IT’S BEEN AN UNUSUAL week in the bond market, and not necessarily in a good way. This has many investors questioning the value of bonds, which is understandable. Bonds are supposed to be the “safe” side of a portfolio, but they’ve struggled in recent years.
Arguably, the drama we’re seeing in the bond market today began more than 50 years ago. To put today’s situation in perspective, I’ll briefly summarize that long history. Then we can look at what steps you might take to better protect your portfolio from here.
Back in the 1970s, as you’re probably aware, inflation rose above 10%. Policymakers struggled for years to bring it under control, but in the early 1980s a Fed chair named Paul Volcker finally succeeded. He accomplished that by raising the Fed’s benchmark rate to nearly 20%. With this step, Volcker succeeded in calming inflation, and that allowed the Fed to begin lowering rates, a gradual process that continued for most of the following 40 years.
Because bond prices move inversely to interest rates, that entire stretch was extremely beneficial for bonds. As rates fell, bonds rose. Between 1980 and 2020, intermediate-term U.S. government bonds returned 7% per year, on average. That multi-decade run helped seal the reputation of bonds as an easy and reliable way to offset the risk of stocks.
But then the other shoe dropped. Due to pandemic-related government spending and tangled supply chains, inflation began rising around 2021. Well aware of what the economy experienced in the 1970s, the Fed responded by raising rates aggressively. For a time, that appeared to bring inflation under control, and the government had even started to lower rates again last year. But then the war with Iran started. That caused energy prices to jump higher, and that, worryingly, has caused inflation to start creeping back up again.
In response, the Fed this week was forced to take action, raising rates in an effort to contain inflation before it gains steam. Interest rates on long-term bonds are now at 20-year highs. And because bond prices move inversely to interest rates, bonds are having another difficult year. Total-bond market funds like Vanguard’s BND are now negative year-to-date.
Where the bond market goes from here is anyone’s guess, but this history is important, in my view, because bonds are unlikely to see another long, positive stretch like the one investors enjoyed a generation ago. Instead, I believe investors need to be more cautious.
What steps might you take? Since we don’t know whether rates will go higher or lower over any given timeframe, the approach I recommend is to own bonds in each of several categories. That way, you’ll benefit, in part, if rates go up, and you’ll benefit, in part, if rates go down. Here’s how I’d structure a bond portfolio today:
For me, the most important thing is to own mostly short-term bonds. Specifically, you might allocate 60% of your bond portfolio to short-term Treasurys, using a fund like Vanguard’s VGSH. This fund should be among the most stable investments available because it’s backed by the U.S. government, which, for better or worse, has the ability to print money to meet its obligations. And its short duration means that, all things being equal, it will be less susceptible to rising interest rates if rates do continue to rise. As a point of reference, in 2022, when rates rose quickly, this fund lost less than 4% of its value. That’s in contrast to total-bond market funds, which lost an extremely unpleasant 13% that year.
If you’re in a high tax bracket (over 30%), you could split your short-term holdings between Treasurys, which are taxable at the federal level, and municipal bonds, which are exempt from federal tax. You might consider a short-term municipal fund like Vanguard’s VTES or VWSUX.
Next, I’d allocate 20% to intermediate-term bonds. While these will be more susceptible to losses when rates rise, they’ll also gain more when rates fall. Last year, for example, when rates fell, intermediate-term government bond funds like Vanguard’s VGIT gained more than 7%. So I see them as worth the additional risk.
That said, if this risk concerns you, there’s a relatively easy alternative: For this part of your portfolio, you could purchase a ladder of individual bonds covering maturities between five and 10 years. While it requires additional effort to purchase individual bonds, what you’ll receive in return is greater certainty. At the moment that you purchase an individual bond, you’ll know the yield to maturity. Barring a default—which is unlikely with a government bond—that’s precisely the return you will earn.
For the final 20% of a bond portfolio, I recommend inflation-protected Treasury bonds, known as TIPS. Here again, you could purchase individual bonds or a bond fund, and there’s a lot of debate on this topic. But according to research I find convincing, the best way to protect against inflation is with short-term TIPS. So to keep things simple, I would opt for a fund rather than a ladder of individual bonds, which would require frequent trading. One good fund in this category is Vanguard’s VTIP.
