FREE NEWSLETTER

When is renting a home a good idea?

Go to main Voices page »

Subscribe
Notify of
4 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Matt White
Matt White
1 month ago

I wouldn’t get in a hurry to buy a house until I became familiar with the community and neighborhood and gained some clarity that I wanted to settle there for at least a few years. I think of moving as difficult, disruptive, and expensive. All of that ramps up even more when moving out of a home you own, so I don’t want to buy a home unless I plan to stay a while.

Greg Spears
Greg Spears
1 month ago

The transaction costs of buying or selling a home are quite high. For that reason, I’ve been told not to buy unless you could reasonably foresee living there for seven years.

We rented homes in Florida, for example, because we were just passing though. We lived in three places inside of five years.

We bought our first house in Takoma Park, Maryland because we wanted to live there for years and raise our family there.

Rick Connor
Rick Connor
1 month ago

My older brother moved to Baton Rouge, LA in the mid-80s. The local economy was heavy dependent on the oil business, which was depressed at the time. There were numerous news townhome communities with lots of vacancies. He lived there for 4 years, and was able to rent a nice townhouse for the time he was there. With lots of vacancies, and no real desire to pack up and move, he was able to negotiate a lower rent several times.

A few of his coworkers saw the opportunity to purchase homes at low prices. It was a buyers market, so they bought with 0 down. Unfortunately, house prices kept going down locally and several people ended up underwater when they chose to move for career reasons.

I saw a similar phenomena in the Washington DC area in the wake of the 2007 crisis. Nice suburban single and townhomes sold for way under the previous high purchase prices, and less than the mortgage owed.

If you are a transient to an area, perhaps moving somewhere for a few years as a career step, it may be wise to consider if it makes sense to invest in a home. This is especially true if you are younger, and moving to an area with lots of variation in home prices. I spent a lot of my career traveling to the Silicon Valley region. Home prices there tended to swing much greater than the east coast where I lived. If you caught it at the bottom you could make out well.

Kristine Hayes
Kristine Hayes
1 month ago

I chose to be a renter following my divorce. I was 45 years old and hadn’t lived on my own for over two decades. I didn’t have a clear picture of how my finances would hold up on a single income. I didn’t want to buy a home only to find out I couldn’t afford it.

Because I chose to live in a moderately priced apartment, I ended up having more than enough money to cover all of my living expenses. I began contributing increasingly larger sums of money to my retirement accounts. After living as a renter for six years, I was able to afford the purchase of a small ‘starter’ home which I sold just four years later for a large profit.

Those six years as a renter allowed me to get a solid financial foundation built.

Free Newsletter

SHARE