, and that is plenty for us. I don’t imagine letting it go much higher than that.

W.D. Housley
18 days ago

There’s an old investment saying: “Invest in what you know.”

One thing I think we sometimes overlook in the international investing debate is how difficult it can be for us as Americans to fully understand the business cultures, political systems, government policies, and economic realities of other nations. Those factors can profoundly affect how companies operate and how their shareholders fare.

Meanwhile, we have a much better understanding of the American business environment, its capital markets, its legal framework, and the forces that drive its leading companies. Many of those companies also earn substantial revenue worldwide.

I’m not suggesting we ignore international markets. But there’s a difference between diversifying intelligently and spreading our investments into markets whose risks and dynamics we may not fully understand.

Diversification is good—but it’s surprisingly easy to slip into de-worse-ification.

Boomerst3
16 days ago
Reply to  W.D. Housley

Historical Cycles (Decades of Leadership)

  • 1972–1982: International won (International returned 13.1% annually vs. U.S. at 6.7%) [1]
  • 1982–1992: International won (Driven by the Japanese market boom; International returned 23.1% annually vs. U.S. at 16.2%) [1, 2]
  • 1992–2002: U.S. won (Tech and dot-com acceleration; U.S. returned 9.3% annually vs. International at 5.6%) [1]
  • 2002–2012: International won (Post-dot-com crash and China/emerging market growth; International returned 8.7% annually vs. U.S. at 7.1%) [1, 2]
  • 2012–2024: U.S. won (Extended Bull Run) (Dominated by the “Magnificent Seven” mega-cap tech stocks, strong U.S. dollar, and rapid U.S. corporate earnings growth; U.S. returned ~14.6% annualized vs. International at ~6.2%) [1, 2]
  • 2024–2026 Shift: International recovering/outperforming (Foreign equities have experienced a multi-year cyclical rebound aided by a softer U.S. dollar, more attractive starting valuations, and higher dividend yields)
Jerry Pinkard
20 days ago

I agree Bruce. I am a longtime investor and currently own VEA, which is a broadly diversified ETF index of Euro countries. I have owned other mutual funds and ETFs focused on international markets. My experience and observation is that US markets are better performers and I agree with your logic of US based multi national companies.

Harold Tynes
20 days ago

Considering the Vanguard funds VT and VTI, I would suggest that you consider the concentration risk that now exists in the US Market. The top 10 stocks are 35% of the top 10 holdings.

Top 10 holdingsAS OF Sep-30-2026
34.67%
of 3527 total

Symbol
Company Name
Percentage
NVIDIA Corp
7.13%
AAPLApple Inc
6.63%
MSFTMicrosoft Corp
5.20%
AMZNAmazon.com Inc
3.30%
GOOGLAlphabet Inc Class A
2.76%
AVGOBroadcom Inc
2.28%
METAMeta Platforms Inc Class A
2.18%
GOOGAlphabet Inc Class C
2.18%
MUMicron Technology Inc
1.64%
TSLATesla Inc
1.37%

Expand your investment horizon to the world you have a more diverse portfolio that is not overwhelmed by the Big 7. Top 10 stocks are 22% of the holdings

Top 10 holdingsAS OF Sep-30-2026
22.45%
of 10242 total

Symbol
Company Name
Percentage
NVIDIA Corp
4.54%
AAPLApple Inc
4.11%
MSFTMicrosoft Corp
3.25%
AMZNAmazon.com Inc
2.06%
GOOGLAlphabet Inc Class A
1.73%
2330:TWTaiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co Ltd
1.62%
AVGOBroadcom Inc
1.39%
METAMeta Platforms Inc Class A
1.36%
GOOGAlphabet Inc Class C
1.36%
MUMicron Technology Inc
1.02%

V Saraf
21 days ago

For a long time I have followed the logic that major US companies in S&P derive significant revenues from their international operations.

But recently, I have started moving towards a still more diversified portfolio. Rather than VTI, based solely on US stocks, I have moved towards VT. Both are ETFs offered by Vanguard.

Yes, the wisdom here comes from JL Collins.