At the end of the day, the most important thing, in my view, is to build a bond portfolio that’s diversified enough that you could reliably draw on it in years when stocks are down. And recognizing that even short-term bonds carry some amount of risk, it’s worth also holding a “floor” of cash, using a government money market fund, as an additional element in your portfolio. These won’t gain in value when interest rates fall, but they’re designed not to lose any value if rates rise.
Put it all together, and I see this as an effective sleep-at-night structure no matter where things go next.
Adam M. Grossman is the founder of Mayport, a fixed-fee wealth management firm. Sign up for Adam’s Daily Ideas email, follow him on X @AdamMGrossman and check out his earlier articles.
I thought the advice was to stay away from bond funds when rates are going up.
I follow this good advice for the fixed income portion of my portfolio but with equal allocations to short-term (1/3), intermediate-term (1/3), and inflation-protected (1/3).
Milton Friedman famously argued that inflation is “always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon”—too much money chasing too few goods and services. I don’t see evidence of a comparable surge in money supply today.
My hypothesis is that much of the recent uptick in inflation reflects an energy-price shock driven by geopolitical conflict, compounded by enormous demand for capital from AI hyperscalers. I expect at least some of those pressures eventually to subside.
Kevin Warsh and the Fed cannot end wars by fiddling with overnight rates.
So I’ve gone somewhat against the grain here. Rather than avoiding duration, I’ve taken a position in long-term TIPS at a 3+% real yield. My thesis is that as the inflation shock subsides, long-term real yields will eventually retreat from today’s unusually high levels, giving me some capital appreciation from the duration.
If I’m wrong about the timing, I’m still holding a Treasury security yielding more than 3% above inflation.
If real yields keep climbing, however, there could be considerable mark-to-market pain along the way.
Am I catching a falling knife? Time will tell.
I liked Jonathan’s philosophy that you should have enough liquid assets and guaranteed income to cover your next 5 years spending, especially if you are retired. I lean towards at least 3 years but the concept is the same. I like SPAXX and FAGIX for my liquid assets, SPAXX is a good MM fund and FAGIX has a really good long-term record as kind of a hybrid stock/bond fund, it does fluctuate some(+/- 10%) but it has been run by the same guy for 20 years.
SPAXX is at 3.46%, and SPRXX is at 3.53% as of 9/26. I’ll take it. Set it and forget it.
I’d say SPAXX is the least good money market fund at Fidelity, so check out the alternatives. If you have the minimum, FZDXX is good.
I keep it simple as a retired 63 year old. My stocks are risky with a heavy lean into large cap Technology, so I can’t have high risk in my bond allocation.
73% stocks – USA lean and around 20% International
2 years of CDs for income
1 year income in ishares ICSH ultra short term bonds
4 years of income in ishares defined maturity TIPs. 4 separate ETFs.
3 years of income in 2031 T note at 4.5%.
A question I have:
In the recent market decline, bonds declined along with stocks. What makes us think bonds will provide stability the next time stocks have a significant decline?
If inflation, rising rates, and concerns about U.S. debt can cause both stocks and bonds to fall, I’m not sure we can assume bonds will always be the safe counterbalance to stocks.
What say you?
My thoughts as well
Excellent post, and great advice from commenters, as well. I have a Schwab retirement account and love many of Vanguard’s investment funds— but buy the ETF equivalent to avoid trading fees by Schwab for Vanguard mutual funds. Example: I own VCRB, the Vanguard Core Bond ETF.
Again, great post and advice!
Bonds are where I’ve made all my money since retirement.
Most people think of bonds as their safety net. But over the last 5, 10, and 15 years, BND (the Vanguard total bond index) returned -0.5%, 1.3%, and 1.8% annually. You could have done a lot better.
Actually, BND didn’t beat inflation. See https://schrts.co/ytfajysu
My thinking changed in 2010, when I bought my first unconventional fund, PIMIX, and I never looked back. I realized there are funds and managers who can make good money with much lower volatility, which is just another way of saying a better Sharpe ratio. Add a basic understanding of how markets behave, and my system was born.
It’s no secret that rising rates demolish bond funds. So when inflation was running hot in early 2022 and Fed officials were openly saying they would raise rates, why were you still holding bond funds? It was the easiest time in years to be out of everything — and that’s exactly what I did.
The same logic applies elsewhere. Oil runs through the whole economy, from manufacturing to shipping, so when oil prices rise, inflation follows. When the Iran conflict began, wasn’t it obvious oil would go up? Oil up, inflation up, rates up, bond funds down.
