John Urban spent his career in enterprise software. He co-founded GT Nexus, a supply-chain network acquired by Infor in 2015. When he retired, he ran into a gap: plenty of tools project your finances out over decades, but almost none help you decide what to actually do this year, with taxes in mind. He built RetireSmartIRA to close that gap, a retirement tax-planning app for people managing Roth conversions, RMDs, IRMAA, and the handful of thresholds that quietly decide how much of their savings they keep. The app and his free Roth conversion and RMD calculators are at: https://www.retiresmartira.com He lives in Northern California with his wife, Kathy. When he isn't modeling tax cliffs, he's usually spending time with old friends, reading, following Bay Area sports, or looking for a good bottle of wine.
EVERY JANUARY, if you own an IRA and money must come out of it that year, your custodian writes to you. The letter gives you the amount or offers to work it out. We barely read it, but it is doing more than we notice.
Most people never miss a required distribution, and the reason is not diligence. It is that somebody tells them.
Inherited IRAs are different. The IRS notice that creates the requirement says reporting is not required for the IRAs of deceased owners,
WHEN A HUSBAND dies, his widow inherits his IRA. Somewhere in the paperwork of the months that follow there is a decision to make, and nobody presents it to her as one. She can take the account as her own, or she can leave it titled as inherited.
Taking it as her own means filling something in. Leaving it means doing nothing, and the IRS tells custodians they may assume that is what she wants.
EVERY ARTICLE ABOUT Roth conversions says the same thing: pay the tax from taxable money, not from the IRA.
That is good advice if you have taxable money.
Plenty of retirees do not. Their savings sit almost entirely in a traditional IRA, built from years of 401(k) contributions and a rollover at retirement, with little brokerage money and no cash reserve worth naming.
For them, “pay from outside money” is not advice. It is a condition they do not meet.
THE WIDOW TAX is sold to the wrong households. It gets pitched to affluent couples as the reason to convert to a Roth or buy life insurance. The pitch says that when one spouse dies, the survivor files single, lands in a higher bracket, and gets clobbered. I ran the numbers for three couples at three incomes, and at the comfortable end the widow tax often costs nothing, or even less than nothing.
The real cost lands lower down,
IF YOU’RE IN YOUR early 60s and retired, you probably have a lot of financial questions on your mind. The next few years may be among your lowest-income and lowest-tax-paying years. Your salary and bonus years are behind you. Social Security and required minimum distributions from your IRAs and 401(k)s have not started yet. You are hearing advice about doing Roth conversions during this low-tax window, and the arguments are compelling. You may also be thinking about consulting or part-time work to stay active and bring in some income.

Comments
Good point, and it’s one I didn’t make in the piece. If the account an heir inherits is a Roth, there are no annual distributions to miss in years one through nine, and what does come out is generally tax-free, so the catch-up tax and Medicare surcharge in the article don’t arise. The account still has to be emptied by the end of year ten, so there’s one deadline to remember instead of ten. A surviving spouse can get there too, but only after treating the account as her own; an inherited IRA can’t be converted. Whether converting makes sense is still about the tax you pay now against what your heirs would pay later, but it’s a fair point to add to the list.
Post: Inherited IRA Trap
Link to comment from October 26, 2026
Larry, I can understand your frustration, especially after talking with the attorney, CPA, and even the IRS without getting a clear answer. I think there are two separate issues here. The RMD for the year your mother-in-law died should be relatively straightforward. It’s based on what she was required to take that year, less anything she’d already withdrawn. If you took more than her RMD that year, you’re likely covered for that piece. The more complicated question is what happens in subsequent years because the IRA was left to a trust. A key question for the trust attorney is whether it qualifies as what’s called a “see-through” trust under the IRS rules. That, along with the trust’s beneficiaries and provisions, helps determine which RMD rules apply. I’d also ask whether IRA distributions can be passed through to the individual beneficiaries rather than taxed inside the trust, and whether the IRA can eventually be transferred into separate inherited IRAs when the trust terminates. Neither is something you should assume without reviewing the trust. Given the amount involved, I think it’s worth finding a CPA or estate attorney who specializes in inherited IRAs held by trusts. This is complicated enough that I’d want someone who deals with these rules regularly rather than guessing at the right answer.
Post: Inherited IRA Trap
Link to comment from October 26, 2026
Disclosure first: I built RetireSmartIRA, so weigh this accordingly. Its Multi-Year Plan does what you describe: it lays out each year’s conversion, the tax on it, where that tax is paid from, and the resulting IRA, Roth and taxable balances, next to a version with no conversions. It runs on iPhone, iPad and Mac and is free. If you just want a quick look at one year’s conversion first, there’s a free calculator on retiresmartira.com that runs in the browser with no download. Whichever tool you use, Randy’s point stands: the conversion itself isn’t the cash flow, the tax payment is, so check how each tool assumes that tax gets paid.
Post: Roth conversion cash flow
Link to comment from October 26, 2026
Great article and discussion... Thanks!
Post: Exit Strategy
Link to comment from October 26, 2026
Thanks for the kind words Bill!
Post: Inherited IRA Trap
Link to comment from October 24, 2026
Dan, Thank you, It makes me feel great that you did all that!!!
Post: Inherited IRA Trap
Link to comment from October 24, 2026
Bill, automation is a good safeguard, with one thing to check for an inherited account: make sure the automatic amount is figured on the beneficiary schedule, not the owner’s table. They are different, and the beneficiary amount is usually larger. Your point about year 10 is the other half, and spreading extra withdrawals over the earlier years is often cheaper than one large final distribution.
Post: Inherited IRA Trap
Link to comment from October 24, 2026
Bill, thank you, both for this and for the comment that started the piece. Your point about the 5498 is a good one, and the timing makes it worse than useless as a reminder: it can arrive in May of the year after the distribution was due, when the shortfall already exists. And an electronic form sent to an account the beneficiary rarely logs into is easy to miss entirely. The professional fees for amending several years are a cost I left out of the $47,700, and they could be significant.
Post: Inherited IRA Trap
Link to comment from October 24, 2026
John, Thanks for your comment and I agree. For most widows her age taking the account as her own is the cleaner path: her own schedule, a smaller required amount, and the custodian’s annual reminder. As I wrote about that choice in “Widow’s IRA Choice,” two cases point the other way:
- a widow under 59½ who needs the money, since an inherited IRA has no early-withdrawal penalty, and
- one whose husband was younger and died before his own distributions had to start, where staying a beneficiary can let her wait. In this article the trouble was that she never made the choice at all.
Post: Inherited IRA Trap
Link to comment from October 24, 2026
Nice article. Thanks for writing it!
Post: Going Naked
Link to comment from October 24, 2026