Don MacAllister
21 days ago

I use index funds because I like owning a diversified mix of good companies instead of trying to pick individual winners. By including an international fund in my portfolio, I own companies like Samsung, Nestle, Toyota, Canon, Roche, Mercedes, LG, Honda, Novartis, Shell, AstraZeneca, KIA, and Airbus, along with dozens of others. Will it move the needle on my total return? Probably not too much, but I like having these companies in my portfolio.

Mark Gardner
21 days ago

I think there is an important distinction between where a company earns its revenue and where its stock is priced. Owning US multinationals isn’t the same as owning international equities.

The stronger argument for international diversification is that concentrating in one country exposes us to uncompensated risk. By excluding international equities, we are effectively betting on continued US outperformance. Given today’s considerably higher US valuations, that seems an especially questionable bet.

Diversification isn’t about predicting which market will outperform. It’s about avoiding risks we don’t need to take. Why deliberately exclude a substantial portion of the world’s investable equity market when we can own it cheaply and easily?

David Lancaster
21 days ago
Reply to  Mark Gardner

“By excluding international equities, we are effectively betting on continued US outperformance.”

Also if you want a maximally diversified portfolio if you only hold US equities you are excluding 1/3 of the world’s companies.
As an example our equity holdings are 2/3 US, 1/3 international, and our largest holding is 2%, Apple. If it were to go completely belly up it’s effect on our portfolio would be no worse than a somewhat average bad day on Wall Street.

Last edited 21 days ago by David Lancaster
Mark Gardner
21 days ago
Reply to  Bruce Roberts

I actually agree with your intuition. Over sufficiently long periods, I would expect valuations to reflect underlying business fundamentals, regardless of where a company is listed.

But my comment is less about where we end up than how we get there. Two portfolios might deliver similar returns over 20 years while experiencing very different volatility and drawdowns along the way. That’s where diversification matters.

The 2000–2009 decade is a useful reminder.

William Perry
21 days ago

Jonathan penned an article titled “No Right Way” where part of his conclusion on asset allocation expresses his guidance better than I ever could.

“Every indexer makes judgment calls. Yes, there may be choices that are more sensible than others. But there’s no one index-fund portfolio strategy that’s right for everyone. Instead, the right portfolio is the one that works for you.”

So do I have a global market portfolio? No. While the majority of the equity portion of our portfolio is in Vanguard’s global ETF index I am overweight in the fixed portion and that part is heavy in TIPS structured in a rolling medium term ladder.

To a large extent I think our portfolio works for us and I think that was the goal Jonathan’s article was pointing each of us to. Good luck Bruce on finding your current asset allocation and I would add that you may also find time, experiences and circumstances may move you to change your portfolio allocations.

Last edited 21 days ago by William Perry
Mark Crothers
21 days ago

Worth looking at the 2000s. US companies had plenty of foreign sales then too, yet total returns for 2000-2009 were S&P 500 -9%, developed ex-US +12%, emerging markets +154%. Valuations and sector mix drive returns more than where the revenue comes from.

Dan Smith
21 days ago

I think Apple, Google and the other Mag 7 companies take up too much of the S&P500 real estate. Even though they have considerable foreign income, that didn’t prevent the short lived bloodbath suffered by the S&P in 2025. International investments kicked our butts during that period. 
Having said that, I don’t think your opinion is necessarily wrong, you just may have to live with extra volatility that greater diversification may prevent. 

Dan Smith
21 days ago
Reply to  Bruce Roberts

I understand, Bruce. The SP came roaring back once things settled down.

Free Newsletter

Arrives weekly.

Select list(s):
SHARE
HumbleDollar · https://humbledollar.com/forum/do-i-really-need-international-funds-in-my-portfolio-i-say-no/ · printed Nov 17, 2026

Create an account

Our readers find logging in to HumbleDollar directly more reliable than going through Google, Disqus, WordPress.com or X.

Already have an account? Don’t make a second one. Log in with the provider you use now, then go to Your Account to set up direct login.

We send a confirmation link here before the account can be used.
Shown beside your comments and forum posts.
Password(Required)
Strength indicator
Accepted file types: jpg, jpeg, png, webp, Max. file size: 5 MB.
Optional. Square images look best. JPG, PNG or WebP.
Optional. Appears on your author page.

Log in