Bogle and Buffett both preached owning just two or three funds. Buffett called diversification “protection against ignorance.” I’ve followed that approach but have used unique bond funds.
How it played out:
The point isn’t the specific funds. It’s that flexibility and looking at the big picture beat holding a bond index and calling it safety.
Excellent article, but I have completely ditched bonds, and favor of the Warren Buffett, 90% S&P 500 and 10% treasuries. I made my own more like 85% S&P (mine include some other equities) and 15% cash to tide over the down years.
The 90/10 allocation for someone worth hundreds of millions makes sense, especially for one who is elderly, but it does not scale downwards for the majority of us. He once referred to bonds as “return free risk”. Influenced by his analysis, but adapting it to suit my case, my bond allocation is a mix of government money market fund, and individual Treasurys and TIPS which will mature in the next 1-5 years. I think in terms of years worth of future withdrawals rather than raw percentages, and prefer to hold a minimum of 10 years worth. Today with a 3% burn rate, my Stock/Bond allocation of 55/45 includes 15 years worth. If future stock valuations come down to more reasonable levels, I could see moving towards 70/30 but no higher. This will probably underperform better plans, but as they say, the best plan for you is the one you will stick with. And I can sleep well with this approach.
…and, you’ve probably had great performance over time. The issue becomes: what happens in a severe downturn? If you are comfortable with the risk and have the means of living through a 30-40% (or more) market decline, great. However, this ability often takes both greater investment sophistication and more money than most investors possess. That doesn’t make the strategy is wrong, but Caveat Emptor does apply.
Thanks Adam. Would you include guaranteed income in the bond allocation, and if so, how? Perhaps count an annuity or pension without COLA as short term bond, and SS or any other annuity/ pension with COLA as short term TIPS?
I buy MYGA’s for most of my bond allocation. Can get 6.1% on a 3 yr MYGA now from Canvas Annuity direct buy option. No drop in price drama like a bond fund. I consider a Buffer ETF like SMAX my other “bond” allocation with 100% downside protection from market.
Great and timely article, Adam. Thank you! The timing is good for me because I’m in the midst of a rebalancing of my portfolio as we come up on your end.
I’m looking at taking some capital gains off the table and reinvesting in either the same positions or otherwise shifting my asset allocation.
One of the things I am just getting started with is rotating out of some of the bond ETF positions I’m holding and moving into REITs via VNQ.
Any thoughts on using alternatives like REITs as a hedge against equity and bond market volatility?
I like SPAXX @3.36% and SPRXX at 3.39%.
Adam – thank you for a thoughtful article. I find it interesting that there is an increased environment now for manipulating bond holdings. Common wisdom for stocks is to hold for long term, riding cycles using a total market fund (like VTI, VTSAX) without concern for short term volatility. Likewise, a general bond fund (like BND, VBLTX) has similar merits. It now seems that “swinging for the fences” also includes tweaking bonds. In the long run, we may find that, for the average investor, staying put during bond volatility is the best course of action.
I’ve come to agree that limiting my bond allocation to short-term bonds is best for me. They’re much more stable and predictable than longer duration bonds, which is exactly what I want.
But there are still so many choices for how to invest in bonds. A mix of various duration ETF’s, individual bonds, TIPS ladders, etc. It just feels rather cumbersome and tiring to think about. I want something that’s easy to manage while maintaining full liquidity. This second point – liquidity – is especially important to me, because it allows me to draw upon a larger amount than I otherwise would over some bond investing strategies, and not just for one-off expenses, but for opportunities to buy large quantities of stocks during severe market downturns.
To that end, I’ve moved all of my fixed-income allocation to iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF (SGOV). I get that something like a mix of short-term treasury, intermediate-term treasury, and short-term TIPS index funds (as Adam suggests) *could* offer a better long-term return. But looking at the past several years, SGOV actually holds up quite well compared to these funds and was positive during the bondpocalypse of 2022.
Perhaps I will revisit this “ultra short” bond strategy in the future, but for now it seems right for me. Regardless of where you fall on how to invest in bonds, I think the bigger picture is important to keep in focus. If you have an aggressive allocation to stocks, this will be the most significant driver of your portfolio’s return, and having the “best” bond strategy will have only a minimal impact.
Google AI says: “Bill Bengen, the creator of the 4% retirement withdrawal rule, famously concluded that money market funds can completely replace bonds and other fixed-income investments in a retiree’s portfolio without harming their safe withdrawal.”
Free Newsletter
Arrives weekly.